29.3 Affiliate Definitions, Covered Transactions and Collateral
Key Takeaways
Section 23A generally limits covered transactions to ten percent for one affiliate and twenty percent for all affiliates.
Collateral requirements depend on collateral type and must be maintained.
Affiliate and covered-transaction definitions must be analyzed before applying the numerical limits.
Statutory Purpose & the Federal Safety Net
Insured depository institutions enjoy substantial federal safety net benefits, including:
- Federal deposit insurance backed by the full faith and credit of the United States Government;
- Direct access to Federal Reserve discount window emergency liquidity; and
- Direct access to the Federal Reserve wholesale payment system (Fedwire).
Without strict regulatory barriers, a financial holding company or parent corporation could be tempted to exploit the bank's low-cost, government-insured deposit base to finance risky non-bank commercial ventures, bail out troubled securities or real estate affiliates, or purchase substandard assets from sister subsidiaries. Sections 23A and 23B of the Federal Reserve Act and Regulation W function as a statutory firebreak insulating the bank from its affiliates.
Definition of an Affiliate (12 CFR § 223.2)
Under 12 CFR § 223.2, the concept of control governs affiliate status. A company controls another company if it:
- Directly or indirectly owns, controls, or has power to vote 25% or more of any class of voting securities;
- Controls in any manner the election of a majority of the directors or trustees; or
- The Federal Reserve Board determines, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that the company exercises a controlling influence over management or policies.
Included Entities
An affiliate of a bank includes:
- Parent Holding Company: Any company that controls the bank (e.g., the parent bank holding company or financial holding company);
- Sister Subsidiaries: Any company controlled by the same parent company that controls the bank (e.g., an affiliated broker-dealer, mortgage company, or insurance agency);
- Sponsored and Contractually Advised Companies: Any company sponsored and advised on a contractual basis by the bank or an affiliate (e.g., real estate investment trusts or private funds);
- Investment Funds with Bank as Adviser: Any investment fund (including hedge funds, mutual funds, and private equity funds) for which the bank or an affiliate acts as investment adviser; and
- Interlocking Directorate Entities: Any company where a majority of its board of directors or trustees constitutes a majority of the board of directors or trustees of the bank.
Excluded Entities (§ 223.2(b))
Compliance officers must distinguish covered affiliates from entities expressly excluded by statute:
- Operating Subsidiaries: A subsidiary of the bank itself is generally treated as an integral part of the bank, not as an affiliate (unless it is classified as a financial subsidiary, an insured depository institution, or a broker-dealer/futures merchant).
- Bank Premises Subsidiaries: Companies formed solely to hold title to the bank's physical premises or real estate.
- DPC Subsidiaries: Companies formed solely to liquidate assets acquired in good faith in satisfaction of debts previously contracted (DPC).
Financial subsidiaries and statutory updates
A financial subsidiary is treated as an affiliate. Dodd-Frank eliminated the former exemption from the 10% single-affiliate limit; both the single-affiliate and aggregate limits must be checked. Provisions governing valuation of the investment and related transactions require care; a financial subsidiary is not a blanket route around Section 23A. Dodd-Frank also includes credit exposure from derivatives and securities borrowing or lending transactions in covered transactions. Apply the current statute along with implementing Regulation W provisions.
Section 23A Collateral Requirements (12 CFR § 223.14)
Every extension of credit to an affiliate, guarantee issued on behalf of an affiliate, and credit exposure from derivatives must be secured by qualifying collateral with a market value meeting strict statutory percentages at inception and throughout the transaction's life.
Statutory Collateral Margins
| Collateral Category | Statutory Minimum Collateral Requirement (% of Transaction Value) |
|---|---|
| Direct U.S. Obligations & Cash | 100% (Direct obligations of the U.S. or its agencies, obligations fully guaranteed by the U.S., or a segregated deposit account in the bank) |
| State & Municipal Obligations | 110% (Direct obligations of any U.S. State or political subdivision / municipal bonds) |
| Other Debt Instruments | 120% (Eligible corporate bonds, commercial paper, qualifying receivables) |
| Equities, Real Estate & Personal Property | 130% (Stocks, mutual fund shares, commercial/residential real estate, equipment, leases) |
Strictly Ineligible Collateral (§ 223.14(c))
The following assets are legally disqualified from serving as collateral for covered transactions:
- Securities Issued by an Affiliate or the Bank: A bank may never accept stock, bonds, notes, or debentures issued by the bank or any of its affiliates to collateralize an affiliate credit extension.
- Low-Quality Assets: Any classified, nonaccrual, or past-due asset cannot serve as qualifying collateral.
- Intangible Assets: Goodwill, patent rights, servicing assets, and trademark valuations cannot count toward collateral coverage.
A state non-member bank has capital stock and surplus of $50,000,000. The bank currently has $3,500,000 in outstanding covered transactions with Affiliate A (a sister mortgage company) and $4,000,000 in covered transactions with Affiliate B (a sister leasing company). Affiliate A requests a new loan of $2,000,000 to finance its loan warehouse operations. How does Regulation W (12 CFR Part 223) treat this proposed credit extension?
The loan is prohibited because total covered transactions with Affiliate A would reach $5,500,000, exceeding the 10% single-affiliate limit of $5,000,000.
The loan is prohibited because total transactions across all affiliates would exceed the bank's aggregate affiliate limit of 15% of capital stock and surplus.
The loan is permissible provided Affiliate A pledges 100% commercial real estate collateral to secure the entire balance.
The loan is permissible because the resulting aggregate total of $9,500,000 is below the 20% aggregate affiliate limit of $10,000,000.
A bank proposes to extend a $2,000,000 term loan to its sister real estate investment affiliate. The loan is to be secured by prime commercial real estate. Under Section 23A of the Federal Reserve Act and 12 CFR § 223.14, what is the minimum required market value of the commercial real estate collateral at the time the transaction is executed?
$2,000,000 (100% of the loan amount).
$2,400,000 (120% of the loan amount).
$2,200,000 (110% of the loan amount).
$2,600,000 (130% of the loan amount).
Identify covered transactions before measuring exposure
Covered transactions include loans and other credit to affiliates, purchases of affiliate securities, asset purchases from affiliates, acceptance of affiliate securities as collateral for third-party credit, and guarantees or letters of credit on affiliates’ behalf. The statute also reaches specified credit exposure from securities-financing and derivative transactions. A service fee can be subject to Section 23B without being a Section 23A covered transaction, so classify the arrangement before calculating a cap.
Ordinarily, Section 23A limits covered transactions with one affiliate to ten percent of capital stock and surplus and with all affiliates together to twenty percent. With fifty million dollars of the applicable capital base, the limits are five million and ten million dollars. Existing credit of three and a half million dollars to Affiliate A plus a proposed two-million-dollar loan produces five and a half million dollars, exceeding A’s single-affiliate limit even if aggregate affiliate exposure remains below ten million dollars. Collateral does not cure this excess. Check an asserted exemption under its own conditions and retain the safe-and-sound requirement where applicable.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.