Introduction to Therapeutic Techniques

Therapeutic techniques are evidence-based communication and intervention methods developed in psychology and counseling that have been adapted for use in financial planning contexts. These techniques help CFP professionals:

• Build deeper client relationships through skilled listening and rapport
• Help clients overcome ambivalence about implementing financial plans
• Facilitate positive behavior change without creating resistance
• Address the emotional dimensions of money decisions
• Guide clients toward their own solutions rather than imposing recommendations

The Financial Therapy Association emphasizes that effective financial therapy combines emotional work with practical strategies for managing finances, using techniques from psychology, marriage and family therapy, social work, and financial planning.

---

Active Listening: The SOLER Model

Active listening goes beyond simply hearing words---it involves fully engaging with the client through both verbal and non-verbal communication. Gerard Egan developed the SOLER model as a framework for the non-verbal components of active listening.

The SOLER Framework

Why SOLER Works

SOLER reinforces three key therapeutic elements:

1. Attentiveness: Clients feel the planner is fully present and engaged
2. Unconditional Positive Regard: Open, relaxed posture conveys acceptance
3. Empathy: Forward lean and eye contact communicate genuine interest

Integration with Financial Planning

Egan's work bridges various psychological theories, including cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and motivational interviewing. His emphasis on active listening, empathy, and structured problem-solving makes SOLER ideal for financial planning conversations.

Practical Application: During client meetings, periodically check your posture. Are you leaning back with crossed arms? Adjust to SOLER position to signal engagement.

Limitations of SOLER

SOLER is visually focused and works best in face-to-face settings. For telephone or video counseling, planners must adapt---emphasizing verbal cues, voice tone, and explicit acknowledgment of what the client shares.

---

Reflective Statements and Paraphrasing

Reflective listening is the most crucial and challenging skill in motivational interviewing. It goes beyond simply staying silent and being a good listener---the key lies in how you respond to what the person is saying.

What is Reflective Listening?

Reflective listening involves:

1. Actively listening to the client's words
2. Interpreting the underlying meaning
3. Expressing your understanding through a statement (not a question)

Types of Reflections

The 2:1 Ratio

In motivational interviewing, therapists aim for a ratio of 2 reflections for every 1 question. Too many questions can feel like an interrogation; reflections feel like understanding.

Why Reflection Works

• Clients feel heard: When you accurately reflect, clients know you understand
• Deepens client insight: Hearing their thoughts reflected back helps clients process
• Reduces defensiveness: Reflection feels supportive rather than challenging
• Builds momentum: Accurate reflections encourage clients to continue sharing

---

Motivational Interviewing Techniques: OARS

OARS represents the four core communication skills used in motivational interviewing. These techniques are used "early and often" throughout the MI approach.

The OARS Framework

---

Open-Ended Questions

Open questions invite exploration and cannot be answered with a simple "yes" or "no."

Closed vs. Open Questions:

Best Practices:

• Start with "What," "How," "Tell me about," or "Help me understand"
• Avoid leading questions that suggest the "right" answer
• Follow open questions with reflection, not more questions
• Use evocative questions that guide reflection on change: "How might things be different if you achieved this goal?"

---

Affirmations

Affirmations recognize client strengths and acknowledge positive behaviors, no matter how small.

Key Principles:

• Must be genuine: Clients detect insincerity immediately
• Focus on specific behaviors: "You've been consistent with your contributions for three years" vs. "You're doing great"
• Acknowledge effort, not just outcomes: "It took courage to come in and discuss this"
• Build self-efficacy: Help clients see their own capacity for change

Examples in Financial Planning:

• "You've shown real commitment by tracking your spending for three months."
• "It takes strength to acknowledge that debt and take steps to address it."
• "Your dedication to your children's education is evident in how you prioritize saving for them."
• "Coming to this meeting despite your anxiety about finances shows your determination."

Caution: Affirmations should not feel like empty praise or flattery. They must reflect genuine recognition of real strengths or efforts.

---

Reflective Listening

(See detailed section on Reflective Statements above)

Key Point: Reflective listening is the most important and challenging MI skill. Aim for a 2:1 ratio of reflections to questions.

---

Summarizing

Summaries collect what the client has shared and present it back in an organized way.

Types of Summaries:

Best Practices:

• Begin with "So..." or "Let me make sure I understand..."
• Include both sides of ambivalence when present
• End with an invitation for correction or addition
• Use strategically to shift direction or emphasize key points

---

Solution-Focused Techniques

Solution-focused therapy concentrates on what clients want to achieve in the future rather than analyzing past problems. This approach is particularly valuable in financial planning because it emphasizes client strengths and existing resources.

The Miracle Question

The Miracle Question is a powerful technique for helping clients envision their ideal future and identify concrete steps toward it.

Standard Formulation: "Suppose tonight, while you're sleeping, a miracle happens and the problem we've been discussing is solved. But because you were asleep, you don't know the miracle happened. When you wake up tomorrow morning, what will be different that will tell you a miracle has occurred?"

Financial Planning Adaptation: "Imagine you wake up tomorrow and your financial worries have completely disappeared. Everything is exactly as you'd want it. What's the first thing you'd notice? What would be different?"

Why It Works:

• Gives permission to think beyond current limitations
• Creates vivid imagery of success
• Identifies concrete details that reveal underlying values and goals
• Shifts focus from problems to solutions
• Generates hope and motivation

Follow-Up Questions:

• "What else would be different?"
• "How would [spouse/children] know something had changed?"
• "What would you be doing differently?"
• "What small part of this miracle is already happening?"

---

Scaling Questions

Scaling questions help clients assess their current position and identify small, actionable steps forward.

Basic Format: "On a scale of 0 to 10, where 10 is [goal achieved] and 0 is [worst case], where would you say you are right now?"

Examples in Financial Planning:

• "On a scale of 0 to 10, how confident are you in your ability to stick to this spending plan?"
• "Where would you rate your current level of financial stress, with 10 being completely stressed and 0 being completely relaxed?"
• "On a scale of 0 to 10, how ready are you to start increasing your 401(k) contributions?"

Powerful Follow-Up Questions:

Research Finding: Scaling questions are particularly effective at generating specific action steps, even more so than miracle questions or exception questions.

---

Reframing Negative Thoughts

Reframing involves helping clients see situations from a different perspective, transforming perceived negatives into potential positives or opportunities.

How Reframing Works: The situation doesn't change, but the meaning the client assigns to it shifts, opening new possibilities for response.

Examples in Financial Planning:

Principles of Effective Reframing:

1. Don't dismiss the client's feelings: Acknowledge the difficulty before reframing
2. Make it genuine: Forced positivity feels dismissive
3. Connect to client values: The reframe should resonate with what matters to them
4. Offer, don't impose: "Another way to look at this might be..." rather than "You should think about it this way"

---

When to Use Each Technique

Different techniques are most effective at different points in the client relationship and for different purposes.

---

Integrating Techniques: A Practical Example

Scenario: A client says, "I know I should be saving more for retirement, but I just can't seem to do it. I always find something else to spend money on."

Integrated Response:

1. Reflection: "It sounds like there's a gap between what you want to do and what's actually happening with your savings." (Acknowledges the struggle)

2. Open Question: "What tends to come up that leads to spending instead of saving?" (Explores the situation)

3. Affirmation: "The fact that you're aware of this pattern and brought it up shows you're taking your retirement seriously." (Builds confidence)

4. Scaling Question: "On a scale of 0 to 10, how important is it to you to change this pattern?" (Assesses motivation)

5. If appropriate - Miracle Question: "If you woke up tomorrow and this was no longer a struggle, what would be different about how you handle money?" (Creates vision)

6. Summary: "So you're very motivated to change---you rated it an 8---and you've identified that impulse purchases are the main challenge. You mentioned that automatic transfers might help remove the decision-making. Would you like to explore setting that up?" (Organizes and transitions)

---

Quiz Questions

Question 1: A financial planner says to a client, "On one hand, you want to pay off your mortgage early, and on the other hand, you value having accessible cash for emergencies." What type of reflective statement is this?

A) Simple reflection B) Amplified reflection C) Double-sided reflection D) Transitioning summary

Correct Answer: C) Double-sided reflection

Explanation: A double-sided reflection acknowledges both sides of a client's ambivalence, connecting them with "on one hand... on the other hand" or similar language. This technique is particularly useful in motivational interviewing to help clients hear their own ambivalence and work through it.

---

Question 2: According to the OARS framework in motivational interviewing, what is the recommended ratio of reflective statements to questions?

A) 1 reflection for every 2 questions B) Equal numbers of reflections and questions C) 2 reflections for every 1 question D) Only reflections, no questions

Correct Answer: C) 2 reflections for every 1 question

Explanation: In motivational interviewing, practitioners aim for a 2:1 ratio of reflections to questions. Too many questions can feel like an interrogation and create defensiveness. Reflections feel supportive and help clients feel understood while deepening their own insight.

---

Question 3: A client says, "I've tried budgeting before and I always fail. What's the point of trying again?" Which technique would be MOST appropriate for the planner to use first?

A) Immediately suggest a different budgeting app B) Use a scaling question to assess readiness C) Reframe the "failures" as learning experiences D) Ask the Miracle Question

Correct Answer: C) Reframe the "failures" as learning experiences

Explanation: The client is expressing a limiting belief based on past experiences. Reframing helps them see those experiences differently---as learning opportunities rather than proof of inability. An example reframe: "It sounds like you've learned several approaches that don't work for you. That brings you closer to finding one that does." This addresses the negative self-talk before moving to action-oriented techniques.