3.3 NC Coastal Property Pool (Beach Plan) & FAIR Plan

3.3 NC Coastal Property Pool (Beach Plan) & FAIR Plan

Coastal geography and exposure to severe weather—such as hurricanes, tropical storms, and nor'easters—create unique property underwriting challenges in North Carolina. When private, admitted insurers restrict underwriting appetite in high-risk areas or when insurance carriers face insolvency, statutory mechanisms step in to ensure property owners have access to coverage and that valid claims are paid. This section examines North Carolina's two residual property underwriting pools—the North Carolina Insurance Underwriting Association (NCIUA / Beach Plan) and the North Carolina Joint Underwriting Association (NCJUA / FAIR Plan)—as well as the state's insurer solvency safety net, the North Carolina Insurance Guaranty Association (NCIGA).

---

1. NC Coastal Property Pool / Beach Plan (NCIUA - NCGS Chapter 58, Article 45)

Following Hurricane Camille and severe coastal insurance availability crises, the North Carolina General Assembly enacted NCGS Chapter 58, Article 45 in 1969, creating the North Carolina Insurance Underwriting Association (NCIUA), commonly known as the Beach Plan or Coastal Property Insurance Pool (CPIP).

Geographic Territory & Covered Counties

The NCIUA operates exclusively within two defined coastal zones comprising 18 designated coastal counties:

1. Beach Area: All barrier islands and oceanfront areas adjacent to the Atlantic Ocean, sounds, and inlets (e.g., the Outer Banks, Topsail Island, Pleasure Island, Oak Island).
2. Coastal Area: The 18 designated coastal counties in their entirety: Beaufort, Brunswick, Camden, Carteret, Chowan, Craven, Currituck, Dare, Hyde, Jones, New Hanover, Onslow, Pamlico, Pasquotank, Pender, Perquimans, Tyrrell, and Washington.

Coverages Offered by NCIUA

• Windstorm & Hail Only Policies: Specifically designed for property owners who obtain standard fire and liability coverage in the voluntary market, but whose private policy contains a mandatory coastal wind/hail exclusion.
• Essential Property Insurance (Full Coverage): Direct loss coverage against Fire, Lightning, Extended Coverage perils (Windstorm, Hail, Explosion, Riot, Civil Commotion, Aircraft, Vehicles, Smoke), and Vandalism & Malicious Mischief (V&MM).
• Homeowners & Dwelling Policy Forms: Both residential dwelling forms and commercial property policies are available up to statutory aggregate limits.

Underwriting Rules & Storm Binding Moratorium

• Insurability Standards: Property must be structurally sound and meet minimum building code requirements. It cannot be denied solely due to coastal location.
• Wind Mitigation Credits: Substantial premium discounts are provided for structures built or retrofitted to IBHS Fortified standards (e.g., fortified roofs, ring-shank nails, sealed roof decks).
• Binding Moratorium (Tropical Storm / Hurricane Freeze): When a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is issued by the National Weather Service for any portion of the North Carolina coastline, a binding moratorium automatically takes effect. Agents and the Association cannot bind new coverage or increase existing policy limits until the official watch/warning is lifted.

2. NC FAIR Plan (NCJUA - NCGS Chapter 58, Article 46)

The North Carolina Joint Underwriting Association (NCJUA), known as the FAIR Plan (Fair Access to Insurance Requirements), was established in 1969 under NCGS Chapter 58, Article 46 to ensure availability of essential property insurance in inland areas.

Operational Scope and Purpose

• Geographic Area: The FAIR Plan provides coverage across the remaining 82 inland/non-coastal counties of North Carolina (and coordinates coverage for properties outside the Beach Plan's primary coastal wind zones).
• Market of Last Resort: Designed for property owners who have been unable to obtain basic property coverage in the voluntary admitted market after making diligent efforts.
• Covered Perils: Direct physical loss from Fire, Lightning, Extended Coverage perils (including Windstorm and Hail, since inland policies do not split wind into a separate pool), and Vandalism & Malicious Mischief (V&MM).

Mandatory Inspection and Underwriting Protections

• Free Physical Inspection (NCGS § 58-46-15): Any property owner or their agent is entitled to request a free physical inspection of the property by NCJUA inspectors to determine insurability.
• Prohibition on Redlining / Location Discrimination: The NCJUA cannot reject a property solely due to environmental hazards, neighborhood characteristics, or geographic area. Coverage may only be conditioned on or denied for severe, uncorrected physical defects (e.g., open wiring, severe roof dilapidation, unaddressed fire hazards, or illegal occupancy).

---

3. Comparison of NC Residual Property Plans

---

4. North Carolina Insurance Guaranty Association (NCIGA)

When an admitted property and casualty insurance company becomes financially insolvent and is ordered into liquidation by a court of competent jurisdiction, policyholders and injured claimants face catastrophic financial exposure. The North Carolina Insurance Guaranty Association (NCIGA), established in 1971 under NCGS Chapter 58, Article 48, serves as the statutory safety net.

Mandatory Membership & Scope

All insurance companies licensed to write direct property and casualty insurance in North Carolina must participate as members of the NCIGA. The association covers claims on policies issued by admitted (licensed) carriers.

Critical Exam Rule — Surplus Lines Exclusion: The NCIGA covers only admitted insurers. Claims against unauthorized, non-admitted, or surplus lines carriers are strictly excluded from NCIGA protection. Policyholders who purchase coverage through surplus lines carriers have no guaranty association coverage if the surplus lines insurer becomes insolvent.

Covered Claims, Limits, and Deductibles (NCGS § 58-48-35)

1. Workers' Compensation Claims: Covered up to the full statutory limits established under the North Carolina Workers' Compensation Act (NCGS Chapter 97)—there is NO dollar maximum cap.
2. General Property & Casualty Claims: Covered up to a maximum limit of $300,000 per claim for all covered first-party property losses and third-party liability claims.
3. Return of Unearned Premium: NCIGA reimburses unearned premiums paid by policyholders up to a maximum of $10,000 per policy.
4. Statutory Deductible: A $50 deductible applies to all covered property and casualty claims paid by the NCIGA.
5. Residency Requirement: The claimant or insured must be a North Carolina resident at the time of the insured occurrence, or the property from which the claim arises must be permanently located in North Carolina.

Excluded Lines from NCIGA Coverage

The following lines of insurance are expressly exempt from NCIGA coverage: Life and health insurance, annuities, title insurance, surety and fidelity bonds, credit insurance, mortgage guaranty insurance, and ocean marine insurance.

Funding and Assessment Mechanism

The NCIGA does not hold a massive standing fund; it operates via post-insolvency assessments. When an insurer enters liquidation, the NCIGA assesses member insurers proportionally based on their net direct written premiums in North Carolina. Assessments are segregated into three separate accounts (Auto, Workers' Compensation, and All Other Property/Casualty) and are capped at 2% of net direct written premiums per account in any single calendar year.