27.3 Pulp Therapy in Primary Teeth
Key Takeaways
- Bleeding that arrests within three to five minutes after pulpal amputation confirms reversible inflammation and allows pulpotomy.
- Persistent bleeding beyond five minutes indicates irreversible pulpitis and requires pulpectomy or extraction.
- Mineral trioxide aggregate and Biodentine are the preferred pulpotomy medicaments; Buckley's formocresol is discouraged in UK practice.
- Primary pulpectomy files to 1.0 to 2.0 mm short of the radiographic apex and obturates with a resorbable paste.
- Pure zinc oxide eugenol resorbs more slowly than the tooth and can deflect the erupting successor, so resorbable iodoform pastes are often preferred.
4. Pulp Therapy in Primary Teeth
The primary objective of paediatric pulp therapy is to maintain the primary tooth in a functional, symptom-free state until normal physiological exfoliation, preventing arch space loss and avoiding infection of the underlying permanent tooth germ.
Diagnostic Decision Matrix for Primary Tooth Pulp Therapy
│
├── Transient, provoked pain (cold/sweet); resolves immediately; normal furcation radiograph
│ └── DIAGNOSIS: Reversible Pulpitis
│ │
│ └── Coronal pulp exposed during caries removal?
│ ├── NO ──> Indirect Pulp Capping (IPC) or Hall Technique
│ └── YES ──> PULPOTOMY (Coronal pulp amputation)
│ │
│ └── Haemostasis achieved with damp cotton pellet in ≤ 5 min?
│ ├── YES ──> Medicament (MTA / Biodentine / Ferric Sulphate) + PMC
│ └── NO ──> Radicular pulpitis: convert to PULPECTOMY or EXTRACTION
│
└── Spontaneous nocturnal throbbing; sinus/abscess; inter-radicular bone loss; non-vital
└── DIAGNOSIS: Irreversible Pulpitis / Necrosis
│
└── Is the tooth restorable with ≥ 1/3 root length remaining?
├── YES ──> PULPECTOMY (Resorbable paste obturation: ZOE or Vitapex) + PMC
└── NO ──> EXTRACTION (+/- Space Maintainer)
Diagnostic Differentiation: Reversible vs Irreversible Pulpitis
| Feature | Reversible Pulpitis | Irreversible Pulpitis / Necrosis |
|---|---|---|
| Pain Character | Provoked by thermal, chemical, or sweet stimuli; stops immediately upon removal of stimulus | Spontaneous, unprovoked throbbing pain; lingers after stimulus removal; nocturnal pain waking child |
| Analgesic Response | Does not require systemic analgesia | Often requires systemic analgesics (paracetamol/ibuprofen) |
| Soft Tissue Signs | Healthy gingival margins; no sinus tract, swelling, or redness | Sinus tract (parulis), localized gingival swelling, or buccal/palatal abscess |
| Mobility & Percussion | Normal physiological mobility; non-tender to vertical/horizontal percussion | Pathological mobility; tender to light percussion or mastication |
| Radiographic Signs | Clear inter-radicular bone architecture; intact lamina dura; normal PDL space | Inter-radicular furcation radiolucency; widened PDL; internal or pathological external resorption |
Vital Pulp Therapy
Indirect Pulp Capping (IPC)
Indicated in primary molars with deep carious lesions exhibiting reversible pulpitis, where caries excavation risks mechanical exposure:
- Caries is excavated selectively from the peripheral cavity margins to sound dentine.
- Demineralised affected dentine is left over the pulp chamber to avoid exposure.
- A biocompatible liner (calcium silicate cement, MTA, or resin-modified glass ionomer) is placed over the deep dentine, followed by an immediate hermetic seal with a PMC or composite.
Pulpotomy (Coronal Pulp Amputation)
Indicated when a vital primary tooth with reversible pulpitis undergoes mechanical or carious exposure of the coronal pulp during caries excavation.
- Protocol:
- Administer local anaesthetic and achieve rubber dam isolation.
- Deradiate and unroof the entire coronal pulp chamber with a high-speed sterile diamond bur, ensuring no dentine overhangs remain.
- Amputate all coronal pulp tissue down to the orifices of the root canals using a sharp sterile spoon excavator or a large sterile round bur at slow speed under light water cooling.
- Irrigate the chamber gently with sterile saline or water to flush debris.
- Haemostasis Verification (Critical Diagnostic Step): Place a sterile cotton pellet moistened with saline over the canal orifices and apply gentle pressure for 3 to 5 minutes.
- Successful Haemostasis: Bleeding arrests completely within 3–5 minutes. The radicular pulp is vital and non-inflamed. Proceed with pulpotomy medicament placement.
- Haemostasis Failure (> 5 minutes of persistent bleeding): The inflammatory process has propagated into the radicular pulp tissue (radicular pulpitis). Pulpotomy will fail. The clinician must convert the procedure to a pulpectomy or extract the tooth.
Pulpotomy Medicaments
| Medicament | Mode of Action | Clinical / Radiographic Success | Clinical Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mineral Trioxide Aggregate (MTA) | Biocompatible tricalcium silicate; releases calcium hydroxide; induces hard tissue dentine bridge formation | Superior success (> 95%) | Gold standard in UK practice; non-toxic, non-mutagenic; higher material cost |
| Biodentine | Dentine-replacement tricalcium silicate; releases $Ca(OH)_2$; bioactive | Equivalent to MTA (> 95%) | Faster setting time (~12 min); handles like dentine; no tooth discolouration |
| Ferric Sulphate (15.5%) | Chemical astringent; ferric and sulphate ions react with blood proteins forming a ferric ion-protein complex that agglutinates and mechanically plugs capillary orifices | High success (~75–85%) | Apply for 15 seconds; rinse thoroughly; does not stimulate dentine bridging; risk of internal resorption |
| Buckley's Formocresol | Fixative agent (formaldehyde + cresol); cellular protein cross-linking and mummification | Historically ~70–80% | Contraindicated / Discouraged: Formaldehyde is a known mutagen and carcinogen; distributes systemically; risk of enamel defects on permanent successors |
Non-Vital Pulp Therapy: Pulpectomy
Indicated in restorable primary molars presenting with irreversible pulpitis or pulpal necrosis, where maintaining the tooth is essential for space maintenance (particularly the second primary molar before the eruption of the first permanent molar).
Operative Protocol
- Complete access opening, canal orifice location, and pulp extirpation.
- Determine working length radiographically, establishing a limit 1.0 to 2.0 mm short of the radiographic apex to prevent over-instrumentation into the underlying permanent germ.
- Mechanically debride the canals using hand K-files up to size #30–#35 with gentle filing. Primary root dentine is thin; aggressive filing risks lateral perforation.
- Irrigate copiously with 0.5%–1.0% sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl), chlorhexidine (0.2%), or sterile saline.
- Dry canals thoroughly with sterile paper points.
- Obturation with Resorbable Paste: The root canals must be filled with a material that resorbs at a rate equivalent to physiological root resorption. Suitable pastes include:
- Pure Zinc Oxide Eugenol (ZOE) without setting catalyst/accelerators.
- Calcium Hydroxide and Iodoform Paste (Vitapex / Metapex): Superior resorption kinetics; resorbs rapidly if extruded beyond the apex without foreign body reaction.
- Definitive Restoration: The tooth must be sealed coronally with a Preformed Metal Crown (PMC) to prevent microleakage.
[!CAUTION] Strict Contraindication of Non-Resorbable Materials: Gutta-percha points, resin sealers, and non-resorbable pastes are strictly contraindicated for obturating primary teeth. As the primary roots resorb, non-resorbable materials do not degrade, remaining in the alveolar bone as a rigid physical obstruction that deflects or prevents the normal eruption of the succedaneous permanent tooth.
Materials and Medicaments
The materials used in primary pulp therapy are examinable in their own right. Ferric sulphate is used as a haemostatic and pulpotomy agent; mineral trioxide aggregate and other calcium silicate cements give high success rates but may discolour the crown; formocresol has largely been abandoned in UK practice on toxicity and carcinogenicity grounds. Root filling in a primary pulpectomy must use a resorbable material — conventionally a non-reinforced zinc oxide eugenol or an iodoform-based paste — so that it resorbs with the root and does not deflect the permanent successor. Using gutta-percha in a primary tooth is a reliable wrong answer.
The examinable decision rule is that pulp therapy is justified only when the tooth is restorable, the child can cooperate for the procedure, and the tooth has a useful lifespan ahead of it; otherwise extraction with appropriate space management is the correct plan.
Which of the following clinical presentations represents an absolute contraindication to placing a Preformed Metal Crown using the Hall Technique on a primary molar?