2.1 Fundamental Principles of Local Taxation under RA 7160

2.1 Fundamental Principles of Local Taxation under RA 7160

Quick Answer: Local taxation in the Philippines is an autonomous power directly conferred by Article X, Section 5 of the 1987 Constitution and regulated by Book II of Republic Act No. 7160 (the Local Government Code of 1991). Under Section 130, local taxes must be uniform, equitable, based on the taxpayer's ability to pay, levied solely for public purposes, not confiscatory or oppressive, and never contrary to national policy. Local tax collection cannot be privatized or let to any private entity, and local tax measures are strictly construed against the local government and liberally in favor of the taxpayer.

---

Constitutional Foundation of Local Taxing Power

Historically, under the 1935 Constitution and Commonwealth Act No. 470 (Assessment Law), local government units (LGUs) possessed no inherent or autonomous power to tax. Local governments were treated as mere administrative subdivisions of the central government, exercising only such taxing authority as Congress chose to expressly delegate. While the 1973 Constitution recognized local fiscal powers in principle, it remained highly centralized under presidential decree.

The 1987 Philippine Constitution revolutionized this paradigm by establishing genuine local autonomy. Article X, Section 5 directly provides:

"Each local government unit shall have the power to create its own sources of revenues and to levy taxes, fees, and charges subject to such guidelines and limitations as the Congress may provide, consistent with the basic policy of local autonomy. Such taxes, fees, and charges shall accrue exclusively to the local governments."

This constitutional grant elevates local taxing authority from a purely delegated legislative favor into a direct constitutional power. However, this power is not absolute. As the Supreme Court held in Pelizloy Realty Corporation v. Province of Benguet (G.R. No. 183137), local taxing power remains subject to the guidelines and limitations enacted by Congress in Republic Act No. 7160, known as the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC). When an LGU exercises its taxing authority, it must strictly operate within the boundaries established in Book II of RA 7160.

---

The Fundamental Principles of Section 130

Section 130 of RA 7160 serves as the statutory bedrock of local treasury operations. It establishes seven explicit mandatory principles that govern every local tax ordinance, fee imposition, and revenue measure passed by local legislative councils (Sanggunian):

1. Uniformity in Each Local Government Unit (Sec. 130(a))

Taxation shall be uniform in each local government unit. Uniformity does not mean that every person or commodity must be taxed at the exact same peso amount. Rather, uniformity requires that all taxable subjects or objects belonging to the same class shall be treated alike, both in privileges conferred and liabilities imposed.

In the landmark ruling Ormoc Sugar Company, Inc. v. Treasurer of Ormoc City (22 SCRA 603), the Supreme Court established the four indispensable requisites of a valid classification in taxation:

1. Substantial Distinctions: The classification must rest upon substantial distinctions that make real differences.
2. Germane to the Purpose: It must be germane to the purpose of the law or revenue measure.
3. Not Limited to Existing Conditions: It must not be limited to existing conditions only, but must apply equally to future conditions substantially identical.
4. Equal Application to the Same Class: It must apply equally to all members of the same class.

In Ormoc Sugar, the municipal board enacted an ordinance taxing centrifugal sugar produced specifically by "Ormoc Sugar Company, Inc." naming the corporation directly. The Supreme Court invalidated the tax because it singled out one entity by name, failing the third and fourth requisites. Even if only one sugar central existed in the city at that moment, an ordinance must be drafted in generic terms to cover any future sugar mill that might operate within the jurisdiction.

2. Equitable and Based on Ability to Pay (Sec. 130(b)(1))

Local taxes, fees, and charges must be equitable and based, as far as practicable, on the taxpayer's ability to pay. This principle operationalizes the constitutional mandate that Congress—and by extension LGUs—shall evolve a progressive system of taxation (Sec. 130(e)). In local finance, this is manifested in graduated business tax schedules (Section 143), where higher gross receipts or higher taxable capacities bear a proportionally greater fiscal responsibility, rather than regressive flat rates that unduly burden small micro-enterprises.

3. Levied and Collected Only for Public Purposes (Sec. 130(b)(2))

Public purpose is an inherent limitation on all taxation. Local revenues cannot be levied for private enrichment, sectarian institutions, or purely private benefit (Pascual v. Secretary of Public Works, 110 Phil. 331). Every centavo collected by the local treasury must be appropriated for the general welfare, public infrastructure, basic social services, or governmental operations of the levying LGU.

Revenue Generation vs. Regulatory Purpose

A frequent BCLTE exam concept is the legal distinction between the taxing power and the police power:

• Taxes: Primary purpose is revenue generation to support general government expenditures. The amount is determined by the financial needs of the LGU and statutory ceilings.
• Regulatory Fees and Service Charges: Primary purpose is regulation, surveillance, and licensing under police power (e.g., Mayor's Permit fees, sanitary inspection fees). Under Section 147, regulatory fees must be commensurate with the actual cost of regulation, inspection, and administrative surveillance. If a regulatory fee is so exorbitant that it bears no reasonable relation to administrative costs and generates massive surplus revenues, it constitutes an unauthorized, disguised tax.

4. Not Unjust, Excessive, Oppressive, or Confiscatory (Sec. 130(b)(3))

An imposition that confiscates property or drives lawful commercial enterprises out of business violates the Due Process Clause of the Constitution. In City of Baguio v. De Leon (25 SCRA 938), the Court reiterated that while legislative bodies enjoy broad discretion in setting rates, local taxes become void when they are manifestly oppressive, arbitrary, or amount to an indirect expropriation of private property without just compensation.

5. Not Contrary to Law, Public Policy, National Economic Policy, or in Restraint of Trade (Sec. 130(b)(4))

Local governments cannot establish fiscal walls or trade barriers. Ordinances that attempt to penalize foreign goods, restrict interstate commerce, or contradict national economic programs (such as incentives granted by national investment laws) are ultra vires and void.

6. Prohibition on Delegating or Farming Out Collection (Sec. 130(c))

Section 130(c) states unequivocally: "The collection of local taxes, fees, charges and other impositions shall in no case be let to any private person."

This is a strict civil service rule. Revenue collection is a sovereign executive function. An LGU cannot hire private collection agencies, contract private debt collectors, or outsource tax collection to private individuals, even on a contingent commission basis. All collections must be performed directly by the Local Treasurer, officially designated assistant treasurers, bonded treasury collection officers, or authorized government depository banks (AGDBs) accredited under Department of Finance (DOF) regulations.

7. Exclusive Inurement to the Levying LGU (Sec. 130(d))

Revenues collected pursuant to the provisions of the Local Government Code shall inure solely to the benefit of, and be subject to disposition by, the LGU levying the tax, fee, or charge, unless otherwise specifically provided by law. The national government cannot seize, withhold, or redirect local tax revenues to other government agencies or neighboring jurisdictions.

---

Rules of Statutory Interpretation under RA 7160

Section 5 of RA 7160 provides strict rules of interpretation that local treasury officers must apply during tax assessments and disputes:

---

Distribution of Taxing Powers Across LGU Tiers

To prevent conflicting jurisdictions, the Local Government Code distributes specific taxing powers among provinces, municipalities, cities, and barangays. Cities enjoy a unique status, combining the taxing powers of both provinces and municipalities.