3.3 Quality Control, Violations, and Progressive Discipline

MVA Oversight Powers

COMAR 11.23.01.24 (Quality Control): "The Administration may conduct unannounced visits and audits of licensed drivers' schools to evaluate compliance with laws, regulations, standards, and the quality of instruction."

COMAR 11.23.02.39 (Program Evaluation) goes further for certified schools:

• §A — the MVA may conduct unannounced visits during the school's posted business hours to observe instructors and audits to evaluate compliance and the quality of instruction;
• §B — the MVA may develop one or more research models to evaluate program effectiveness under Transportation Article, §16-505; and
• §C — the MVA may require certified schools to provide statistical information in an approved format to support those research models.

Supporting access rules appear throughout: schools must make operation and student records available during posted business hours (11.23.01.07A(4); 11.23.02.08A(5)); a driver education school shall permit the MVA to enter the classroom and observe the instruction and operations (11.23.02.32I); and approved instructor trainers and professional development providers must let the MVA review records and monitor the instruction given (11.23.02.29E; .30E).

---

The Shared Two-Tier Architecture

Each regulation follows the same shape:

1. MVA MAY suspend / revoke / refuse to renew    -> after notice and hearing
   MVA MAY refuse to issue an initial credential -> after notice and opportunity for hearing
2. MVA SHALL refuse to renew or issue            -> fraudulent, inaccurate, or incomplete
                                                    information, or failure to meet requirements
3. MOST SERIOUS violation                        -> escalated, near-automatic consequence
4. Second MOST SERIOUS violation                 -> revocation
5. Everything else = SERIOUS                     -> progressive disciplinary action
                                                    (conference, fines, suspension, revocation)

The default matters. In every one of these regulations, the "serious" category is defined by subtraction: "Except as provided in §D [or §F] of this regulation, all other violations ... shall be considered a serious violation." There is no minor-violation tier.

---

Consequences Differ by Credential

This is where candidates lose points. The most serious label is common; the consequence is not.

COMAR 11.23.02.13C also lets the MVA immediately suspend or revoke a school certification — with notice of the right to a hearing within 7 days of a request — whenever it determines there is a danger of immediate, substantial, and continuing harm to the public, independent of the violation tiers.

---

What Lands in the Top Tier

Seven categories repeat across every list: fraud (or fraud in the operation of providing instruction), a crime of moral turpitude, a sex offense, contributing to the delinquency of a minor, an offense involving a controlled dangerous substance, an offense involving alcohol or drugs while operating a motor vehicle, and a felony involving the use of a motor vehicle. Acting in a manner that is unsafe for students participating in the program appears in every list as well.

The credential-specific additions are the tested ones:

Drivers' school license (11.23.01.11D(9)) — allowing an individual to provide instruction in the operation of a motor vehicle while the instructor license is refused, suspended, or revoked.

Driving instructor license (11.23.01.19D(9)-(11)) — permitting instruction while an instructor's license is refused, suspended, or revoked; failure to maintain a valid driver's license for the class of vehicle taught with no restrictions except corrective lenses or a §16-203 restriction; and providing instruction with more than four active points on the instructor's current driving record.

School certification (11.23.02.13F(9)-(11)) — knowingly providing program courses while the school certification is refused, suspended, or revoked; knowingly issuing a program completion certificate to an individual who did not complete the program; and knowingly allowing an individual to teach the program courses, conduct behind-the-wheel instruction, or test or evaluate students without the required instructor permit or certification.

Those last two are the integrity core of the whole scheme. The state's driver-licensing pipeline depends on completion certifications being true and on instruction being delivered by credentialed people.

---

Immediate Duties After an Adverse Action

A school whose license is suspended or revoked (11.23.01.11H) shall immediately surrender the school's license, stop conducting courses and all school operations, and refund student fees — 100 percent if instruction has not started or the first class was not completed, prorated otherwise. Under §G, the school has the right to a hearing as set forth in Transportation Article, §15-110.

An instructor whose license is suspended or revoked (11.23.01.19G) shall immediately surrender the instructor license badge to the Administration and stop conducting instruction and refrain from any involvement in the program. "Refrain from any involvement" is broader than "stop teaching" — it reaches scheduling, evaluating, and riding along.

Worked scenario

Case. A certified school is short-staffed and lets an apprentice whose six-month permit expired last week finish the final two behind-the-wheel hours for three students, then submits completion certifications for all three.

Analysis. Two most serious violations under COMAR 11.23.02.13F. Knowingly allowing an individual to conduct behind-the-wheel instruction without the required instructor permit or certification is F(11); the permit was cancelled at the expiration of the 6-month period under COMAR 11.23.02.26A(2). Submitting completion certifications for instruction that was not lawfully delivered risks F(10), knowingly issuing a completion certificate to an individual who did not complete the program. Under §D and §E the exposure is immediate suspension on the first and immediate revocation on the second, each with notice of the right to a hearing within 7 days of a request.