1.2 The Schematic Design Phase & Multi-Discipline Workflow

1.2 The Schematic Design Phase & Multi-Discipline Workflow

The Schematic Design (SD) phase represents the transition from abstract programmatic data to tangible architectural form. During SD, the architect evaluates the owner's program, schedule, budget, site conditions, and regulatory constraints to develop preliminary design solutions exploring spatial relationships, scale, building massing, and basic technical systems.

Because decisions made during Schematic Design establish fundamental structural grids, vertical core locations, mechanical plant strategies, and floor-to-floor heights, effective multi-disciplinary coordination at this early phase is essential to avoid catastrophic redesigns during Design Development (DD) and Construction Documents (CD).

---

Contractual Framework: AIA Document B101-2017

The executed owner–architect agreement establishes the architect's services. AIA B101-2017 Article 3.2 is a common framework for Schematic Design, but it may be modified. Review the actual agreement rather than treating a model contract as a statute.

Key Architect Obligations Under Article 3.2

Schematic Design includes reviewing the program and budget, evaluating site and regulatory constraints, exploring alternatives, and preparing documents and a preliminary cost estimate for the owner's review. B101 calls for submission of the Schematic Design documents and an estimate of the Cost of the Work and a request for owner approval. The executed agreement determines documentation and authorization requirements; do not invent a universal written-approval clause or rely on an unverified subsection number.

---

Standard Schematic Design Deliverables

Schematic Design deliverables communicate the project's conceptual scale, aesthetic character, and technical feasibility without documenting exact construction fastening or complete specifications.

---

Multi-Disciplinary Coordination Workflow

The architect acts as the primary integrator (the "master coordinator") of all engineering consultants. During Schematic Design, key technical inputs from each discipline establish fundamental spatial and financial boundaries:

1. Civil & Geotechnical Engineering

• Geotechnical data: Use the geotechnical report to evaluate allowable bearing, total and differential settlement, seasonal groundwater, expansive or collapsible soils, and seismic site classification. Low bearing or high groundwater calls for comparison of engineered foundations, drainage, waterproofing and basement alternatives; a single bearing number does not automatically require piles or prohibit a basement.

• Civil site utilities: Coordinate utility location, capacity and invert elevations. Fixtures that cannot discharge by gravity to an approved sewer connection may require an ejector system; a basement without such fixtures does not automatically require one merely because its floor is below the municipal sewer.

• Stormwater Management: Site retention/detention pond footprints, pervious surfacing ratios, and bio-swale requirements determine buildable site boundaries.

2. Structural Engineering

• Bay Spacing & Grid Alignment: Coordinating column grid spacing (e.g., $30\text{ ft} \times 30\text{ ft}$ for steel or $20\text{ ft} \times 25\text{ ft}$ for concrete flat slab) with subterranean parking layouts and upper-level partitions.

• Member Depth Allowances: Rule-of-thumb structural depth sizing determines preliminary floor-to-floor heights. For example, a steel beam spanning $30\text{ ft}$ with a depth-to-span ratio of $L/20$ requires a structural depth of $18\text{ inches}$ ($360\text{ inches} / 20$), plus fireproofing.

• Lateral Resisting System: Locating shear walls around vertical elevator/stair cores or positioning perimeter braced frames where they do not obstruct vision glazing or doors.

3. Mechanical (HVAC), Electrical & Plumbing (MEP)

• Central Plant Space Requirements: Boilers, chillers, and primary air handling units (AHUs) typically require $2\%\text{ to }4\%$ of the building's gross area. Mechanical rooms must be positioned for outdoor air intake and exhaust louvers.

• Vertical Shafts: Primary supply and return duct chases require approximately $15\text{ to }25\text{ square feet}$ per $10,000\text{ square feet}$ of conditioned floor area and must align vertically through all stories.

• Electrical Service & Switchgear: Utility transformers (dry-type interior vs. liquid-filled exterior pad-mounted), main switchboard clearances, and emergency generator ventilation/fuel storage routing.

• Plumbing Chases: Wet-column stacking for public restrooms, kitchenettes, and laboratory drainage, ensuring adequate gravity slope for sanitary piping ($1/4\text{ in/ft}$ for pipes $\le 2.5\text{ inches}$; $1/8\text{ in/ft}$ for pipes $3\text{ to }6\text{ inches}$).

---

Spatial Organization: Adjacency Matrices & Bubble Diagrams

Before drafting formal floor plans, architects use abstract diagrammatic tools to verify functional relationships:

• Adjacency Matrix: A two-dimensional chart indexing every programmed space against all other spaces to designate degrees of required proximity: Direct Access (contiguous doors), Convenient Access (adjacent across a common corridor), Neutral / No Preference, or Separation Required (acoustic, visual, security, or hazardous contamination buffers).

• Bubble Diagrams: Graphic translations of the adjacency matrix representing programmatic spaces as proportional circular bubbles connected by directional vectors representing circulation flows, sightlines, and acoustic boundaries.

• Blocking & Stacking Diagrams: In multi-story structures, "stacking" determines the vertical assignment of program components (e.g., public retail on Ground Level, conference centers on Level 2, private offices on Levels 3–8), while "blocking" establishes horizontal departmental boundaries on individual floor plates.

---

Building Area Efficiencies & Net-to-Gross Calculations

A critical responsibility during Schematic Design is converting the owner's net functional program into a realistic gross building footprint that complies with zoning setbacks and Floor Area Ratio (FAR) caps.

Area Definitions

• Net Assignable Area (NSF / Net Square Feet): The actual usable floor space assigned to specific functional activities (e.g., private offices, classrooms, patient treatment rooms, retail sales floor). NSF excludes circulation, restrooms, and shafts.

• Tare Area (Unassignable Area): The supplementary space required to service the net functional areas, including corridors, lobbies, exit stairs, elevators, mechanical/electrical rooms, pipe chases, public restrooms, and structural column/wall thicknesses.

• Gross Square Footage (GSF): The total constructed building area measured to the exterior face of enclosure walls, encompassing all enclosed floor plates: $\text{GSF} = \text{NSF} + \text{Tare Area}$.

The Efficiency Ratio Formula

The relationship between net and gross area is expressed through the Efficiency Ratio:

$\text{Efficiency Ratio} = \frac{\text{Net Assignable Square Feet (NSF)}}{\text{Gross Square Feet (GSF)}}$

$\text{Gross Square Feet (GSF)} = \frac{\text{Net Assignable Square Feet (NSF)}}{\text{Efficiency Ratio}}$

Typical Building Type Efficiency Benchmarks

---

Worked Scenario: Net-to-Gross Sizing for a Municipal Branch Library

Scenario

A municipal library authority provides a functional program requiring $28,000\text{ NSF}$ of functional space (reading rooms, stacks, children's pavilion, staff offices, and meeting halls). Historical data indicates that branch libraries achieve a building efficiency ratio of $70\%$ ($0.70$). The zoning ordinance limits maximum lot coverage to $40\%$ on a $50,000\text{ square foot}$ parcel, and restricts building height to two stories.

Step-by-Step Resolution

1. Step 1: Calculate Total Required Gross Square Footage (GSF)

   • $\text{Required GSF} = \frac{\text{NSF}}{\text{Efficiency Ratio}} = \frac{28,000\text{ NSF}}{0.70} = 40,000\text{ GSF}$.
   • Unassignable Tare Area = $40,000 - 28,000 = 12,000\text{ square feet}$ (dedicated to lobbies, stairs, elevator, mechanical rooms, restrooms, and wall footprints).

2. Step 2: Determine Footprint for a 2-Story Massing

   • Assuming equal floor distribution: $\text{Building Footprint} = \frac{40,000\text{ GSF}}{2\text{ stories}} = 20,000\text{ square feet}$.

3. Step 3: Verify Zoning Lot Coverage Compliance

   • $\text{Maximum Allowable Lot Coverage} = 50,000\text{ sq ft parcel} \times 0.40 = 20,000\text{ square feet}$.
   • The proposed footprint ($20,000\text{ sq ft}$) exactly matches the maximum allowable coverage ($20,000\text{ sq ft}$), satisfying this coverage test. Setbacks, FAR, access, height, area and other applicable requirements still require separate checks.