Recorded Statements, EUOs and Technical Experts

Recorded Statements, EUOs and Technical Experts

Interviews, examinations under oath and expert reports supply different evidence. Obtain required consent, respect California EUO safeguards and test the basis of technical conclusions.

Witness and Claimant Recorded Statements: Penal Code § 632

Interviewing claimants, policyholders, and independent witnesses is essential to determine liability and verify coverage. However, in California, taking recorded statements is strictly controlled by criminal statute.

Protocol for Taking Recorded Statements

To comply with CPC § 632 and industry standards, an adjuster must follow a structured interview architecture:

Obtain consent before starting a confidential recorded conversation, then confirm that consent on the recording. Document who consented and any limitations; do not record first and seek permission afterward.

• Current date, time, and location.
• Full name of the adjuster and adjusting firm.
• Full legal name and contact details of the interviewee.
• Explicit question: "Do you understand that this conversation is being recorded, and do I have your permission to record this statement?" (Obtain and preserve clear consent; the suggested wording is a protocol, not a statutory script).

1. Background Information: Confirm employment, address, driving credentials, vehicle ownership, or property ownership.
2. Uninterrupted Narrative: Ask broad, open-ended questions: "Please describe what happened in your own words from the time you left home until the accident occurred." Allow the witness to provide their full account without premature interruptions.
3. Targeted Follow-up Inquiries: Ask specific questions clarifying timeline, speed, distances, weather conditions, lighting, maintenance history, pre-existing physical damage, and seatbelt usage or smoke alarm functionality.
4. Closing Affirmation: Conclude the statement by asking:
   • "Have you understood all of my questions?"
   • "Have your statements been true and correct to the best of your knowledge?"
   • "Do you confirm that this statement was recorded with your full knowledge and consent, and that no promises or threats were made to induce you to provide it?"

---

Examination Under Oath (EUO)

An Examination Under Oath (EUO) is a contractual sworn examination grounded in the standard property insurance contract and codified in the California Standard Form Fire Policy under California Insurance Code (CIC) § 2071.

California safeguards and noncooperation

Under CIC § 2071.1 the insurer must provide the statute with its EUO notice. Questions must be relevant and reasonably necessary to process/investigate the claim, and the notice, place and length must be reasonable. The insured may have counsel, record the examination and make sworn corrections. On request, a transcript and any existing recording must be provided free, within ten business days after the insurer or its counsel receives them. Objections available in depositions may be asserted; failure to answer a material question that prevents determination of loss/validity can affect contractual rights.

Unjustified refusal to comply with a valid, material EUO duty can bar recovery, but a claimed objection or scheduling problem is not automatic forfeiture. Document the request, relevance, accommodation, responses and applicable legal analysis. A routine adjuster interview is not converted into an EUO merely because the witness says the answers are true.

---

Retaining and Evaluating Outside Technical Experts

In complex, catastrophic, or suspicious losses, the adjuster must recognize when a determination requires specialized scientific expertise beyond standard adjusting competence:

• Certified Fire Investigators (CFI): Certified through the International Association of Arson Investigators (IAAI) or National Association of Fire Investigators (NAFI). They use applicable scientific fire-investigation methods, including relevant NFPA 921 guidance, to evaluate origin and cause. A pattern alone does not prove an accelerant or intentional fire.
• Forensic Structural Engineers: Investigate foundation failures, earth movement, wind vs. wave damage, load-bearing failure, structural collapse, and building code compliance.
• Accident Reconstructionists: Evaluate vehicle crash dynamics, download Electronic Data Recorders (EDRs or "black boxes"), calculate pre-impact vehicle speeds, and analyze crush damage.
• Forensic Accountants: Quantify complex commercial Business Interruption (BI), Extra Expense, and inventory loss claims.

Adjusters must objectively review expert reports to ensure conclusions are grounded in reliable scientific methodology, physical evidence, and verifiable testing rather than speculation.

California EUO safeguards

CIC § 2071.1 requires reasonable notice, permits the insured's representation by counsel and limits questions to matters relevant to the claim. The insurer must state that the insured may obtain a transcript and may record the examination. Accommodation and reasonable scheduling matter. An ordinary voluntary recorded interview and a contractual examination under oath are different evidence-gathering methods; an adjuster should explain which is being requested.