Optional Provisions
In addition to the 12 mandatory provisions, insurers may include 11 optional provisions in health insurance policies. Unlike mandatory provisions that protect the insured, optional provisions generally protect the insurer.
Overview of Optional Provisions
| Key Difference | Mandatory | Optional |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protect insured | Protect insurer |
| Required | Yes, by law | No, insurer's choice |
| Modification | Must be at least as favorable | Standard wording used |
Key Principle: Optional provisions place more responsibility on the insured and give the insurer rights to adjust coverage or benefits under certain circumstances.
The 11 Optional Provisions
1. Change of Occupation
This provision allows the insurer to adjust benefits if the insured changes to a more hazardous occupation:
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| More hazardous occupation | Benefits reduced to amount premium would have purchased |
| Less hazardous occupation | Premiums reduced; excess returned |
Example:
- Accountant (low risk) becomes construction worker (high risk)
- Premium paid: $500/year
- Premium for construction worker: $750/year
- Benefit adjustment: 500/750 = 67% of original benefits
2. Misstatement of Age
If the insured's age was misstated on the application:
| Situation | Adjustment |
|---|---|
| Age understated | Benefits reduced proportionally |
| Age overstated | Excess premiums returned |
Calculation:
Adjusted Benefit = Original Benefit × (Premium Paid / Premium for Correct Age)
Note: This provision adjusts benefits rather than voiding the policy, which protects the insured.
3. Other Insurance with the Same Insurer
If the insured has multiple policies with the same insurer providing similar benefits:
| Provision | Effect |
|---|---|
| Limits excess coverage | Total benefits limited to reasonable amount |
| Premium return | Excess premiums returned |
| Prevents over-insurance | Insured cannot profit from multiple policies |
4. Insurance with Other Insurers (Expense-Incurred)
For policies reimbursing actual expenses when the insured has similar coverage with other insurers:
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Undisclosed other insurance | Benefits reduced proportionally |
| Excess premium | Returned to insured |
| Prevents duplication | Limits total reimbursement to actual expenses |
5. Insurance with Other Insurers (Other Benefits)
For policies providing fixed benefits (not expense reimbursement):
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Other insurance not disclosed | May reduce benefits |
| Prevents over-insurance | Limits potential for profit |
6. Relation of Earnings to Insurance
Applies to disability income policies when benefits exceed the insured's actual earnings:
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Benefits exceed earnings | Benefits reduced to actual monthly earnings |
| Exception | Minimum benefit of $200/month (or policy amount if less) |
| Premium adjustment | Proportional premium returned |
Purpose: Prevents moral hazard by ensuring disability benefits don't exceed what the insured would earn by working.
7. Unpaid Premium
Allows the insurer to deduct unpaid premiums from claims:
| Application | Details |
|---|---|
| Claim during grace period | Unpaid premium deducted from benefit |
| Outstanding loans | May also be deducted |
8. Cancellation
Allows the insurer to cancel the policy:
| Requirement | Details |
|---|---|
| Written notice | Required |
| Notice period | At least 5 days before cancellation |
| Premium refund | Pro-rata refund of unearned premium |
| Insured's right | May cancel at any time with short-rate refund |
9. Conformity with State Statutes
Ensures policy provisions comply with state law:
| Situation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Provision conflicts with law | Law prevails |
| Automatic amendment | Policy reads to conform with law |
10. Illegal Occupation
Limits coverage for losses occurring while engaged in illegal activity:
| Application | Details |
|---|---|
| Coverage denied | If loss occurs during illegal occupation |
| Felony involvement | Loss related to committing a felony |
11. Intoxicants and Narcotics
Limits coverage for losses caused by substance use:
| Substance | Effect |
|---|---|
| Alcohol intoxication | No coverage for losses while intoxicated |
| Narcotic use | No coverage unless prescribed by physician |
| Illegal drugs | No coverage for drug-related losses |
Optional Provisions Summary Table
| Provision | Protects | Key Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Change of occupation | Insurer | Adjusts benefits for hazard change |
| Misstatement of age | Both | Adjusts benefits, not void |
| Same insurer coverage | Insurer | Limits duplicate coverage |
| Other insurance (expense) | Insurer | Reduces for other coverage |
| Other insurance (other) | Insurer | May reduce benefits |
| Relation of earnings | Insurer | Benefits can't exceed earnings |
| Unpaid premium | Insurer | Deducts from claims |
| Cancellation | Insurer | Right to cancel with notice |
| Conformity with statutes | Both | Ensures legal compliance |
| Illegal occupation | Insurer | Excludes illegal activities |
| Intoxicants and narcotics | Insurer | Excludes substance-related losses |
Renewability Provisions
While not among the 11 optional provisions, renewability is a critical policy feature:
| Type | Definition |
|---|---|
| Non-cancellable | Insurer cannot cancel or raise premiums to age 65 |
| Guaranteed renewable | Insurer must renew but can raise class premiums |
| Conditionally renewable | Renewal subject to certain conditions |
| Optionally renewable | Insurer may refuse renewal on anniversary |
| Non-renewable (term) | Coverage ends at term expiration |
Exam Tip: Non-cancellable policies offer the strongest protection because both renewal and premiums are guaranteed. Guaranteed renewable policies must be renewed but premiums can increase for the entire class.
An insured purchased a disability income policy as an accountant. She later becomes a roofing contractor. Under the Change of Occupation provision, what happens to her benefits?
The Relation of Earnings to Insurance provision applies to which type of policy?
Which renewability provision guarantees both renewal AND level premiums through age 65?
22.3 Additional Provisions
Continue learning