6.3 Deferred and Indexed Annuities
Key Takeaways
- Deferred annuities grow tax-deferred during accumulation; SPDA uses one premium, FPDA uses flexible premiums.
- Surrender charges decline over a multi-year schedule; a bailout provision allows penalty-free surrender if the current rate drops below a threshold.
- A fixed indexed annuity links interest to an index but guarantees a floor, so it is a fixed-annuity product with protected principal.
- Participation rate, cap, and spread all reduce the index-linked credit; apply participation first, then the cap.
- Indexed-annuity owners are not invested in the index, and FIAs are not variable annuities - a frequent exam trap.
Deferred Annuity Mechanics
A deferred annuity postpones income to a future date, allowing the contract value to grow tax-deferred during accumulation. It can be funded by a single premium (SPDA) or flexible premiums (FPDA). During accumulation the owner can surrender the contract or take partial withdrawals, subject to surrender charges and possible tax penalties; at the chosen maturity date the owner annuitizes into one of the standard payout options.
Key contractual values to distinguish:
- Accumulation value - total premiums plus credited interest.
- Cash (surrender) value - accumulation value minus any surrender charge.
- Death benefit during accumulation - generally the greater of accumulation value or premiums paid; if the annuitant dies before annuitization, the beneficiary receives this amount, avoiding probate.
Surrender Charges and the Bailout Provision
Deferred annuities impose a declining surrender charge to discourage early withdrawal, commonly a schedule such as 7% in year one, decreasing one point per year to 0% after seven years. Most contracts allow a free-withdrawal corridor - often 10% of value per year - without charge.
A bailout provision lets the owner surrender without penalty if the credited current rate falls more than a stated amount (e.g., 1%) below the rate at issue. Worked example: a $50,000 SPDA surrendered in year two with a 6% charge on the amount above the 10% free corridor yields a charge of 6% x ($50,000 - $5,000) = $2,700, so the owner nets $47,300 before tax.
Equity-Indexed (Fixed Indexed) Annuities
A fixed indexed annuity (FIA), also called an equity-indexed annuity, is legally a fixed annuity. It credits interest linked to an external index such as the S&P 500 but still guarantees a minimum return, so principal is protected. Because it is a general-account product with a floor, most states classify it as fixed (often no securities license required), though suitability scrutiny is high.
The defining feature is the combination of upside participation with a downside floor: in a down market the index credit is zero (or the small guaranteed minimum), never negative. The trade-off is that the owner does not capture the full index gain - several limiting features reduce it.
Indexed Crediting Features (Exam Vocabulary)
| Feature | Effect | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Participation rate | Percentage of index gain credited | 80% participation on a 10% index rise = 8% credit |
| Cap rate | Maximum credit regardless of index | 6% cap means a 12% index rise still credits only 6% |
| Spread/margin/asset fee | Subtracted from index gain | 2% spread on a 10% rise = 8% credit |
| Floor | Guaranteed minimum (often 0%) | A 20% index drop credits 0%, never negative |
Worked example: the index rises 10%. With an 80% participation rate the gross is 8%; if a 6% cap also applies, the credit is capped at 6%. If instead a 2% spread applies to the 10% gain, the credit is 8%. Candidates must apply participation first, then the cap, and recognize that the floor protects principal in losing years.
Common Traps
- An indexed annuity is not a variable annuity; principal is protected and the contract is a fixed-annuity chassis.
- The owner is not invested in the index - it is only a measuring benchmark for crediting interest.
- Caps, participation rates, and spreads are the reason actual credits trail raw index gains - this is the most-tested concept.
- Surrender periods on FIAs are often long (7-10 years), so suitability for older buyers is a regulatory hot spot.
A fixed indexed annuity has an 80% participation rate and a 7% cap. The reference index rises 12% this term. What interest is credited?
What happens to the credited interest of a fixed indexed annuity in a year the reference index falls 15%?