6.6 Liability and Protection
Key Takeaways
- Montana requires a notary surety bond (currently $25,000 per the Secretary of State) that protects the PUBLIC, not the notary.
- If the surety pays a claim, it may seek full reimbursement from the notary, who remains personally liable.
- Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance is optional and protects the NOTARY; good-faith refusals and a complete journal are your best defense.
Two Very Different Safety Nets
New notaries constantly confuse the surety bond with Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance. They are opposites: the bond protects the public and the insurance protects the notary. This distinction is one of the most heavily tested concepts in the chapter.
The Surety Bond
Montana requires every notary to file a surety bond before commissioning. The Secretary of State's current requirement is a $25,000 bond (raised from the older $10,000 statutory figure — always go by the SOS's current guidance).
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Amount | $25,000 (current SOS requirement) |
| Who it protects | The public |
| Against what | The notary's errors, negligence, or misconduct |
| How claims work | An injured member of the public files a claim against the bond |
What the Bond Does NOT Do
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Protect the notary | No — it protects the public |
| End the notary's liability | No — the notary stays personally liable |
| Forgive the payout | No — the surety can seek full reimbursement from the notary |
So if the surety pays a $20,000 claim to a defrauded homebuyer, the surety company can then bill the notary for that $20,000. This is the single most misunderstood point about the bond, and the exam exploits it: candidates assume that because they 'have a bond,' they are covered. They are not. The bond is a guarantee to the public that funds exist to compensate them; it is not insurance for the notary. The bond amount is also a cap on what the public can recover from the bond itself — it does not cap the notary's total personal liability, which can exceed the bond if a court awards more in damages.
The notary remains on the hook for the difference, on top of repaying the surety.
Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance
E&O is optional and is purchased by the notary to protect themselves.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Required? | No — optional but strongly recommended |
| Who it protects | The notary |
| Coverage | Unintentional errors and omissions |
| Often covers | Legal defense costs |
Bond vs. E&O at a Glance
| Feature | Surety Bond | E&O Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Required | Yes | No |
| Protects | Public | Notary |
| Amount | $25,000 | Varies by policy |
| Reimbursement risk to notary | Surety can recover | None |
When Liability Arises
| Situation | Likely Claim |
|---|---|
| Notarizing without the signer present | Fraud, negligence |
| Failing to verify identity | Negligence |
| Using the wrong certificate type | Negligence/error |
| Ignoring obvious coercion or red flags | Negligence |
| Giving legal advice | UPL / malpractice exposure |
Good-Faith Refusals Are Protected
Montana protects notaries who refuse a notarization for legitimate reasons. You are generally safe declining when:
- You cannot reasonably verify the signer's identity.
- You suspect fraud, duress, or coercion.
- The signer appears mentally incompetent or unaware of the act.
- Required personal appearance or proper procedure is missing.
Refusing for an improper reason — such as the signer's race, religion, or national origin — is not protected and can itself be misconduct. The distinction the exam draws is between a refusal grounded in a genuine notarial concern (identity, willingness, awareness, proper procedure) and a refusal grounded in bias or convenience. 'I won't notarize because I can't confirm who you are' is protected; 'I won't notarize because I don't like your accent' is discrimination.
When you do refuse, the safest practice is to state the procedural reason plainly, decline politely, and note the encounter — never lecture the signer or accuse them of fraud, which can expose you to a defamation claim.
Worked Example
A frail, confused elderly man is brought in by a relative who answers all the notary's questions for him and pushes a deed transferring the man's house to that relative. The notary reasonably doubts the signer understands or freely consents, and declines in good faith — a protected refusal. Proceeding could expose the notary to a negligence claim against the bond.
Your Best Practical Defense
| Practice | Protection It Provides |
|---|---|
| Complete, accurate journal | Evidence the act was proper; retained 10 years |
| Verify identity every time | Defense against fraud/forgery claims |
| Use the correct certificate | Defense against 'wrong act' claims |
| Refuse when red flags appear | Avoids the liability entirely |
| Carry E&O insurance | Pays claims/defense so the surety doesn't bill you |
If a Claim Arises
- Do not admit fault — contact your attorney or insurer first.
- Gather documentation — journal entry, certificate copies.
- Notify the surety if a bond claim is filed.
- Notify your E&O carrier if you have coverage.
- Consult an attorney for guidance.
On the Exam
- Bond protects the public, not the notary.
- $25,000 is the current SOS-required bond amount.
- Surety can seek reimbursement — the notary stays personally liable.
- E&O is optional and protects the notary.
- Good-faith refusals are protected; the journal is your evidence.
What is the key difference between the surety bond and Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance for a Montana notary?
After a surety company pays a claim from a Montana notary's bond, what may the surety company do?
An elderly, confused signer is pushed by a relative to transfer his house, and the relative answers all questions for him. What is the notary's safest, protected course of action?
You've completed this section
Continue exploring other exams