4.5 Planning & Managing Budget
Key Takeaways
Cost estimating techniques include analogous (least accurate), parametric (uses statistical relationships), bottom-up (most accurate), and three-point (PERT) estimating
The cost baseline is the approved time-phased budget used to measure and monitor cost performance, excluding management reserves
Contingency reserves address identified risks (known unknowns) and are part of the cost baseline, while management reserves address unidentified risks (unknown unknowns)
Estimate accuracy improves through project phases: ROM (-25% to +75%), Budget (-10% to +25%), and Definitive (-5% to +10%)
Earned Value Management (EVM) uses Cost Performance Index (CPI = EV/AC) and Schedule Performance Index (SPI = EV/PV) to measure project performance
Cost management ensures the project is completed within the approved budget. It involves estimating costs, determining the budget, and controlling expenditures throughout the project.
Cost Management Processes
| Process | Purpose | Key Output |
|---|---|---|
| Plan Cost Management | Establish policies and procedures for cost management | Cost Management Plan |
| Estimate Costs | Approximate monetary resources needed | Cost Estimates |
| Determine Budget | Aggregate estimates to establish cost baseline | Cost Baseline |
| Control Costs | Monitor status and manage cost changes | Work Performance Information |
Cost Estimating Techniques
Comparison of Techniques
| Technique | Accuracy | Time/Cost | Best Used When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Analogous | -25% to +75% | Lowest | Early phases, limited information |
| Parametric | -10% to +25% | Moderate | Historical data available |
| Bottom-Up | -5% to +10% | Highest | Detailed WBS available |
| Three-Point | Varies | Moderate | Uncertainty exists |
Analogous Estimating (Top-Down)
Uses costs from previous similar projects as the basis for estimates:
Example: "The last website project cost $50,000, so this similar one should cost about $50,000."
| Advantage | Disadvantage |
|---|---|
| Quick and inexpensive | Less accurate |
| Useful with limited information | Depends on similarity |
| Good for high-level budgeting | May not account for differences |
Parametric Estimating
Uses statistical relationships between historical data and other variables:
Example: Cost per line of code x estimated lines of code
| Cost Parameter | Unit Rate | Quantity | Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Software coding | $50/line | 10,000 lines | $500,000 |
| Testing | $20/test case | 500 cases | $10,000 |
| Documentation | $100/page | 200 pages | $20,000 |
| Total | $530,000 |
Bottom-Up Estimating
Estimates individual work packages and aggregates them:
Project Total: $530,000
├── Phase 1: $80,000
│ ├── WP 1.1: $30,000
│ └── WP 1.2: $50,000
├── Phase 2: $250,000
│ ├── WP 2.1: $100,000
│ ├── WP 2.2: $100,000
│ └── WP 2.3: $50,000
└── Phase 3: $200,000
├── WP 3.1: $150,000
└── WP 3.2: $50,000
- Most accurate estimating technique
- Most time-consuming and expensive
- Requires detailed WBS
Three-Point Estimating
Uses optimistic, most likely, and pessimistic estimates:
Beta/PERT Formula: E = (O + 4M + P) / 6
Triangular Formula: E = (O + M + P) / 3
Example:
- Optimistic: $80,000
- Most Likely: $100,000
- Pessimistic: $150,000
PERT Estimate = ($80,000 + 4($100,000) + $150,000) / 6 = $103,333
Estimate Accuracy Levels
| Level | Accuracy Range | Project Phase | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rough Order of Magnitude (ROM) | -25% to +75% | Initiation | Feasibility, go/no-go decisions |
| Budget Estimate | -10% to +25% | Planning | Budget authorization |
| Definitive Estimate | -5% to +10% | Detailed Planning | Baseline, contracts |
Progressive Elaboration of Estimates
Estimates become more accurate as the project progresses:
- Initiation: ROM estimate based on analogous data
- Early Planning: Budget estimate using parametric methods
- Detailed Planning: Definitive estimate using bottom-up approach
Cost Baseline Development
The Cost Baseline is the approved, time-phased budget used to measure and monitor project cost performance.
From Estimates to Baseline
| Component | Description | Included in Baseline? |
|---|---|---|
| Activity Cost Estimates | Cost of individual activities | Yes |
| Contingency Reserves | For identified risks (known unknowns) | Yes |
| Cost Baseline | Time-phased spending plan | Yes |
| Management Reserves | For unidentified risks (unknown unknowns) | No |
| Project Budget | Cost Baseline + Management Reserves | Total funding |
Visual Representation
Project Budget
↓
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Management Reserves │ ← Unknown unknowns
├─────────────────────────────────────┤
│ Cost Baseline │ ← Performance baseline
│ ┌─────────────────────────────┐ │
│ │ Contingency Reserves │ │ ← Known unknowns
│ ├─────────────────────────────┤ │
│ │ Activity Cost Estimates │ │ ← Work package costs
│ └─────────────────────────────┘ │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
Contingency and Management Reserves
Contingency Reserves
- Address identified risks (known unknowns)
- Part of the cost baseline
- PM has authority to use
- Calculated through risk analysis
Management Reserves
- Address unidentified risks (unknown unknowns)
- NOT part of the cost baseline
- Requires sponsor approval to use
- Typically a percentage of project budget
Reserve Calculation Example
| Component | Amount | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Base Estimate | $400,000 | Sum of activity estimates |
| Contingency Reserve | $40,000 | 10% for identified risks |
| Cost Baseline | $440,000 | Base + Contingency |
| Management Reserve | $44,000 | 10% of baseline |
| Project Budget | $484,000 | Baseline + Management Reserve |
Funding Requirements
The funding limit reconciliation ensures that expenditures are reconciled with funding limits:
Funding Patterns
| Pattern | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Front-loaded | More funding early | Capital purchases upfront |
| Back-loaded | More funding later | Labor-intensive completion |
| Linear | Even spending over time | Steady-state operations |
| S-Curve | Gradual start, peak, gradual end | Typical project pattern |
Cash Flow Planning
- Identify when funds are needed
- Align with organizational funding cycles
- Account for payment terms with vendors
- Consider revenue timing if applicable
Earned Value Management (EVM) Basics
Earned Value Management integrates scope, schedule, and cost to assess project performance.
Key EVM Metrics
| Metric | Formula | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Planned Value (PV) | Budgeted cost of work scheduled | What should have been done |
| Earned Value (EV) | Budgeted cost of work performed | What has been accomplished |
| Actual Cost (AC) | Actual cost of work performed | What was actually spent |
Performance Indices
| Index | Formula | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Cost Performance Index (CPI) | EV / AC | > 1.0 = Under budget, < 1.0 = Over budget |
| Schedule Performance Index (SPI) | EV / PV | > 1.0 = Ahead of schedule, < 1.0 = Behind schedule |
Variance Analysis
| Variance | Formula | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Cost Variance (CV) | EV - AC | Positive = Under budget |
| Schedule Variance (SV) | EV - PV | Positive = Ahead of schedule |
Example
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| PV (Planned) | $100,000 |
| EV (Earned) | $80,000 |
| AC (Actual) | $90,000 |
| CPI | 0.89 (over budget by 11%) |
| SPI | 0.80 (behind schedule by 20%) |
| CV | -$10,000 (over budget) |
| SV | -$20,000 (behind schedule) |
Key Takeaways
- Analogous is fastest but least accurate; Bottom-up is most accurate but slowest
- Parametric uses statistical relationships with historical data
- Three-point accounts for uncertainty using optimistic, most likely, and pessimistic estimates
- Contingency reserves are for identified risks and are in the cost baseline
- Management reserves are for unidentified risks and are NOT in the cost baseline
- EVM uses PV, EV, and AC to measure cost and schedule performance
Which cost estimating technique is MOST accurate and uses detailed estimates of individual work packages?
Analogous estimating
Parametric estimating
Three-point estimating
Bottom-up estimating
A project has a budget of $500,000 including $50,000 in contingency reserves and $45,000 in management reserves. What is the cost baseline?
$500,000
$455,000
$450,000
$405,000
A project has PV = $200,000, EV = $180,000, and AC = $210,000. What is the Cost Performance Index (CPI) and what does it indicate?
CPI = 0.86, project is over budget
CPI = 1.17, project is under budget
CPI = 0.90, project is behind schedule
CPI = 0.95, project is on budget
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.