7.1 Natural Gas & Propane Combustion Fundamentals

Natural Gas & Propane Combustion Fundamentals

Quick Reference: Combustion is a rapid, exothermic chemical reaction between hydrocarbon fuel and oxygen. Natural gas (methane, $\text{CH}_4$) has a specific gravity of $0.60$ (lighter than air) and a higher heating value of $1,000 - 1,050\text{ BTU/cu ft}$. Propane ($\text{C}_3\text{H}_8$) has a specific gravity of $1.52$ (heavier than air) and a heating value of $2,500\text{ BTU/cu ft}$. Complete combustion requires $10\text{ cu ft}$ of air per cubic foot of natural gas and $24 - 25\text{ cu ft}$ of air per cubic foot of propane, plus $20\% - 50\%$ excess air to prevent toxic carbon monoxide ($\text{CO}$) production.

---

1. Fuel Gas Physical Properties & Combustion Chemistry

Understanding the physical and thermodynamic differences between Natural Gas (Methane) and Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LP / Propane) is foundational for equipment selection, burner orifice sizing, manifold pressure setting, and field safety.

Stoichiometric Chemical Reactions

Stoichiometric (perfect) combustion represents the exact theoretical proportion of fuel and pure oxygen where all carbon converts to carbon dioxide ($\text{CO}_2$) and all hydrogen converts to water vapor ($\text{H}_2\text{O}$), releasing maximum heat without unburned fuel or excess oxygen.

Natural Gas (Methane) Perfect Combustion Reaction:

$$\text{CH}_4 + 2\text{O}_2 \longrightarrow \text{CO}_2 + 2\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Heat (approx. } 1,050\text{ BTU)}$$

Because atmospheric air consists of approximately $20.9\%$ oxygen and $79.1\%$ nitrogen by volume, every $1\text{ cu ft}$ of $\text{O}_2$ brings $3.78\text{ cu ft}$ of inert nitrogen ($\text{N}_2$). Therefore, $2\text{ cu ft}$ of pure $\text{O}_2$ requires $2 / 0.209 = 9.57\text{ cu ft}$ of atmospheric air (nominally $10\text{ cu ft}$).

$$\text{CH}_4 + 2\text{O}_2 + 7.56\text{N}_2 \longrightarrow \text{CO}_2 + 2\text{H}_2\text{O} + 7.56\text{N}_2 + \text{Heat}$$

Propane Perfect Combustion Reaction:

$$\text{C}_3\text{H}_8 + 5\text{O}_2 \longrightarrow 3\text{CO}_2 + 4\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Heat (approx. } 2,500\text{ BTU)}$$

*Accounting for atmospheric nitrogen ($5\text{ cu ft } \text{O}_2 \times 4.78 = 23.9\text{ cu ft air}$):

$$\text{C}_3\text{H}_8 + 5\text{O}_2 + 18.9\text{N}_2 \longrightarrow 3\text{CO}_2 + 4\text{H}_2\text{O} + 18.9\text{N}_2 + \text{Heat}$$

---

2. Classification of Combustion Air

In actual gas heating appliances, gas and air do not mix with molecular perfection. To guarantee complete combustion and avoid lethal carbon monoxide formation, appliances require multiple air stages and excess air:

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                               TOTAL AIR SUPPLIED TO APPLIANCE                           |
|                                                                                         |
| +--------------------------------------+ +--------------------------------------------+ |
| |        COMBUSTION AIR (15 cu ft)     | |             DILUTION AIR (Category I)      | |
| |                                      | |                                            | |
| | +----------------+ +---------------+ | | (Drawn into draft hood/diverter to cool    | |
| | | PRIMARY AIR    | | SECONDARY AIR | | |  flue gases, stabilize chimney draft,      | |
| | | (30% - 50%     | | (50% - 70%    | | |  and isolate burner from downdrafts)       | |
| | | mixed in       | | drawn around  | | |                                            | |
| | | burner venturi)| | flame base)   | | |                                            | |
| | +----------------+ +---------------+ | |                                            | |
| | +----------------------------------+ | |                                            | |
| | | EXCESS AIR (20% - 50% safety)    | | |                                            | |
| | +----------------------------------+ | |                                            | |
| +--------------------------------------+ +--------------------------------------------+ |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

1. Primary Air: Introduced into the burner body upstream of the ignition point via the gas orifice and venturi mixer tube. The velocity of the high-pressure gas jet exiting the spud orifice draws primary air into the burner via the Bernoulli/venturi effect, providing $30\%$ to $50\%$ of the air required for complete combustion.
2. Secondary Air: Atmospheric air supplied directly to the combustion chamber surrounding the burner flames. It diffuses into the outer flame envelope to complete the combustion reaction initiated by the primary air-fuel mixture.
3. Excess Air: Air supplied to the combustion chamber beyond the stoichiometric theoretical requirement ($20\%$ to $50\%$ excess air, typically raising total combustion air to $12 - 15\text{ cu ft}$ per cubic foot of natural gas). Excess air ensures complete fuel consumption despite minor variations in gas pressure, air humidity, and burner fouling.
4. Dilution Air: Ambient air drawn into the draft hood or draft diverter of Category I atmospheric gas appliances. Dilution air mixes with hot combustion gases downstream of the heat exchanger to cool the stack temperature, reduce flue dew point, and maintain consistent chimney draft.

---

3. Flame Chemistry, Appearance & Abnormalities

Visual inspection of the burner flame is a vital diagnostic procedure for identifying combustion imbalances, improper air shutter adjustment, over-firing, or cracked heat exchangers.

           CORRECT FLAME                            YELLOW TIPPING / INCOMPLETE                   LIFTING FLAME
        (Blue, Sharp Cones)                             (Lack of Primary Air)                (Excess Velocity / Pressure)
             /\                                              /\                                       /\ 
            /  \  <-- Outer Envelope (Dark Blue)            /  \  <-- Soft Yellow Tip (Soot/CO)      /  \  <-- Flame lifts
           / /\ \                                          / /\ \                                   / /\ \     off burner port
          / /  \ \                                        / /  \ \                                 / /  \ \    (Flame roar)
         / /____\ \ <-- Inner Cone (Light Blue)          / /____\ \                               / /____\ \ 
        +----------+                                    +----------+                             ~~~~~~~~~~~~  <-- Air gap
        |  BURNER  |                                    |  BURNER  |                             +----------+
                                                                                                 |  BURNER  |

Flame Characteristics & Diagnostic Matrix

---

4. Incomplete Combustion & Carbon Monoxide (CO) Formation

When hydrocarbon fuels burn in an oxygen-deficient environment, or when the flame is cooled below its ignition temperature before combustion completes (flame impingement on a cold heat exchanger wall), carbon atoms cannot fully oxidize to $\text{CO}_2$.

Incomplete Combustion Reactions:

$$2\text{CH}_4 + 3\text{O}_2 \longrightarrow 2\text{CO} + 4\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Heat (approx. } 600\text{ BTU)}$$ $$\text{CH}_4 + \text{O}_2 \longrightarrow \text{C (Soot)} + 2\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Heat (approx. } 250\text{ BTU)}$$

Hazards of Carbon Monoxide (CO)

Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, tasteless, and non-irritating toxic gas. $\text{CO}$ binds to human hemoglobin with an affinity approximately $200\text{ to } 250\text{ times}$ greater than oxygen, forming carboxyhemoglobin ($\text{COHb}$) and starving vital organs of oxygen.

| CO Concentration in Air (PPM) | Health Effects & Exposure Time Limits | |---|---|| | $9\text{ ppm}$ | Maximum allowable indoor air concentration for 8 hours (ASHRAE / EPA ambient standard) | | $35\text{ ppm}$ | Maximum allowable continuous 8-hour workplace exposure limit (OSHA PEL) | | $50\text{ ppm}$ | Standard field action threshold; investigate source, inspect furnace and heat exchanger | | $100 - 200\text{ ppm}$ | Slight headache, fatigue, nausea, and dizziness within 2 to 3 hours of exposure | | $400\text{ ppm}$ | Frontal headache, life-threatening after 3 hours; ANSI maximum air-free limit in flue gas | | $800\text{ ppm}$ | Severe dizziness, nausea, convulsions within 45 minutes; unconsciousness within 2 hours | | $1,600\text{ ppm}$ | Headache, rapid pulse, dizziness within 20 minutes; death within 1 hour | | $3,200\text{ ppm}$ | Severe dizziness within 5 to 10 minutes; death within 30 minutes | | $6,400\text{ ppm}$ | Immediate unconsciousness; death within 10 to 15 minutes | | $12,800\text{ ppm}$ ($1.28\%$) | Immediate physiological collapse, respiratory arrest, and fatality within 1 to 3 minutes |

---

5. Code-Mandated Combustion Air Requirements (NC Fuel Gas Code / IFGC Chapter 3 & NFPA 54)

All fuel-burning appliances require an adequate, continuous supply of combustion, ventilation, and dilution air. The North Carolina Fuel Gas Code (NCFGC) and NFPA 54 (National Fuel Gas Code) establish strict geometric calculation rules based on appliance location and building envelope construction.

Method 1: All Combustion Air From Inside the Building (Standard Method)

Applicable when the building is not of unusually tight construction (air infiltration rate $\ge 0.40\text{ ACH}$):

$$\text{Required Room Volume} = 50\text{ ft}^3 \text{ per } 1,000\text{ BTU/hr Total Combined Appliance Input Rating}$$ $$\text{Required Volume (cu ft)} = \left( \frac{\text{Total Input Rating (BTU/hr)}}{1,000} \right) \times 50$$

• If the space is an Unconfined Space (actual room volume $\ge$ required volume), no additional outdoor combustion air openings are required.
• If the space is a Confined Space (actual volume $<$ required volume), combustion air must be brought in from interconnected rooms via two permanent openings:
  • One opening within $12\text{ inches}$ of the top of the enclosure.
  • One opening within $12\text{ inches}$ of the bottom of the enclosure.
  • Each opening must provide a minimum free area of $1\text{ sq in.}$ per $1,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ of total appliance input rating, but never less than $100\text{ sq in.}$ total free area.

Method 2: All Combustion Air From Outdoors

When a confined space cannot communicate with interior rooms or when the building has an air infiltration rate $< 0.40\text{ ACH}$, combustion air must be ducted or opened directly to the outdoors:

                       OUTDOOR COMBUSTION AIR SIZING RULES (NC FUEL GAS CODE)
+---------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------+
| CONFIGURATION                                     | REQUIRED FREE AREA PER 1,000 BTU/HR INPUT   |
+---------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------+
| Two Openings: Direct Outdoors or Vertical Ducts   | 1 sq in. per 4,000 BTU/hr (Each Opening)    |
| Two Openings: Horizontal Ducts to Outdoors        | 1 sq in. per 2,000 BTU/hr (Each Opening)    |
| One Opening: Direct Outdoors or Vertical Duct     | 1 sq in. per 3,000 BTU/hr (Single Opening)  |
+---------------------------------------------------+---------------------------------------------+

1. Two Permanent Openings — Direct Outdoors or Vertical Ducts:
   • Sizing: $1\text{ sq in.}$ per $4,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ of total appliance input rating.
   • Location: One opening within $12\text{ inches}$ of the ceiling, one within $12\text{ inches}$ of the floor.
   • Vertical ducts must terminate in an attic, crawlspace, or directly outdoors.
2. Two Permanent Openings — Horizontal Ducts:
   • Sizing: $1\text{ sq in.}$ per $2,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ of total appliance input rating.
   • Location: One high (within $12\text{ in.}$ of top), one low (within $12\text{ in.}$ of bottom).
   • Note: Horizontal ducts require double the area of vertical ducts ($1\text{ per } 2,000$ vs $1\text{ per } 4,000$) due to increased aerodynamic friction and lack of thermal stack buoyancy.
3. One Permanent Opening — Direct or Vertical/Horizontal Duct:
   • Sizing: $1\text{ sq in.}$ per $3,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ of total appliance input rating.
   • Location: Within $12\text{ inches}$ of the top of the enclosure.
   • Appliance clearances: Minimum $1\text{ inch}$ sides/back and $6\text{ inches}$ front clearance from the appliance to the enclosure walls.

Louver and Screen Free Area Reductions

When calculating the physical dimensions of combustion air grilles, contractors must adjust for the blockage caused by louver blades and mesh screens:

• Metal Louvers: $60\% - 75\%$ free area (standard rule: use $75\%$ if manufacturer data is unavailable).
• Wood Louvers: $20\% - 25\%$ free area (standard rule: use $25\%$ if manufacturer data is unavailable).
• Protective Wire Mesh: Mesh size must not be smaller than $1/4\text{ inch}$ ($6.4\text{ mm}$) to prevent lint and insect clogs.

Sizing Calculation Example:

A mechanical closet in Raleigh, NC contains a $100,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ gas furnace and a $40,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ gas water heater (Total input = $140,000\text{ BTU/hr}$). Two vertical ducts extend into a ventilated attic.

1. Net Free Area Required per Opening: $$\text{Net Free Area} = \frac{140,000\text{ BTU/hr}}{4,000\text{ BTU/hr/sq in.}} = 35.0\text{ sq inches per opening}$$
2. Physical Grille Sizing with Metal Louvers ($75\%$ free area): $$\text{Gross Grille Area} = \frac{35.0\text{ sq in.}}{0.75} = 46.67\text{ sq inches} \quad \implies \quad 6" \times 8"\text{ Grille } (48\text{ sq in.})$$
3. Physical Grille Sizing with Wood Louvers ($25\%$ free area): $$\text{Gross Grille Area} = \frac{35.0\text{ sq in.}}{0.25} = 140.0\text{ sq inches} \quad \implies \quad 10" \times 14"\text{ Grille } (140\text{ sq in.})$$

---

6. High-Altitude Appliance Derating

As altitude increases, atmospheric barometric pressure and air density decrease ($29.92\text{ in. Hg}$ at sea level vs $24.6\text{ in. Hg}$ at $5,000\text{ ft}$). Because atmospheric gas burners draw air by volume rather than mass, an unadjusted burner will ingest less oxygen by weight, causing rich burning, severe soot formation, and carbon monoxide generation.

NFPA 54 & NCFGC High-Altitude Derate Rule:

• Up to $2,000\text{ ft}$ Elevation: No derating required ($100\%$ nameplate firing rate).
• Above $2,000\text{ ft}$ Elevation: Derate appliance input rating by $4\%$ for every $1,000\text{ ft}$ of elevation above sea level.

$$\text{Derate Percentage (\%)} = 0.04 \times \left( \frac{\text{Elevation (ft)}}{1,000} \right)$$ $$\text{Adjusted High-Altitude Input (BTU/hr)} = \text{Nameplate Input (BTU/hr)} \times \left[ 1 - 0.04 \times \left( \frac{\text{Elevation (ft)}}{1,000} \right) \right]$$

Worked Example: Derating in the Blue Ridge Mountains (Boone, NC)

A gas furnace with a sea-level nameplate input rating of $80,000\text{ BTU/hr}$ is installed in Boone, NC at an elevation of $3,500\text{ ft}$:

1. Calculate Derate Factor: $$\text{Derate} = 4\% \times \left( \frac{3,500}{1,000} \right) = 4\% \times 3.5 = 14.0\%$$
2. Calculate Required Firing Input Rate: $$\text{Adjusted Input} = 80,000 \times (1 - 0.14) = 80,000 \times 0.86 = 68,800\text{ BTU/hr}$$
3. Field Adjustment: The installing contractor must install smaller main burner spud orifices (or adjust manifold pressure in accordance with manufacturer high-altitude conversion kits) to achieve $68,800\text{ BTU/hr}$.

---

7. Flue Gas Combustion Analysis & Diagnostics

Modern electronic combustion analyzers measure flue gas constituents ($\text{O}_2$, $\text{CO}$, stack temperature) and calculate combustion efficiency, excess air percentage, and carbon dioxide ($\text{CO}_2$).

Combustion Parameter Benchmarks

Air-Free Carbon Monoxide Formula (ANSI Z21.47 / EPA)

Because dilution air and excess air artificially dilute the measured $\text{CO}$ concentration in flue gas, combustion diagnostics use Air-Free $\text{CO}$ ($\text{CO}_{\text{AF}}$) to calculate the true concentration generated in an undiluted combustion stream:

$$\text{CO}_{\text{air-free}} = \text{CO}_{\text{measured}} \times \left( \frac{20.9}{20.9 - \%\text{O}_{2,\text{measured}}} \right)$$ $$\text{CO}_{\text{air-free}} = \text{CO}_{\text{measured}} \times \left( \frac{\%\text{CO}_{2,\text{ultimate}}}{\%\text{CO}_{2,\text{measured}}} \right)$$

Example: An atmospheric furnace flue measures $35\text{ ppm CO}$ with an oxygen reading of $8.0\% \text{ O}_2$:

$$\text{CO}_{\text{air-free}} = 35 \times \left( \frac{20.9}{20.9 - 8.0} \right) = 35 \times \left( \frac{20.9}{12.9} \right) = 35 \times 1.62 = 56.7\text{ ppm air-free}$$