Variable Universal Life (VUL)
Variable universal life (VUL) combines the investment options of variable life with the premium flexibility of universal life. It offers the most flexibility of any life insurance product—but also the most risk.
What Is Variable Universal Life?
Variable universal life (VUL) is permanent life insurance that combines:
- The flexible premiums of universal life
- The investment options of variable life
The result is a highly flexible product where the policy owner controls both premium payments and investment allocations.
Key Characteristics
1. Flexible Premiums
VUL offers the same premium flexibility as universal life:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Premium amount | Can vary (subject to minimum and maximum) |
| Payment schedule | Flexible—pay more, less, or skip payments |
| Overpayments | Build cash value faster |
| Underpayments | Covered by cash value if sufficient |
Premium flexibility works because:
- Cash value can cover mortality and expense charges
- As long as cash value remains, policy stays in force
- If cash value is depleted and no premium paid, policy lapses
2. Investment Choices
Like variable life, VUL cash value is invested in subaccounts:
| Subaccount Type | Risk Level | Potential Return |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed account | Low | Guaranteed minimum |
| Money market | Low | Low |
| Bond funds | Low-moderate | Moderate |
| Balanced funds | Moderate | Moderate |
| Stock funds | High | High |
| Specialty funds | High | High |
Policy owners can:
- Allocate premiums among multiple subaccounts
- Transfer between subaccounts (often free transfers allowed monthly)
- Adjust allocation strategy over time
3. No Minimum Death Benefit Guarantee
Unlike variable life, VUL typically has no minimum death benefit guarantee:
| Feature | Variable Life | VUL |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum death benefit | Yes (guaranteed floor) | Usually no |
| If investments decline | Death benefit has floor | Death benefit can decrease |
| Policy lapse risk | Lower | Higher |
Exam Tip: This is a critical distinction. Variable life guarantees a minimum death benefit; VUL typically does NOT.
4. Combination of Variable and Universal Features
VUL combines features from both product types:
| From Variable Life | From Universal Life |
|---|---|
| Subaccount investments | Flexible premiums |
| Cash value tied to performance | Adjustable death benefit |
| Securities regulation | Unbundled transparency |
| Prospectus required | Premium flexibility |
How VUL Works
Premium and Cash Value Flow
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Policy owner pays premium (flexible amount) |
| 2 | Expense charges deducted |
| 3 | Net premium added to cash value |
| 4 | Policy owner directs investment allocation |
| 5 | Monthly COI and fees deducted from cash value |
| 6 | Cash value fluctuates with investment performance |
Death Benefit Options
Like universal life, VUL typically offers death benefit options:
| Option | Death Benefit |
|---|---|
| Option A (Level) | Face amount only |
| Option B (Increasing) | Face amount + cash value |
Risks of VUL
VUL is the riskiest form of permanent life insurance:
1. Investment Risk
- Cash value can decline or be lost entirely
- No guaranteed minimum cash value
- Poor investment choices can devastate the policy
2. Policy Lapse Risk
- If cash value depleted and no premium paid, policy lapses
- No minimum death benefit guarantee (typically)
- Requires active monitoring and management
3. Complexity Risk
- Most complex life insurance product
- Requires understanding of both insurance and investments
- Poor understanding can lead to poor decisions
What Can Go Wrong
| Problem | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Market decline | Cash value drops significantly |
| Insufficient premium | Cash value depleted faster |
| COI increases with age | Higher deductions from cash value |
| Policy owner ignores policy | Unexpected lapse |
VUL Compared to Other Products
| Feature | Whole Life | Universal Life | Variable Life | VUL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premium | Fixed | Flexible | Fixed | Flexible |
| Investment risk | None | Limited | High | Highest |
| Death benefit guarantee | Full | Depends on funding | Minimum | Usually none |
| Cash value guarantee | Yes | Minimum rate | No | No |
| Potential returns | Low | Low-moderate | High | High |
| Securities license | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Advantages of VUL
| Advantage | Description |
|---|---|
| Maximum flexibility | Control premiums and investments |
| Growth potential | Cash value can grow significantly |
| Tax-deferred growth | Investment gains not currently taxed |
| Investment control | Choose your own allocation |
| Adjustable death benefit | Increase or decrease as needs change |
Disadvantages of VUL
| Disadvantage | Description |
|---|---|
| Highest risk | No guarantees on cash value or death benefit |
| Complexity | Difficult to understand and manage |
| Requires monitoring | Must actively manage the policy |
| Higher costs | Investment fees plus insurance costs |
| Lapse potential | Can lose coverage if not properly funded |
Who Is VUL Appropriate For?
VUL is suitable for:
- Sophisticated investors who understand market risk
- Those who want maximum control over their policy
- Individuals with fluctuating income who need premium flexibility
- Long-term investors comfortable with volatility
- Those who will actively monitor their policy
VUL is NOT suitable for:
- Conservative investors seeking guarantees
- Those who won't actively manage their policy
- People who need stable, predictable death benefits
- Those with limited investment knowledge
Key Takeaways
- VUL combines flexible premiums with investment subaccounts
- Policy owners control both premiums and investment allocation
- VUL typically has no minimum death benefit guarantee (unlike variable life)
- Cash value is fully at risk—can decline to zero
- Most flexible but also riskiest permanent life insurance
- Requires securities license and prospectus delivery
- Suitable only for sophisticated investors who will actively manage the policy
The key difference between variable life and variable universal life (VUL) is:
Unlike variable life insurance, VUL typically:
VUL is considered the riskiest form of permanent life insurance because:
VUL would be most appropriate for:
8.4 Suitability Requirements
Continue learning