15.6 Claims Dispute Resolution: Appraisal Versus DFS Mediation

Claims Dispute Resolution: Policy Appraisal vs. DFS Mediation

Not all claims disputes involve fraud; most represent honest, good-faith disagreements over valuation or policy interpretation. Florida provides two primary alternative dispute resolution mechanisms to resolve claims without expensive courtroom litigation.

1. The Policy Appraisal Clause (Amount of Loss Only)

The standard property insurance policy contains a contractual Appraisal Clause. Appraisal is invoked when the insurer and the insured agree that a loss is covered, but disagree sharply on the amount of loss (the repair or replacement cost).

                    CONTRACTUAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL WORKFLOW
                                        │
           ┌────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────┐
           ▼                                                         ▼
    INSURER SELECTS                                           INSURED SELECTS
  Independent Appraiser                                     Independent Appraiser
           │                                                         │
           └────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────┘
                                        ▼
                               TWO APPRAISERS SELECT
                             Competent, Impartial Umpire
                                        │
                                        ▼
                            BINDING APPRAISAL AWARD
                    Agreed & Signed by Any Two of the Three
                 (Appraiser + Appraiser OR Appraiser + Umpire)

• Scope Limitation: Appraisal CANNOT determine coverage issues! It cannot decide whether a peril is covered, whether a policy exclusion applies, or whether the policyholder breached contract conditions. Coverage questions are legal questions reserved exclusively for judges.
• The Selection Process: Each party selects a competent, independent appraiser within 20 days. The two appraisers then select a competent, impartial umpire. If the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire, a circuit court judge appoints one.
• The Binding Award: The appraisers evaluate the loss independently. If they agree, the agreed valuation sets the loss. If they disagree, they submit their differences to the umpire. An agreement or award signed by any two of the three (e.g., Appraiser 1 + Appraiser 2, or Appraiser 1 + Umpire) establishes the legally binding amount of the loss.

2. Florida DFS Property Insurance Mediation Program (F.S. § 627.7015)

Under Florida Statutes § 627.7015, the Florida Legislature established the DFS Property Insurance Mediation Program as a state-administered, non-adversarial alternative to costly litigation for residential property disputes.

• Mandatory Carrier Notice: When a claim dispute arises regarding a residential property loss, the insurer must provide written notice to the insured of their statutory right to participate in DFS mediation. If the insurer fails to provide this required notice, the carrier loses the legal right to demand policy appraisal.
• Eligible Claims: Applies to residential property insurance policies (homeowners, dwelling, condo unit owners, mobile homes).
• Cost Allocation: The insurer pays 100% of the mediation conference fees; the policyholder participates at zero administrative charge.
• Informal & Non-Binding: The conference is conducted by a DFS-approved, neutral certified mediator. The mediator has no authority to impose a binding ruling. Both parties must negotiate in good faith, but neither is forced to settle.
• The 3-Day Right of Rescission: If the parties successfully reach a mediated settlement agreement, the policyholder has 3 business days to rescind (cancel) the agreement, provided the policyholder has not cashed or deposited the settlement check.

Exam Trap: Appraisal is Binding, Mediation is Non-Binding!

Never confuse Appraisal with DFS Mediation on the exam:

1. Appraisal is a private contractual clause that yields a binding award signed by two of three participants, resolving the amount of loss only.
2. DFS Mediation (F.S. § 627.7015) is a state statutory process that is non-binding, paid entirely by the carrier, and allows the insured a 3-business-day right of rescission!

---

Summary Comparison: Policy Appraisal vs. DFS Mediation Program

---

3. Who May Serve: The "Competent and Disinterested" Standard

Florida policies require each side's appraiser to be competent and disinterested or competent and impartial, and Florida courts read those words strictly. "Disinterested" means free from bias, prejudice or partiality, and without a pecuniary interest in the outcome. Two disqualifiers matter on a working claim file:

• Contingency compensation destroys disinterest. An appraiser paid a percentage of the award — the standard public adjuster fee arrangement — cannot serve as a disinterested appraiser. Appraisers must be engaged on a flat-fee or hourly basis.
• The claim's own adjuster cannot flip roles. A person who adjusted the loss for one party is an advocate for that party, not a neutral valuer.

If the two appraisers cannot agree on an umpire, either party may petition the circuit court, which appoints one. There is no state license for umpires; competence is demonstrated through property valuation experience, estimating proficiency and the absence of any financial relationship with either side. An adjuster who nominates a friendly umpire invites a motion to disqualify and hands the policyholder a delay argument.

4. Presuit Notice Under F.S. § 627.70152

Since 2021 a policyholder cannot simply file suit on a property claim. F.S. § 627.70152 imposes a mandatory presuit step that the adjuster's file must be ready for:

The response deadline is the trap. An insurer that lets 10 business days pass without answering loses the ability to steer the dispute into appraisal and hands the claimant an unobstructed path to court.

5. Mediation Eligibility, Exclusions and Cost

F.S. § 627.7015 is narrower than most candidates assume. It applies to claims under personal lines and commercial residential policies before appraisal or litigation. It does not reach general commercial coverages, motor vehicle insurance, or liability coverages written inside a property policy.

Subsection (9) lists the situations in which mediation is not available:

1. The insurer reasonably suspects fraud.
2. On the agreed facts, there is no coverage under the policy.
3. The insurer has denied the claim based on material misrepresentation.
4. The amount in controversy is less than $500, unless both parties agree to mediate anyway.
5. The loss was not reported within the deadlines of F.S. § 627.70132.

Notice is not a one-time event: the insurer must inform the policyholder of the right to mediate at issuance, at renewal, and when a first-party claim is filed. The insurer bears all of the cost of conducting the conference, with one exception — a policyholder who fails to appear and then reschedules pays for the rescheduled session. An insurer that fails to appear must reimburse the policyholder's actual cash expenses of attending.

Exam Trap: Two Ways an Insurer Loses Its Appraisal Right

If the insurer fails to give the required mediation notice, or requests mediation that then fails to resolve the dispute, the policyholder is not required to submit to or participate in any contractual loss appraisal process. Appraisal is a contract right the carrier can forfeit through its own procedural default.

6. The Third and Fourth Tracks

Appraisal and mediation are not the only routes. F.S. § 627.70154 allows a residential property policy to include mandatory binding arbitration, but only under strict conditions: the arbitration requirement must appear in a separate endorsement, the insurer must give an actuarially sound premium credit for it, the policyholder must sign a form consenting to give up the right to sue, and the parties must still comply with the mediation statute first. Separately, sinkhole disputes go to the neutral evaluation program in F.S. § 627.7074, covered in Section 7.4, which is non-binding on both parties but admissible in later litigation.