12.4 Age Adjustments and Policy Reinstatement

Study Focus

Schedule 8 prevents avoidance merely because age was misstated. An understated age can reduce the benefit in proportion to the premium paid.

4. Misstatement of Age Provision (Schedule 8, Paragraph 1 FSA 2013)

Life premiums depend on age, so a wrong date of birth distorts the contract. Recognising that age errors often arise from clerical mistakes or missing birth records, Schedule 8, Paragraph 1 of the FSA 2013 keeps the policy alive and adjusts it instead:

• No avoidance (Paragraph 1(1)): A life insurer shall not avoid a life policy, or refuse a claim, by reason only of a misstatement of the age of the life insured.
• Proof of age at any time (Paragraph 1(5)): The insurer may ask for proof of age at any time, and adjusting the policy for the true age does not mean the policy is disputed.

Case A: Age Understated (True Age Is Higher)

The premium charged was lower than the premium for the true age.

• Statutory Remedy (Paragraph 1(2)): The insurer may reduce the sum insured and bonuses so that they bear the same proportion to the original amounts as the premium actually paid bears to the premium that would have been payable at the true age.
• Mathematical Formula:

$$\text{Adjusted Sum Insured} = \text{Original Sum Insured} \times \left(\frac{\text{Premium Actually Paid}}{\text{Premium Required at True Age}}\right)$$

Step-by-Step Worked Example: Understated Age Adjustment

Mr. Tan took out a 20-year term policy with an original sum insured of RM 250,000, paying an annual premium of RM 1,500. On his proposal form, Mr. Tan stated his age as 30. Ten years later, Mr. Tan dies in an accident. During the death claim verification against his National Registration Identity Card (MyKad), the claims examiner discovers that Mr. Tan's true age at policy inception was actually 35.

• According to the insurer's published premium rate book at inception:
  • Annual premium per RM 1,000 sum insured at age 30 = RM 6.00 (hence $\text{RM } 250 \times 6.00 = \text{RM } 1,500$ paid).
  • Annual premium per RM 1,000 sum insured at age 35 = RM 7.50 (hence true premium required for RM 250,000 was $\text{RM } 250 \times 7.50 = \text{RM } 1,875$).
• Applying the Paragraph 1(2) formula:

$$\text{Adjusted Sum Insured} = \text{RM } 250,000 \times \left(\frac{\text{RM } 1,500}{\text{RM } 1,875}\right)$$ $$\text{Adjusted Sum Insured} = \text{RM } 250,000 \times 0.80 = \text{RM } 200,000$$

• The insurer pays the adjusted sum insured of RM 200,000 to the beneficiaries, achieving exact actuarial equity without forfeiting the policy.

Case B: Age Overstated (True Age Is Lower)

The premium charged was higher than necessary.

• Statutory Remedy (Paragraph 1(3)): The insurer must either:
  1. increase the sum insured and bonuses in the same proportion (premium paid compared with the premium for the true age); or
  2. reduce the premium from the date of issue to the correct amount and repay the overpaid premiums, less any cash value of bonuses that was paid out above what the true age would have produced.

Policies Where Cover Depends on Age

Where the period of cover is fixed by reference to age (for example, cover to age 65), the insurer may also change the coverage period to what it would have been at the true age (Paragraph 1(4)).

Misstatement of sex is not covered by Paragraph 1; any adjustment for it depends on the policy terms and the misrepresentation rules in Schedule 9.

---

5. The Reinstatement Provision (Reviving a Lapsed Policy)

When a policy lapses due to non-payment of renewal premiums following the expiration of the contractual grace period, the contract terminates. However, standard policies contain a Reinstatement Provision that grants the policyholder the contractual right to revive the original lapsed policy rather than purchasing a brand new contract.

Economic Advantages of Reinstatement Over New Insurance

1. Preservation of Lower Original Entry Age: Premiums on a new policy would be permanently higher because the applicant is now older.
2. Retention of Accumulated Cash Values: A new policy requires several years to build initial surrender values, whereas a reinstated policy restores accumulated cash reserves and terminal bonuses.
3. Avoiding New Inception Charges: Reinstatement eliminates new policy acquisition expenses and unallocated first-year premium deductions.

Mandatory Requirements for Reinstatement

To successfully reinstate a lapsed policy, the policyholder must satisfy four cumulative conditions:

1. Time Limitation: Application for reinstatement must be submitted within the contractual window—as specified in the policy from the exact date of premium default.
2. Evidence of Insurability: The life insured must furnish satisfactory evidence of current insurability at their own expense. This entails submitting a formal Declaration of Good Health or undergoing clinical medical examinations if requested by the underwriter.
3. Payment of All Back-Premiums with Compound Interest: The policyholder must pay all overdue unpaid renewal premiums together with compound interest at a rate stipulated in the policy contract (use the contract rate).
4. Settlement or Reinstatement of Policy Loans: Any outstanding policy loan balance or Automatic Premium Loan (APL) that existed prior to lapse must either be repaid in full or reinstated against available policy cash values.

Legal Impact of Reinstatement on Incontestability and Suicide

When a policy is reinstated, legal protections are recalibrated:

• Incontestability for Reinstatement Statements: Policy terms commonly provide that statements made in the reinstatement application can be contested for two years from the date of reinstatement, mirroring the two-year rule in Schedule 9, Paragraph 13. Statements in the original proposal keep their original two-year period.
• Suicide Clause Restarts: Check whether and how the policy restarts its suicide exclusion on reinstatement; the period is contractual.

---

Summary Comparison of Core Standard Policy Provisions