5.3 Project Administration, Submittals, RFIs & Records

5.3 Project Administration, Submittals, RFIs & Records

Commercial construction requires rigorous administrative management to coordinate thousands of components, materials, and trade interfaces. Administrative workflows—such as the submittal process, Requests for Information (RFIs), and contemporaneous jobsite documentation—ensure that the physical construction aligns with the contract documents, local building codes, and architectural specifications.

---

Submittal Management & Classification

Under standard contract conditions (including AIA Document A201 General Conditions of the Contract for Construction § 3.12), submittals are not Contract Documents. Instead, they represent administrative demonstration items submitted by the contractor to show how specific materials, fabrications, and installations will conform to the contract requirements.

The Submittal Register (Submittal Log)

At the project's inception, the general contractor must develop a comprehensive Submittal Register (or Submittal Log) based on the project manual specifications (CSI MasterFormat Divisions 01 through 48). A complete submittal log tracks:

• Specification Section & Paragraph Number (e.g., Section 08 44 00 Curtain Wall and Glazed Assemblies);
• Submittal Description & Classification Type (Shop Drawing, Product Data, Sample, Mockup);
• Responsible Subcontractor or Vendor;
• Target Date for Subcontractor Submission to GC;
• Target Date for GC Review & Forwarding to Architect;
• Contractual Review Window for Design Team (typically 14 to 21 calendar days per Division 01);
• Fabrication & Long-Lead Delivery Durations;
• Required Jobsite Arrival Date tied directly to the CPM schedule logic.

Types of Submittals

---

The Submittal Review & Approval Workflow

The submittal workflow follows a strict multi-tiered chain of custody. Bypassing steps or failing to perform required field verifications exposes the general contractor to direct liability for non-conforming work.

                      ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
                      │   STEP 1: SUBCONTRACTOR / VENDOR        │
                      │   Prepares Shop Drawings & Data Sheets  │
                      └────────────────────┬────────────────────┘
                                           │
                                           ▼
                      ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
                      │   STEP 2: GENERAL CONTRACTOR REVIEW     │
                      │   • Verify Field Dimensions & Quantities│
                      │   • Coordinate Trade Interfaces         │
                      │   • Apply Mandatory GC Approval Stamp   │
                      └────────────────────┬────────────────────┘
                                           │
                                           ▼
                      ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
                      │   STEP 3: ARCHITECT / ENGINEER REVIEW   │
                      │   • Checks Conformance with Design Intent│
                      │   • Technical Specialty Consultant Check│
                      │   • Applies Action Disposition Stamp    │
                      └────────────────────┬────────────────────┘
                                           │
                   ┌───────────────────────┴───────────────────────┐
                   ▼                                               ▼
   ┌───────────────────────────────┐               ┌───────────────────────────────┐
   │      APPROVED / AS NOTED      │               │     REVISE & RESUBMIT         │
   │  Proceed with Fabrication &   │               │   Correct Deficiencies &      │
   │  Jobsite Delivery             │               │   Resubmit for Review         │
   └───────────────────────────────┘               └───────────────────────────────┘

General Contractor Verification Duties & Approval Stamp

Under AIA Document A201 § 3.12.5, by submitting shop drawings, product data, and samples, the Contractor represents to the Owner and Architect that the Contractor has:

1. Reviewed and approved them;
2. Determined and verified materials, field measurements, and field construction criteria related thereto; and
3. Checked and coordinated the information contained within such submittals with the requirements of the Work and of the Contract Documents.

Critical Requirement: Submittals forwarded to the architect without the General Contractor's review stamp and signature may be returned without action by the design team, and any resulting schedule delay is non-excusable and borne solely by the contractor.

Design Professional Action Stamping

The architect and consulting engineers review submittals solely for the limited purpose of checking for conformance with information given and the design concept expressed in the Contract Documents (AIA A201 § 3.12.7). Standard action dispositions include:

• Approved (Furnish as Submitted): The submittal conforms to design intent; fabrication and procurement may proceed immediately.
• Approved as Noted (Furnish as Corrected): Minor corrections required (e.g., change paint sheen). Fabrication may proceed provided noted corrections are incorporated. Resubmittal is generally not required unless requested.
• Revise and Resubmit (Make Corrections & Resubmit): Substantial deficiencies or deviations from specifications exist. Fabrication is prohibited until revised documents are reviewed and approved.
• Rejected (Submit Specified Item): The proposed product or system does not meet contract requirements and is entirely rejected. A compliant submittal must be created.

---

Requests for Information (RFI) Workflows

A Request for Information (RFI) is a formal administrative instrument used by the general contractor to seek written clarification or interpretation of ambiguous drawings, conflicting specifications, or unforeseen jobsite conditions from the design team.

Key Components of a Compliant RFI

To ensure rapid resolution and avoid claims of improper documentation, an effective RFI must include:

1. RFI Number & Date of Issuance;
2. Specific Contract Document References: Exact drawing numbers, detail tags, sheet numbers, and specification section/paragraph citations;
3. Clear Description of the Issue: Concise explanation of the ambiguity, clash, or missing detail;
4. Contractor's Recommended Solution: High-quality RFIs include a practical, cost-effective proposed solution for the architect's concurrence, speeding up response times;
5. Impact Assessment: Notation of potential impact on project schedule (CPM critical path) or construction cost.

RFI Tracking & Management

All RFIs must be maintained in an active RFI Tracking Log that records the date submitted, assigned design consultant, date response received, total turnaround days, and whether the response triggers a potential change order or scope modification.

Common Misuses of the RFI Process

• Submittal Substitutions Disguised as RFIs: Proposing a product substitution via an RFI instead of through the formal submittal and substitution request procedure.
• Incremental Change Orders: Attempting to obtain pricing approval through RFI responses rather than standard Change Order requests.
• Lazy Plan Inquiries: Submitting RFIs for information that is already clearly shown on other sheets in the coordinated contract drawing set.

---

Jobsite Field Documentation & Daily Logs

Contemporaneous field records are the most critical evidence in construction disputes, delay claims, OSHA safety audits, and warranty investigations. Memories fade, but objective daily records created in real time carry substantial legal weight.

Essential Elements of the Superintendent Daily Job Log

1. Date & Weather Conditions: Exact ambient temperature range, precipitation (inches of rain/snow), wind velocity, and site ground conditions (e.g., muddy/standing water preventing excavation).
2. Manpower Headcount by Trade: Exact count of trade workers on site categorized by subcontractor and labor trade (e.g., 8 electricians, 12 framers, 4 plumbers) and total daily man-hours.
3. Active & Idle Equipment: Specific heavy equipment on site (e.g., 50-ton hydraulic crane, CAT 320 excavator) and operational status (hours active vs. idle due to weather/delays).
4. Material Deliveries: Deliveries received, bill of lading numbers, delivery damage, and staging locations.
5. Work Description & Locations: Specific descriptions of work completed by building, floor, elevation, or grid line (e.g., Framed interior partitions on 3rd floor grid lines A-D).
6. Inspections & Testing: Building official visits, Special Inspector testing (concrete slump/cylinders, soil compaction), and pass/fail results.
7. Safety Activities & Incidents: Daily safety toolbox talks conducted, topics discussed, near-misses, OSHA inspections, or injury records.

Progress Photography & Meeting Minutes

• Progress Photography: Date-stamped, high-resolution photographs taken from consistent fixed angles across weekly milestones, especially capturing concealed conditions (in-wall rough-ins, rebar placement prior to concrete pours).
• Owner-Architect-Contractor (OAC) Meetings: Weekly or bi-weekly meeting minutes documenting schedule status, 3-week lookahead schedules, open submittals, pending RFIs, change order requests, and action item assignments with firm commitment dates.