10.3 Investment Plans and Services
Key Takeaways
- Every scheme offers a regular plan and a direct plan holding the identical portfolio.
- The direct plan carries a lower expense ratio because it embeds no distribution commission.
- Within each plan, investors choose between the growth option and the IDCW option.
- The growth option makes no distributions, allowing gains to compound and defer tax until redemption.
- IDCW sub-options are payout, reinvestment and transfer, each with different tax and stamp duty consequences.
Two Decisions, Not One
An investor choosing a scheme makes two further choices that are frequently confused:
- Which plan — regular or direct. This determines cost.
- Which option — growth or IDCW. This determines whether income is distributed or accumulated.
The two are independent. All four combinations exist: regular growth, regular IDCW, direct growth, direct IDCW.
Regular Plan and Direct Plan
| Regular plan | Direct plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Distributor involved | Yes, ARN quoted | No |
| Distribution commission | Embedded in the expense ratio | None |
| Expense ratio | Higher | Lower |
| Portfolio | Identical | Identical |
| Fund manager | Same | Same |
| NAV | Grows more slowly | Grows faster |
Both plans hold exactly the same securities managed by the same person. The only difference is the expense ratio, and because expenses accrue daily the NAVs diverge steadily.
Direct plans were introduced in 2013. The determinant of which plan applies is whether a distributor code is quoted, not the medium used — an investor transacting on an AMC website while quoting an ARN is in the regular plan.
Growth Option
No income is distributed. All gains remain in the scheme and are reflected in a rising NAV.
- Units held remain constant; NAV grows
- No tax until redemption, and then at capital gains rates
- Gains compound within the scheme
For most investors who do not need periodic cash, this is the appropriate option, and the reasoning is set out in section 9.3: for a high-slab investor in an equity-oriented scheme, distributions taxed at 30% compare unfavourably with long-term capital gains at 12.5%.
IDCW Option
Income is distributed from realised gains and distributable surplus, and NAV falls by the amount distributed.
| Sub-option | Mechanism | Consequences |
|---|---|---|
| IDCW payout | Cash credited to the bank account | Taxable at slab; TDS above INR 10,000 |
| IDCW reinvestment | Units issued at the ex-distribution NAV | Taxable at slab and stamp duty on units issued, with no cash received |
| IDCW transfer | Distribution invested into another scheme of the same fund house | Taxable at slab; new units in the target scheme |
IDCW reinvestment is the least attractive combination and is chosen surprisingly often. The investor receives nothing in hand, pays income tax on the distribution, and pays stamp duty on the units issued against it. If accumulation is the objective, the growth option achieves it without either charge.
Systematic Services
Beyond plans and options, schemes offer transaction services covered fully in section 10.10:
- Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) — invest a fixed amount at fixed intervals
- Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) — move a fixed amount periodically from one scheme to another
- Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) — redeem a fixed amount periodically
- Dividend Transfer Plan — route distributions from one scheme into another
- Trigger facilities — act automatically on a defined event, such as a value or date threshold
Other Services
- Nomination — up to ten nominees may be registered per folio
- Online access — transaction and portfolio viewing through AMC, RTA and platform channels
- Consolidated Account Statement — across all funds linked to the PAN
- Pledge or lien — units may be pledged as security for a loan, with the lien marked in the records
- Demat holding — units may be held in dematerialised form
- Switch — move between schemes or options, remembering that it is a redemption for tax purposes
Advising on Plan and Option
The practical guidance a distributor should be able to give:
| Investor situation | Suggested combination |
|---|---|
| Accumulating for a long-term goal, no cash need | Growth |
| Needs regular cash from the portfolio | Growth with a systematic withdrawal plan |
| Wants income and is in a low tax slab | IDCW payout is defensible |
| Wants accumulation but selected IDCW reinvestment | Move to growth; the reinvestment option costs tax and stamp duty for no benefit |
| Self-directed, has time and temperament | Direct plan |
| Wants ongoing advice and service | Regular plan, with the cost disclosed |
The recommendation that most often needs correcting is IDCW reinvestment, and the correction costs the investor nothing but a switch instruction.
How the Plan Is Actually Determined
The plan is not something the investor ticks and the AMC honours. It is derived from the form:
- ARN quoted in the distributor block, with EUIN or an execution-only declaration — the application is processed under the regular plan.
- ARN left blank — the application is processed under the direct plan, whatever the investor wrote in the plan field.
This mechanical rule produces two recurring problems. An investor who intends to invest direct but writes an old distributor's ARN out of habit lands in the regular plan. An investor who intends to route business through a distributor but submits the form without the ARN lands in the direct plan, and the distributor is not paid on that folio.
Moving Between Plans and Options Is a Redemption
Switching from regular to direct, or from IDCW to growth, is executed as a redemption from one plan or option and a fresh purchase into the other. Three consequences follow, and all three are examinable:
- Capital gains arise on the units being switched out, at the rate applicable to the scheme type and holding period.
- Exit load may apply if the units have not completed the load period.
- A new holding period begins for the units acquired, and stamp duty at 0.005% is charged on the purchase leg.
A switch is therefore not a free administrative correction. Where the investor's position is large and the gain material, the sensible advice is often to direct future contributions to the preferred plan or option and leave the existing units undisturbed.
Liquidity Services
Two facilities are worth knowing by name. The Instant Access Facility permits online instant redemption from a liquid scheme of up to INR 50,000 or 90% of the folio value, whichever is lower, per day per scheme per investor, available to resident individual investors, with units redeemed at the lower of the previous day's NAV and the prospective NAV. Trigger facilities automate an action — a switch, a redemption or a rebalance — when a stated index level, NAV level or date is reached, which removes the need for the investor to be watching.
An investor wants to accumulate wealth over 15 years and has selected the IDCW reinvestment sub-option. What should a distributor advise?
What is the only difference between the regular plan and the direct plan of a scheme?
An investor in the 30% slab needs regular cash flow from an equity-oriented holding. Which arrangement is generally most efficient?