5.4 Procurement Management
Key Takeaways
- Procurement management acquires goods, services, or results from outside the project team across three processes: Plan, Conduct, and Control Procurements.
- Fixed-price contracts put the most risk on the seller; cost-reimbursable contracts put the most risk on the buyer; Time and Materials sits in the middle with shared risk.
- FFP is the most seller-risk contract and CPFF/CPAF carry the most buyer risk; the order from buyer-risk to seller-risk is CPAF/CPFF, CPIF, T&M, FPEPA, FPIF, FFP.
- Procurement solicitation documents differ by intent: RFI gathers information, RFQ gets prices, RFP requests full proposals, and IFB seeks sealed bids (lowest price).
- The make-or-buy analysis weighs cost, core competency, capacity, control, and risk transfer to decide whether to perform work internally or contract it out.
What Procurement Management Covers
Procurement management is the set of processes used to purchase or acquire products, services, or results from outside the project team. On the CAPM you must know the three processes, the major contract types and their risk profiles, the solicitation documents, and the make-or-buy decision.
| Process | Process Group | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Plan Procurement Management | Planning | Decide what to buy, how, and document make-or-buy decisions |
| Conduct Procurements | Executing | Obtain seller responses, select sellers, award contracts |
| Control Procurements | Monitoring & Controlling | Manage contracts, performance, changes, and closure |
Contract Types and Where Risk Sits
Fixed-Price (seller carries the risk)
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Firm Fixed-Price (FFP) | One set price for defined scope; no adjustment. Seller absorbs any overrun. |
| Fixed-Price Incentive Fee (FPIF) | Fixed price plus a bonus for hitting targets (cost, schedule, performance). |
| Fixed-Price with Economic Price Adjustment (FPEPA) | Fixed price with clauses to adjust for inflation/currency over long terms. |
Cost-Reimbursable (buyer carries the risk)
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Cost Plus Fixed Fee (CPFF) | All allowable costs reimbursed plus a flat fee. Buyer absorbs overruns. |
| Cost Plus Incentive Fee (CPIF) | Costs reimbursed plus a fee that varies by performance; cost savings shared. |
| Cost Plus Award Fee (CPAF) | Costs reimbursed plus a fee based on the buyer's subjective evaluation. |
Time and Materials (shared risk)
T&M sets fixed unit rates (e.g., $120/hour) but leaves total hours open. Risk is shared: the rate protects the buyer, but open hours expose them, while the seller is guaranteed its margin on each hour. T&M suits work whose scope is not yet defined, such as staff augmentation or early-stage support.
The Risk Spectrum
Most Buyer Risk <------------------------> Most Seller Risk
CPAF / CPFF -> CPIF -> T&M -> FPEPA -> FPIF -> FFP
Exam Tip: Anchor on the two ends. FFP = max seller risk (they eat any overrun). CPFF/CPAF = max buyer risk (the buyer reimburses whatever the seller spends). If a question describes a well-defined scope and a buyer wanting cost certainty, the answer is usually FFP. If scope is fuzzy and the buyer accepts cost risk, it points to a cost-reimbursable or T&M contract.
Solicitation and Procurement Documents
| Document | Intent | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| RFI (Request for Information) | Gather general market/capability info | Early research, no commitment |
| RFQ (Request for Quotation) | Obtain prices for a clearly defined item | Scope is well understood |
| RFP (Request for Proposal) | Request full proposals incl. approach + price | Complex or undefined solutions |
| IFB (Invitation for Bid) | Solicit sealed bids; lowest qualified price wins | Government/public works |
| SOW (Statement of Work) | Describe the procured item in enough detail to bid | Attached to the solicitation |
Distinguish them by what the buyer wants back: information (RFI), a price (RFQ), a solution proposal (RFP), or a competitive bid (IFB). The SOW is not a solicitation by itself; it is the detailed scope description that sellers price against.
The Make-or-Buy Decision
The make-or-buy analysis decides whether to perform work internally (make) or contract it (buy):
| Factor | Favors Make | Favors Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Core competency | It is core to the business | It is not core |
| Capacity / skills | Available internally | Not available |
| Cost | Cheaper in-house | Cheaper externally |
| Control | Need tight quality/schedule control | Acceptable to delegate |
| Risk | Keep risk in-house | Transfer risk to seller |
Source Selection Criteria
When evaluating proposals, the team weighs cost/price, technical capability, management approach, past performance, financial stability, and risk. Lowest price alone is rarely the sole criterion outside a pure IFB.
Conduct Procurements in Practice
Conduct Procurements is where solicitations meet the market. Typical tools include bidder conferences (also called contractor, vendor, or pre-bid conferences) where all prospective sellers gather and ask questions, ensuring every bidder has the same information and no one gets an unfair advantage. Proposal evaluation applies the source selection criteria, often via a weighted scoring matrix. Negotiation then settles price, schedule, responsibilities, and terms before the contract is signed. The major output is a signed agreement (contract) plus selected sellers and resource calendars.
Control Procurements and Closure
Control Procurements manages each contract through its life: tracking seller performance, processing approved change requests (a contract can only be changed through its formal change-control clauses), making payments, and handling claims. A claim is a contested change where buyer and seller disagree on compensation; if they cannot settle it, the contract's alternative dispute resolution (ADR) clause applies, with negotiation preferred and arbitration or litigation as fallbacks.
When work is accepted and obligations are met, the procurement reaches closure, including final payment, formal acceptance, and an updated lessons-learned record. Note that a contract is a legal document, so terminating it early follows the termination clause, not a casual decision.
Procurement Roles and Authority
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Buyer | The party acquiring the product or service (often the project's organization) |
| Seller / vendor / contractor | The party providing the product or service |
| Procurement administrator | Person with authority to sign and amend contracts |
Exam Tip: In many organizations the PM cannot sign contracts — only a designated contracting officer or procurement department can. If a scenario asks who authorizes a contract change, the answer often is not the project manager acting alone but the formal procurement authority following the change-control process. Always route contract changes through the documented procedure rather than an informal verbal agreement with the vendor.
Which contract type places the MOST risk on the buyer?
A buyer needs a complex new system, the solution approach is open, and they want sellers to propose methodology, technical approach, AND price. Which document should they issue?
Scope is clearly and completely defined, and the buyer wants maximum cost certainty with the overrun risk on the seller. Which contract is the best fit?
Match each contract type with the party that bears the MOST risk:
Match each item on the left with the correct item on the right