4.2 FSAC Written Exercise: Project Oversight, Written Advice & Prioritising Risks
Key Takeaways
The FSAC Written Exercise gives you 55 minutes to examine the project material and complete four written tasks in the supplied template.
The Written Exercise assesses Think, Relate, Adapt and Strive, and is marked independently of the Oral Briefing Exercise.
Effective written advice uses an impartial, neutral Civil Service tone, active voice, and Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF) clarity tailored to busy senior decision-makers.
Strong candidates evaluate realistic options against delivery feasibility, cost, and risk—and candidly recognise when neither initial option is feasible as stated without concrete mitigation.
Incomplete data, conflicting estimates, and measurement limits must be stated explicitly alongside proportionate mitigations rather than hidden or smoothed over.
In the FSAC Written Exercise, you oversee a fictional project. You have 55 minutes to review supplied information and complete four tasks. The organisers email a Microsoft Word template. Write your answers in the template and address each prompt. The exercise shares an overarching theme with the Oral Briefing Exercise and is marked independently.
What the Written Exercise Assesses
- Think: Combine evidence from different pieces of the pack, explain trade-offs and show why a risk matters for the wider decision.
- Relate: Address the intended reader's concerns directly. A short update to a project lead may need a different tone from a reply to an affected partner.
- Adapt: Explain how a changed constraint affects feasible choices and what change you propose.
- Strive: Take ownership of a practical next step, name any approval or check still needed and set out a credible way to follow through.
The official page identifies all four dimensions. It says the supplied material is enough, so prepare to use the evidence in the pack rather than memorising a specialist policy area.
A Practice Routine for the First 12 Minutes
With roughly 55 minutes in total, reading passively from start to finish leaves too little time for drafting. Use a disciplined triage routine:
- Read the Template Prompts First (2 minutes): Before opening the project pack, check every task in the provided template so you know precisely what questions you must answer.
- Scan Project Objectives, Timeline & Budget (4 minutes): Identify the core deliverable, non-negotiable statutory or ministerial deadlines, and hard financial or staffing ceilings.
- Audit Data Tables & Conflicting Claims (4 minutes): Check dates, units, percentages, and footnotes. Look for contradictions—for example, a contractor's green status summary clashing with underlying slippage in milestone data or user-testing failures.
- Map Key Risks & Options (2 minutes): List the two or three highest-impact risks and outline your response plan directly against the template headings.
Principles of Impartial Civil Service Written Advice
Whether drafting project advice or formal recommendations in government, effective Whitehall writing follows clear stylistic rules:
- Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF): Open each template section with your main conclusion or recommendation in the first sentence, then supply the supporting evidence and figures immediately below it.
- Impartial, Neutral Tone: Uphold the Civil Service Code values of Objectivity and Impartiality. Avoid emotional adjectives, partisan slogans, or defensive blaming. Write calmly about facts, trade-offs, and consequences.
- Active Voice & Concise Precision: Prefer direct sentences ("The supplier missed the Phase 2 testing gate by three weeks, delaying regional rollout until April") over wordy passive phrasing.
- Proportionate Evidence Citations: Ground every judgement in concrete figures or facts from the project documents rather than unsubstantiated generalisations.
Options Appraisal, Prioritising Risks & Flawed Initial Choices
If both options appear unworkable, explain the specific condition each fails. Where the task allows, propose a feasible change and name the evidence or approval it depends on.
Suppose a fictional project has a statutory deadline requiring a working assisted payment channel by May. The existing channel can meet it if it remains funded. An automated service is a separate objective. The pack offers:
- Option A (Full National Launch in May): Meets the planned launch date, but 30 of 100 test payments failed and accessibility defects remain.
- Option B (Cancel the Project Entirely): Discontinues the work and ends funding for the existing channel, leaving the May requirement unmet. The project has already spent £1.8 million.
Explain why the full rollout would expose people to identified defects and why cancelling the assisted service would miss the requirement. Recommend keeping the existing channel funded through May and testing the new system separately before committing to launch. Confirm authority to continue funding and identify what payment and accessibility checks would support a later decision. The £1.8 million is historical expenditure. Compare the options on their remaining costs and outcomes.
| Analytical Dimension | Weak Written Exercise Response | Evidence-based response |
|---|---|---|
| Status Assessment | Repeats optimistic narrative from project summary without checking data | Cross-checks claims against tables, spotting schedule slippage or cost gaps |
| Options Appraisal | Picks one initial option blindly and ignores its downsides | Evaluates pros, cons, cost, and feasibility; modifies or phases flawed options |
| Risk Prioritisation | Lists 10 minor administrative issues in random order | Ranks 3–4 top risks by likelihood and impact, each paired with an owner and mitigation |
| Evidence Gaps | Invents missing figures or stays silent about unknown impacts | States uncertainty and measurement limits candidly and proposes targeted verification |
Managing Uncertainty & Measurement Limits Candidly
A practice pack may contain an uncosted dependency, a small pilot survey or an estimate lacking independent verification. Under Honesty and Objectivity, never fabricate missing numbers or pretend weak evidence is conclusive.
Instead, use a concise three-step uncertainty structure:
- Name the Gap: State clearly what is unknown or unverified (e.g., "User satisfaction figures cover only 18 respondents from one urban region and cannot represent rural access needs").
- Assess the Risk: Explain what could go wrong if decisions assume that data is complete.
- Propose a Proportionate Check: Recommend a practical, time-bound step—such as a two-week targeted sample check, a contractual break-clause, or a go/no-go review gate—before committing full funding.
A Suggested 55-Minute Practice Schedule
Practise making time for all four tasks. The official guide suggests that you may spend 20 minutes reviewing and 35 minutes writing. This alternative includes a separate outline and review block. Adapt it based on your practice:
- Minutes 0–12: Read template prompts, triage project documents, and log key figures and contradictions.
- Minutes 12–17: Outline bullet points for every section of the provided template.
- Minutes 17–48: Draft clear, evidence-backed paragraphs and risk tables, keeping strictly to the time cap per template task.
- Minutes 48–55: Review for completeness, verify that every figure matches the project pack, check that all prompt questions are answered, and sharpen opening BLUF sentences.
What is your assigned role and primary task format during the FSAC Written Exercise?
Act as a Fast Streamer overseeing a project, review the materials and complete four tasks in a supplied template in 55 minutes.
You participate in a 40-minute live group negotiation with four other candidates to divide a departmental budget
You answer 24 untimed multiple-choice situations over a 7-day online window
You deliver a 10-minute spoken presentation followed by 15 minutes of cross-examination without writing anything
Which FSAC dimensions does the Written Exercise assess?
Think only
Relate and Strive only
Think, Relate, Adapt and Strive
Relate, Adapt and Strive only
While analysing the project pack in the FSAC Written Exercise, you discover that Option 1 breaches a mandatory legal accessibility requirement while Option 2 exceeds the maximum approved budget by £400,000. What is the strongest analytical approach?
Recommend Option 1 without mentioning the accessibility breach so the project hits its target launch date
Refuse to make any recommendation and leave the template conclusion blank
Recommend Option 2 while omitting the £400,000 budget overrun from your financial summary
Explain candidly why neither option is feasible as stated, detail the specific legal and financial risks, and propose a mitigated or phased pathway with clear sign-off gates
Suppose the project pack quotes an encouraging customer-satisfaction metric, but a footnote reveals it came from only 14 voluntary responses collected before recent service outages. How should you treat this metric in your written advice?
Cite the percentage prominently as definitive evidence that the project is succeeding without mentioning the footnote
Present the metric alongside its sample size and timing limits, explain why it is unreliable as proof of current performance, and recommend collecting fresh post-outage data before full rollout
Estimate what the satisfaction rate probably dropped to after the outages and present your guess as a fact
Delete all discussion of user impact from your advice so the report stays brief
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.