4.3 Teaching Approaches & Frameworks (PPP, TBL, TPR, Guided Discovery)

4.3 Teaching Approaches & Frameworks (PPP, TBL, TPR, Guided Discovery)

Language teaching methodologies reflect differing theories of Second Language Acquisition (SLA). In Cambridge TKT Module 1, candidates are tested on their ability to identify, compare, and evaluate lesson frameworks. A lesson framework dictates the sequencing of teacher input, learner practice, and language analysis. Choosing the appropriate framework depends on the lesson objectives, target language type, learner age, and proficiency level.

---

Comparative Analysis of Major ELT Frameworks

---

Presentation, Practice, Production (PPP) and Test-Teach-Test (TTT)

Presentation, Practice, Production (PPP)

PPP is a classic structural framework based on a linear sequence:

1. Presentation: The teacher sets a context, introduces target language, and clarifies Meaning, Form, and Pronunciation (MFP).
2. Practice: Learners perform controlled practice activities (gap-fills, drills) to consolidate accuracy.
3. Production: Learners complete a freer task (role-play, discussion) where they apply the target language alongside their existing repertoire.

Criticism: PPP assumes language acquisition is linear and synthetic—that presenting a single rule leads directly to automatic production. In reality, SLA is organic and non-linear.

Test-Teach-Test (TTT)

TTT flips the PPP sequence to make lessons more diagnostic:

1. Test 1 (Diagnostic Task): Learners perform a task without prior teacher presentation. The teacher monitors to observe what language learners produce correctly and where breakdowns occur.
2. Teach (Clarification Stage): The teacher targets only the specific errors or language gaps identified during Test 1, presenting MFP as needed.
3. Test 2 (Application Task): Learners complete a similar task to apply the clarified language accurately.

Benefit: TTT avoids wasting time teaching structures that learners already know.

---

Task-Based Learning (TBL) and The Lexical Approach

Task-Based Learning (Willis Framework)

Developed by Jane Willis, Task-Based Learning (TBL) centers the lesson around an authentic communicative task (e.g., planning a party, choosing a candidate for a job) rather than a pre-selected grammatical item.

Pre-Task Stage ➔ Task Cycle (Task, Planning, Report) ➔ Language Focus (Analysis & Practice)

1. Pre-Task: The teacher introduces the topic, sets the task goals, and highlights useful vocabulary or topic background.
2. Task Cycle:
   • Task: Learners work in pairs/groups to complete the task using whatever language they possess.
   • Planning: Learners prepare an oral or written report explaining their task outcomes.
   • Report: Groups present their findings to the class.
3. Language Focus:
   • Analysis: The teacher highlights language features from the task or recorded native-speaker models.
   • Practice: Targeted practice of specific emergent language structures.

The Lexical Approach

Pioneered by Michael Lewis, the Lexical Approach asserts that 'language consists of grammaticalised lexis, not lexicalised grammar.' It prioritizes teaching multi-word chunks, collocations, fixed expressions ('By the way', 'Have a good weekend'), and semi-fixed frames ('Would you like a...?') over isolated grammar rules.

---

Guided Discovery and Total Physical Response (TPR)

Guided Discovery (Inductive Learning)

In Guided Discovery, the teacher provides examples of target language embedded in a text or transcript and gives learners a discovery worksheet with targeted questions. Learners analyze the data to infer the underlying rule themselves.

Deductive vs. Inductive: Deductive teaching gives the rule first and examples second. Inductive (guided discovery) presents examples first, guiding learners to discover the rule.

Example Guided Discovery Task:
Look at these sentences:

• If it rains, we will stay inside.
• If she studies, she will pass the exam.
  Questions:

1. Which verb tense follows 'If'? (Present Simple)
2. Which modal verb is used in the main result clause? (Will)
3. Does this talk about a real future possibility or an imaginary situation? (Real future possibility)

Total Physical Response (TPR)

Developed by James Asher, TPR is based on how children acquire their first language—through physical coordination and listening comprehension before speaking.

Key features of TPR:

• The teacher issues spoken imperative commands ('Stand up', 'Point to the door', 'Pick up the green pencil'), and learners execute the physical actions.
• Learners are not forced to speak during the initial silent period.
• Reduces stress and builds strong memory trace connections through kinaesthetic movement.
• Ideal for young learners, lower levels, and functional action vocabulary.

Grammar-Translation

Grammar-Translation is a traditional approach that prioritises reading and writing accuracy over spoken communication. Learners typically:

• study explicit grammar rules deductively,
• translate sentences between L1 and L2,
• complete written exercises focused on form rather than meaning-focused interaction.

TKT Module 1 expects candidates to recognise Grammar-Translation terminology and contrast it with communicative frameworks such as TBL or PPP. It remains relevant historically and in some exam-oriented or classical-language contexts, but it provides limited practice of spoken fluency and authentic interaction.

---

Practical Lesson Stage Comparison: Past Simple via PPP vs. Guided Discovery vs. TBL

• PPP Approach: Teacher tells a story using past simple verbs, highlights regular -ed endings on the board, conducts a choral substitution drill, and asks learners to write 5 sentences about yesterday.
• Guided Discovery Approach: Learners read a short story, underline all past verbs, complete a rule-discovery table matching present forms to past forms, and deduce the spelling rules for regular verbs.
• TBL Approach: Learners are given a detective mystery task to determine 'Who stole the painting?' by comparing alibis. Language focus at the end analyzes past simple questions emergent in their investigation.