6.1 Lime-Soda Ash Softening & Ion Exchange Demineralization

6.1 Lime-Soda Ash Softening & Ion Exchange Demineralization

Water hardness is one of the most common aesthetic and operational challenges encountered by public water utilities, particularly in groundwater systems drawing from limestone and dolomite formations across Missouri. While hard water does not pose an acute adverse human health risk, excessive mineral hardness causes mineral scaling in distribution piping, boilers, and household hot water heaters, severely diminishes soap lathering capacity, leaves insoluble curd deposits, and increases utility pumping head losses.

Water softening is the chemical or physical process of reducing polyvalent mineral cation concentrations in water supplies. Certified water operators must understand the distinct chemical principles, equipment configurations, hydraulic pathways, and stabilization requirements of both chemical precipitation softening (lime-soda ash) and ion exchange softening (cation exchange demineralization).

---

Hardness Chemistry & Classification

Primary Cations Responsible for Hardness

Hardness is primarily caused by multivalent (polyvalent) metallic cations dissolved in water. The two dominant contributors in natural water sources are:

1. Calcium ions ($\text{Ca}^{2+}$): Typically originating from the dissolution of calcite or limestone ($\text{CaCO}_3$) and gypsum ($\text{CaSO}_4\cdot 2\text{H}_2\text{O}$).
2. Magnesium ions ($\text{Mg}^{2+}$): Dissolved from dolomite ($\text{CaMg(CO}_3)_2$) and magnesite ($\text{MgCO}_3$).

Other multivalent cations—such as iron ($\text{Fe}^{2+}, \text{Fe}^{3+}$), manganese ($\text{Mn}^{2+}$), strontium ($\text{Sr}^{2+}$), and barium ($\text{Ba}^{2+}$)—also contribute to total hardness, but they are typically present in much lower concentrations.

$\text{Total Hardness} = \text{Calcium Hardness} + \text{Magnesium Hardness}$

Hardness is universally expressed in units of milligrams per liter as calcium carbonate equivalent ($\text{mg/L as CaCO}_3$) or in grains per gallon (gpg):

$1\text{ grain per gallon (gpg)} = 17.12\text{ mg/L as CaCO}_3$

$\text{Grains per gallon (gpg)} = \frac{\text{Hardness in mg/L as CaCO}_3}{17.12}$

Standard Water Hardness Classification Scale

The United States Geological Survey (USGS) and the American Water Works Association (AWWA) classify water hardness according to the following standard tiers:

Carbonate vs. Noncarbonate Hardness

To determine the appropriate chemical dosages in a treatment facility, operators must categorize hardness into two chemical classifications based on the associated balancing anions:

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                                 TOTAL HARDNESS DIVISIONS                                |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  1. CARBONATE HARDNESS (Temporary Hardness):                                            |
|     - Chemically bound to bicarbonate [HCO3-] and carbonate [CO3(2-)] anions.           |
|     - Equal to Total Hardness or Total Alkalinity, whichever is LESS.                   |
|     - Readily precipitates out of solution as CaCO3 upon heating or boiling.            |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  2. NONCARBONATE HARDNESS (Permanent Hardness):                                         |
|     - Chemically bound to sulfate [SO4(2-)], chloride [Cl-], or nitrate [NO3-] anions.  |
|     - Calculated as: Noncarbonate Hardness = Total Hardness - Carbonate Hardness.        |
|     - Does NOT precipitate upon boiling; requires soda ash (Na2CO3) for removal.       |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

• If Total Hardness > Total Alkalinity: $\text{Carbonate Hardness} = \text{Total Alkalinity}$ $\text{Noncarbonate Hardness} = \text{Total Hardness} - \text{Total Alkalinity}$
• If Total Hardness \le Total Alkalinity: $\text{Carbonate Hardness} = \text{Total Hardness}$ $\text{Noncarbonate Hardness} = 0\text{ mg/L}$

---

Chemical Precipitation Softening: The Lime-Soda Ash Process

Chemical precipitation softening relies on adding alkaline chemicals to raise the water's pH, shifting the carbonate equilibrium and converting soluble calcium and magnesium ions into insoluble precipitates:

• Calcium precipitates as calcium carbonate ($\text{CaCO}_3$), which exhibits minimal solubility around $\text{pH } 9.2 - 9.5$.
• Magnesium precipitates as magnesium hydroxide ($\text{Mg(OH)}_2$), which is highly soluble until the pH is driven up to $\text{pH } 10.6 - 10.8$.

Chemical Feed Reagents

1. Quicklime (Calcium Oxide, $\text{CaO}$):
   • High-grade white solid containing $90 - 95% \text{ CaO}$.
   • Requires an on-site slaker to hydrate quicklime in an exothermic reaction yielding slaked lime / hydrated lime slurry: $\text{CaO} + \text{H}_2\text{O} \rightarrow \text{Ca(OH)}_2 + \text{Heat } (15,300\text{ cal/mol})$
   • Slaking water temperature must be maintained between $160^\circ\text{F} - 180^\circ\text{F}$ for complete, rapid slaking.
2. Hydrated Lime (Calcium Hydroxide, $\text{Ca(OH)}_2$):
   • Pre-slaked dry white powder containing $85 - 95% \text{ Ca(OH)}_2$.
   • Commonly utilized in smaller facilities due to easier dry feeding without slaking equipment.
3. Soda Ash (Sodium Carbonate, $\text{Na}_2\text{CO}_3$):
   • Dry white granular compound ($99%+$ purity).
   • Supplies the carbonate ions ($\text{CO}_3^{2-}$) necessary to precipitate noncarbonate calcium and magnesium hardness.
4. Caustic Soda (Sodium Hydroxide, $\text{NaOH}$):
   • Delivered as a $25%$ or $50%$ liquid solution.
   • Can replace both lime and soda ash in some plants, generating less precipitate sludge, though it is more expensive and requires heated storage (50% NaOH crystallizes/freezes at $54^\circ\text{F}$).

Step-by-Step Chemical Precipitation Reactions

  Reaction Sequence for Complete Lime-Soda Ash Precipitation Softening:

  1. Carbon Dioxide Neutralization (Consumes Lime without Softening):
     CO2 + Ca(OH)2  ──►  CaCO3↓ + H2O

  2. Calcium Carbonate Hardness Removal (pH 9.2 - 9.5):
     Ca(HCO3)2 + Ca(OH)2  ──►  2 CaCO3↓ + 2 H2O

  3. Magnesium Carbonate Hardness Removal (pH 10.6 - 10.8, Requires Excess Lime):
     Mg(HCO3)2 + 2 Ca(OH)2  ──►  Mg(OH)2↓ + 2 CaCO3↓ + 2 H2O

  4. Calcium Noncarbonate Hardness Removal (Requires Soda Ash):
     CaSO4 + Na2CO3  ──►  CaCO3↓ + Na2SO4

  5. Magnesium Noncarbonate Hardness Removal (Requires Lime + Soda Ash):
     MgSO4 + Ca(OH)2  ──►  Mg(OH)2↓ + CaSO4  (Converts to Calcium Noncarbonate)
     CaSO4 + Na2CO3   ──►  CaCO3↓ + Na2SO4   (Precipitates with Soda Ash)

Single-Stage vs. Two-Stage Softening & Split Treatment

• Single-Stage Softening: When raw water contains low magnesium ($< 40\text{ mg/L as CaCO}_3$) and only calcium hardness needs removal, lime is dosed to achieve $\text{pH } 9.2 - 9.5$ in a single clarifier basin.
• Two-Stage Excess-Lime Softening: When magnesium exceeds $40\text{ mg/L as CaCO}_3$, lime is dosed to excess ($30 - 50\text{ mg/L}$ excess lime) in Stage 1 to drive the pH to $10.8$, precipitating $\text{Mg(OH)}_2$ and $\text{CaCO}_3$. The water then passes to a primary clarifier, followed by recarbonation and soda ash addition in Stage 2.
• Split Treatment Softening: A fraction of raw water (e.g., $60 - 75%$) is routed to Stage 1 and treated with excess lime to precipitate all calcium and magnesium. The remaining raw water bypasses Stage 1 and is blended into Stage 2. The raw water's natural carbon dioxide and bicarbonate alkalinity neutralize excess lime and precipitate calcium carbonate, significantly reducing chemical consumption.

---

Recarbonation & Finished Water Stabilization

Water emerging from lime softening clarifiers is chemically unstable and supersaturated with calcium carbonate and magnesium hydroxide. If pumped directly to filters and distribution systems, this supersaturated water will cause heavy encrustation on filter sand grains ("growing sand"), clog backwash underdrains, and cement distribution valves.

Recarbonation is the process of bubbling carbon dioxide gas ($\text{CO}_2$) through softened water to lower the pH, neutralize excess hydroxide ions, and convert insoluble carbonates back into stable, soluble bicarbonates.

Two-Stage Recarbonation Chemistry

1. First-Stage Recarbonation (Prior to Secondary Clarification or Filtration):
   • Lowers pH from $10.8$ down to approximately $9.2 - 9.5$.
   • Converts caustic hydroxide into carbonate, halting magnesium hydroxide precipitation and precipitating excess calcium as calcium carbonate: $\text{Ca(OH)}_2 + \text{CO}_2 \rightarrow \text{CaCO}_3\downarrow + \text{H}_2\text{O}$
2. Second-Stage Recarbonation (Following Secondary Settling, Prior to Filtration):
   • Lowers pH from $9.5$ down to $8.2 - 8.6$.
   • Converts insoluble calcium carbonate into soluble calcium bicarbonate, stabilizing the water: $\text{CaCO}_3 + \text{CO}_2 + \text{H}_2\text{O} \rightarrow \text{Ca(HCO}_3)_2$

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                        SOFTENING SLUDGE CHARACTERISTICS COMPARISON                      |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  Calcium Carbonate Sludge (CaCO3):                                                      |
|  - Dense, crystalline, and heavy.                                                       |
|  - Gravity thickens readily to 15% - 30% solids.                                        |
|  - Easily dewatered on vacuum filters, centrifuges, or drying beds.                     |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  Magnesium Hydroxide Sludge (Mg(OH)2):                                                  |
|  - Highly gelatinous, flocculent, and light.                                            |
|  - Settles poorly, retaining water (typically thickens to only 2% - 5% solids).         |
|  - Very difficult to dewater; significantly increases total sludge volume.              |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

---

Ion Exchange Demineralization (Cation Exchange Softening)

Ion exchange softening removes hardness cations without chemical precipitation or sludge production by passing pressurized raw water through a pressure vessel containing synthetic Strong Acid Cation (SAC) exchange resin beads in the sodium form ($\text{R-Na}^+$).

Ion Exchange Mechanism & Selectivity

The resin consists of microscopic cross-linked polystyrene beads with negatively charged functional sulfonate groups ($\text{SO}_3^-$) holding exchangeable sodium cations ($\text{Na}^+$). Because SAC resin has a greater electrostatic affinity for multivalent cations than monovalent ions, calcium and magnesium selectively displace sodium from the resin sites:

$\text{Ca}^{2+} + 2\text{R-Na} \rightleftharpoons \text{R}_2\text{-Ca} + 2\text{Na}^+$ $\text{Mg}^{2+} + 2\text{R-Na} \rightleftharpoons \text{R}_2\text{-Mg} + 2\text{Na}^+$

  Ion Selectivity Sequence on Strong Acid Cation (SAC) Resin:
  Ba2+  >  Pb2+  >  Sr2+  >  Ca2+  >  Ni2+  >  Cd2+  >  Cu2+  >  Co2+  >  Zn2+  >  Mg2+  >  Fe2+  >  Mn2+  >  Na+  >  H+

SAC resin softening features:

• Exchange Capacity: Typically $20,000 - 30,000\text{ grains of hardness removed per cubic foot of resin}$ ($20 - 30\text{ kgr/ft}^3$).
• Hydraulic Loading Rate: Standard service flow rate is $5 - 10\text{ gpm/ft}^2$ of media bed area (or $1 - 3\text{ gpm/ft}^3$ of resin volume).
• Hardness Leakage: As resin sites become exhausted, calcium and magnesium begin breaking through into the effluent. Service runs must terminate when effluent hardness rises above $2 - 5\text{ mg/L as CaCO}_3$.
• Blending (Split-Stream Flow): SAC ion exchange produces completely soft water ($0\text{ mg/L}$ hardness), which is highly aggressive and corrosive to plumbing. To prevent corrosion and reduce salt costs, a calculated bypass stream of raw water is blended with the softened effluent to achieve a finished distribution hardness of $75 - 100\text{ mg/L as CaCO}_3$.

The Four-Step Resin Regeneration Cycle

When the resin's exchange capacity is depleted, it is taken off-line and regenerated via a four-stage sequence that reverses the exchange reaction using high sodium concentration mass action:

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                        ION EXCHANGE RESIN REGENERATION STAGES                           |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 1. BACKWASH:                                                                            |
|    - Upflow wash (5 - 8 gpm/sq ft) for 10 to 15 minutes.                               |
|    - Expands resin bed by 30% to 50%, flushes filtered particulate matter, and         |
|      eliminates internal channel pathways.                                              |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 2. BRINE INJECTION (REGENERATION):                                                      |
|    - Downflow injection of concentrated sodium chloride (NaCl) brine diluted to        |
|      10% to 12% solution (typical salt dosage: 6 - 15 lb NaCl/cu ft of resin).          |
|    - Mass action of high Na+ concentration forces Ca2+ and Mg2+ off resin sites:        |
|      R2-Ca + 2 Na+  ──►  2 R-Na + Ca2+                                                  |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 3. SLOW RINSE (DISPLACEMENT):                                                           |
|    - Low-rate downflow water flush at the brine pumping velocity.                       |
|    - Pushes residual brine deeply through the resin bed to maximize contact time.       |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 4. FAST RINSE:                                                                          |
|    - Downflow service-rate flush (1.5 - 2.0 gpm/cu ft) for 10 to 20 minutes.           |
|    - Flushes remaining excess brine and chloride ions to waste until effluent           |
|      conductivity and chloride reach background baseline levels.                        |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Operational Comparison: Lime Softening vs. Ion Exchange