ANSI S3.22 Electroacoustic Analysis & Quality Control Standards

ANSI S3.22 Electroacoustic Analysis & Quality Control Standards

Electroacoustic analysis (EAA) of hearing aids provides an objective, standardized bench evaluation of hearing aid performance independent of the human ear canal. Governing all commercial hearing aids in the United States under Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulations, the ANSI S3.22 standard ("Specification of Hearing Aid Characteristics") establishes rigorous measurement protocols, standardized acoustic couplers, and tolerances. Audiologists must perform electroacoustic quality control on newly received devices prior to patient delivery, following manufacturer repairs, and whenever troubleshooting acoustic distortion or intermittent function.

---

Purpose and Regulatory Mandate of ANSI S3.22

While real-ear probe-microphone measurements assess the acoustic output delivered to an individual's unique ear canal, ANSI S3.22 electroacoustic analysis serves fundamentally different clinical objectives:

• Manufacturer Specification Compliance: Verifies that a newly manufactured or repaired hearing aid performs within the published engineering specifications filed with the FDA.
• Pre-Fitting Quality Control: Ensures that an instrument is defect-free before the patient arrives for their fitting appointment, eliminating fitting delays caused by dead receivers, excessive internal noise, or harmonic distortion.
• Repair Verification: Objectively determines whether a manufacturer repair successfully resolved an internal failure or introduced new transducer artifacts.
• Diagnostic Troubleshooting: Objectively differentiates patient perceptual complaints (e.g., loudness intolerance, speech muffling) from true hardware degradation (e.g., failed internal dampers, cracked receiver suspensions, moisture damage).

---

Test Chamber Instrumentation & Coupler Acoustics

Electroacoustic analysis is conducted inside an anechoic sound-attenuating test box to prevent ambient room noise from corrupting low-frequency measurements. The test system comprises three primary electroacoustic components:

1. Calibrated Reference Loudspeaker: Delivers controlled acoustic signals across the audio bandwidth ($100$ to $10,000\,\text{Hz}$).
2. Reference Regulating Microphone: Positioned adjacent to the hearing aid's microphone sound inlet; continuously samples sound field intensity to dynamically adjust (level) loudspeaker output, maintaining an exact input level (e.g., $50, 60, 70,$ or $90\,\text{dB SPL}$).
3. 2-cc Coupler & Coupler Measurement Microphone: Simulates the nominal acoustic impedance of an average adult ear canal occluded by an earmold. The coupler terminates in a precision laboratory-grade measurement microphone.

Standardized 2-cc Coupler Types

Selecting the correct 2-cc coupler is critical to prevent severe acoustic artifacts in measured gain and output:

Clinical Warning: Sealing a standard BTE instrument into an HA-1 coupler with putty without the standardized $25\,\text{mm}$ length of #13 tubing abolishes the natural acoustic quarter-wave resonance of the tubing, generating massive high-frequency measurement errors that violate ANSI testing protocols.

---

Maximum Output & Full-On Gain (FOG) Metrics

ANSI S3.22 specifies two primary measurements with the hearing aid volume/gain control set to Full-On and all adaptive digital features (noise reduction, feedback suppression, directionality) disabled in specialized "test mode."

1. OSPL90 (Output Sound Pressure Level with $90\,\text{dB SPL}$ Input)

The OSPL90 curve evaluates the absolute maximum acoustic saturation output the instrument can generate across frequency when driven by an intense $90\,\text{dB SPL}$ swept pure tone:

• Maximum OSPL90: The highest sound pressure level recorded at any single frequency along the entire swept curve.
  • ANSI Tolerance: Measured Maximum OSPL90 must not exceed the manufacturer's specification by more than $+3\,\text{dB}$.
  • Clinical Significance: This is a critical patient safety parameter; an instrument exceeding its maximum output specification risks delivering sound pressures that exceed the patient's loudness discomfort levels, causing acoustic trauma.
• High-Frequency Average OSPL90 (HFA-OSPL90): The linear mathematical average of OSPL90 sound pressure levels at $1000\,\text{Hz}$, $1600\,\text{Hz}$, and $2500\,\text{Hz}$: $\text{HFA-OSPL90} = \frac{\text{OSPL90}_{1000} + \text{OSPL90}_{1600} + \text{OSPL90}_{2500}}{3}$
  • ANSI Tolerance: Measured HFA-OSPL90 must fall within $\pm 4\,\text{dB}$ of the manufacturer's published specification.
  • Special Purpose Average (SPA): If the hearing aid's frequency response does not span the standard HFA frequencies, the manufacturer specifies three alternative frequencies separated by at least two-thirds of an octave.

2. Full-On Gain (FOG) at $50\,\text{dB SPL}$ Input

Full-On Gain evaluates the total amplification capacity of the device when driven by a low-level input ($50\,\text{dB SPL}$) to ensure the amplifier operates linearly without saturating:

• High-Frequency Average Full-On Gain (HFA-FOG): The average gain across $1000\,\text{Hz}$, $1600\,\text{Hz}$, and $2500\,\text{Hz}$ with input at $50\,\text{dB SPL}$ and gain control at maximum: $\text{HFA-FOG} = \frac{\text{FOG}_{1000} + \text{FOG}_{1600} + \text{FOG}_{2500}}{3}$
  • ANSI Tolerance: Measured HFA-FOG must fall within $\pm 5\,\text{dB}$ of the manufacturer's published specification.

---

Reference Test Setting (RTS) & Reference Test Gain (RTG)

Modern hearing aids cannot be tested for distortion, internal noise, or bandwidth at Full-On Gain because a moderate input signal ($60\,\text{dB SPL}$) would drive the amplifier into deep non-linear saturation. The Reference Test Setting (RTS) defines a standardized gain control position that models typical conversational listening without saturation.

Mathematical Formulation of RTS

The Reference Test Setting is calculated directly from the measured HFA-OSPL90: $\text{RTS Target Gain} = \text{HFA-OSPL90} - 77\,\text{dB}$

Step-by-Step Procedure for Setting RTS:

1. Determine the measured HFA-OSPL90 from the initial $90\,\text{dB SPL}$ sweep.
2. Calculate the target output for a $60\,\text{dB SPL}$ input: $\text{Target Coupler Output} = 60\,\text{dB} + \text{RTS Target Gain} = 60\,\text{dB} + (\text{HFA-OSPL90} - 77\,\text{dB}) = \text{HFA-OSPL90} - 17\,\text{dB}$
3. Present a $60\,\text{dB SPL}$ input tone (or speech-shaped noise) at the HFA frequencies ($1000, 1600, 2500\,\text{Hz}$).
4. Adjust the hearing aid gain control downward until the measured HFA output matches $\text{HFA-OSPL90} - 17\,\text{dB}$ within $\pm 1.5\,\text{dB}$.
5. The RTS Exception Rule: If the hearing aid's Full-On Gain (HFA-FOG) is less than $(\text{HFA-OSPL90} - 77\,\text{dB})$, the volume control is left at Full-On Gain (i.e., $\text{RTS} = \text{FOG}$). In mild-gain hearing aids, full-on gain does not provide enough amplification to saturate the amplifier at $60\,\text{dB SPL}$.

---

Frequency Response Curve & Frequency Bandwidth ($f_1$ & $f_2$)

With the hearing aid set to RTS, a $60\,\text{dB SPL}$ input signal (or $50\,\text{dB SPL}$ if specified) is presented to record the Reference Test Frequency Response Curve:

1. Determine HFA Response: Calculate the average sound pressure level across $1000, 1600,$ and $2500\,\text{Hz}$ on the frequency response curve.
2. Establish the Response Limit Line: Subtract $20\,\text{dB}$ from the calculated HFA response: $\text{Response Limit} = \text{HFA Response} - 20\,\text{dB}$ Draw a horizontal line across the frequency chart at this exact sound pressure level.
3. Identify Cutoff Frequencies:
   • Low-Frequency Cutoff ($f_1$): The lowest frequency at which the frequency response curve crosses the $20\,\text{dB}$ response limit line.
   • High-Frequency Cutoff ($f_2$): The highest frequency at which the frequency response curve crosses the $20\,\text{dB}$ response limit line.
4. Frequency Range: Stated as $f_1$ to $f_2$. ANSI S3.22 reports this range for information only; it carries no tolerance.
   • Response-Curve Tolerance: Instead, the frequency response curve must stay within $\pm 4\,\text{dB}$ of specification in the low band (from the higher of $1.25 f_1$ or $200\,\text{Hz}$ up to $2000\,\text{Hz}$) and within $\pm 6\,\text{dB}$ in the high band (from $2000\,\text{Hz}$ to the lower of $4000\,\text{Hz}$ or $0.8 f_2$).

---

Total Harmonic Distortion (THD)

Harmonic distortion occurs when non-linear amplifier or transducer behavior generates unwanted acoustic energy at integer multiples of the input fundamental frequency ($2f, 3f, 4f$):

• Measurement Parameters: Measured with the hearing aid positioned at RTS:
  • At $500\,\text{Hz}$ using a $70\,\text{dB SPL}$ input.
  • At $800\,\text{Hz}$ using a $70\,\text{dB SPL}$ input.
  • At $1600\,\text{Hz}$ using a $65\,\text{dB SPL}$ input.
• The $12\,\text{dB}$ Rule Exemption: If the frequency response curve displays a sharp peak at $2f$ (the second harmonic) that rises $12\,\text{dB}$ or more above the response at the fundamental frequency $f$, harmonic distortion at that test frequency is exempt from compliance testing. Acoustic resonant peaks artificially inflate measured distortion percentages through acoustic resonance rather than true transducer non-linearity.
• ANSI Tolerance: Measured THD at each frequency must not exceed the manufacturer's published specification by more than $+3\%$ (e.g., if the manufacturer specification is $2\%$, a measured distortion up to $5\%$ passes; $5.1\%$ fails).

---

Internal Circuit Noise: Equivalent Input Noise (EIN)

Equivalent Input Noise (EIN) quantifies the internal thermal and electrical circuit noise generated by the microphone and pre-amplifier, expressed as the equivalent acoustic input level required to generate that noise at the output:

Mathematical Formulation

$\text{EIN} = L_{\text{noise}} - \text{HFA gain at RTS}$ where:

• $L_{\text{noise}}$ is the HFA sound pressure level measured in the 2-cc coupler with the input signal turned off while the hearing aid is at RTS.
• The HFA gain is measured at RTS with a $50\,\text{dB SPL}$ input (the HFA coupler output minus 50 dB).

ANSI Tolerance & Clinical Rejection Criteria

• ANSI Tolerance: Measured EIN must not exceed the manufacturer's published specification by more than $+3\,\text{dB SPL}$.
• Clinical Threshold: High-performing modern digital hearing aids exhibit an $\text{EIN} < 25-28\,\text{dB SPL}$. When an instrument's EIN exceeds $30$ to $32\,\text{dB SPL}$, patients with normal or near-normal low-frequency thresholds will perceive an audible, distracting internal "hissing," "frying," or "rushing water" circuit noise, resulting in immediate device rejection.

---

Battery Drain, Telecoil & Directional Quality Verification

Battery Current Drain Test

• Measurement Setup: The hearing aid's physical battery is replaced with a calibrated "battery simulator pill" connected to a regulated DC power supply delivering nominal operating voltage ($1.30\,\text{V}$ for Zinc-Air; $3.80\,\text{V}$ for rechargeable Lithium-Ion).
• Protocol: Evaluated at RTS using a $1000\,\text{Hz}$ pure tone at $65\,\text{dB SPL}$.
• ANSI Tolerance: Measured current drain (in milliamperes, $\text{mA}$) must not exceed the manufacturer's specification by more than $+20\%$.
• Battery Life Estimation Formula: $\text{Battery Operating Hours} = \frac{\text{Battery Capacity (mAh)}}{\text{Measured Current Drain (mA)}}$ Clinical Example: A Size 312 Zinc-Air battery with a nominal capacity of $160\,\text{mAh}$ powered in a hearing aid with a measured current drain of $1.6\,\text{mA}$ yields an expected battery life of $\frac{160}{1.6} = 100\,\text{hours}$ (approximately $6-7\,\text{days}$ at $15\,\text{hours/day}$).

Telecoil / Induction Coil Verification (SPLITS)

• Simulator Field: The hearing aid is switched to telecoil mode and placed inside a standardized Telephone Magnetic Field Simulator (TMFS) producing a magnetic field strength of $31.6\,\text{mA/m}$.
• SPLITS (Coupler Sound Pressure Level for an Inductive Telephone Simulator): Measured across frequency with the gain control at the reference test setting (RTS).
• HFA-SPLITS: Average of SPLITS at $1000, 1600,$ and $2500\,\text{Hz}$.
  • ANSI Tolerance: Measured HFA-SPLITS must fall within $\pm 6\,\text{dB}$ of manufacturer specification.
• Relative Simulated Equivalent Telephone Sensitivity (RSETS): Compares telecoil output with microphone output: $\text{RSETS} = \text{HFA-SPLITS} - (\text{RTG} + 60\,\text{dB})$. A value near $0\,\text{dB}$ means the telecoil sounds about as loud as the microphone does for typical speech.

Directional Microphone Test Box Verification

Directional microphone verification compares frequency sweeps presented at $0^\circ$ azimuth (front) versus $180^\circ$ azimuth (rear) inside the test box:

• Front-to-Back Ratio (FBR): The difference in output between $0^\circ$ and $180^\circ$, typically providing $15$ to $25\,\text{dB}$ of low-to-mid frequency attenuation for sounds originating from the rear.
• Clinical Artifact: Physical occlusion of the rear microphone port by debris, wax, or skin oil collapses the directional polar pattern into an omnidirectional mode, eliminating background noise suppression.

---

ANSI S3.22 Tolerance Summary Reference Table