8.3 Notes Receivable and Factoring

8.3 Notes Receivable and Factoring

Notes Receivable: Interest-Bearing vs. Non-Interest-Bearing

A note receivable is a formal, written promissory note in which the maker promises to pay a specified principal amount and interest to the payee. Under ASC 310 (Receivables), notes are classified as either interest-bearing or non-interest-bearing.

Interest-Bearing Notes

These notes have a stated interest rate that is paid periodically. If the stated interest rate equals the market interest rate, the note is issued at face value. If they differ, the note is recorded at present value, creating a premium or discount.

Non-Interest-Bearing Notes

Despite the name, these notes carry implicit interest. The face value includes the interest factor, and the note is issued in exchange for cash or property at its present value. The difference between the face value and the present value is recorded in a contra-asset account, Discount on Notes Receivable, and is amortized to Interest Revenue over the term of the note using the Effective Interest Method.

• Effective Interest Formula: $\text{Interest Revenue} = \text{Carrying Value of Note} \times \text{Market Interest Rate}$ $\text{Amortization} = \text{Interest Revenue} - \text{Cash Interest Received (which is } \$0 \text{ for non-interest-bearing notes)}$

Worked Example: Non-Interest-Bearing Note

On January 1, Year 1, Company A accepts a 3-year, non-interest-bearing note of $10,000 from a customer. The market rate of interest for a similar note is 10%. The present value factor for a single sum at 10% for 3 years is 0.7513.

• Present Value (Carrying Value): $\$10,000 \times 0.7513 = \$7,513$
• Discount on Notes Receivable: $\$10,000 - \$7,513 = \$2,487$

Journal Entry at Issuance (January 1, Year 1):

Debit Notes Receivable                          $10,000
  Credit Discount on Notes Receivable                   $2,487
  Credit Sales Revenue / Cash                            $7,513

Journal Entry at End of Year 1 (December 31):

• Interest Revenue: $\$7,513 \times 10\% = \$751.30$
• Amortization entry:

Debit Discount on Notes Receivable              $751.30
  Credit Interest Revenue                               $751.30

• New Carrying Value for Year 2: $\$7,513 + \$751.30 = \$8,264.30$

---

Transfers of Receivables (ASC 860)

To accelerate cash flows or transfer credit risk, companies can transfer their accounts or notes receivable. Under ASC 860 (Transfers and Servicing), the accounting treatment depends on whether the transferor has surrendered control over the receivables.

Control Surrender Criteria (Must meet all three for Sale treatment):

1. Isolation: The transferred assets must be isolated from the transferor (put beyond the reach of the transferor and its creditors, even in bankruptcy).
2. Right to Pledge or Exchange: The transferee (buyer) has the right to pledge or exchange the assets without constraint.
3. No Effective Control: The transferor cannot maintain effective control over the assets (e.g., through an agreement that entitles and obligates the transferor to repurchase them before maturity).

If all three criteria are met, the transaction is treated as a Sale. If any criterion is failed, the transaction is treated as a Secured Borrowing (a loan where receivables serve as collateral).

Pledging, Assigning, and Factoring

1. Pledging: Receivables are used as collateral for a loan. The receivables remain on the balance sheet, and only footnote disclosure is required. No journal entry is made for the receivables themselves.
2. Assigning: Specific receivables are designated as security for a loan. The receivables are often reclassified as "Accounts Receivable Assigned." Cash collections on these receivables are used directly to repay the loan liability.
3. Factoring: The sale of receivables to a financial institution (factor) for fee-based cash.

Factoring Without Recourse

The factor assumes the risk of uncollectibility. The transfer is treated as a sale. The seller removes the receivables, records cash received, records a loss on sale (finance fee), and records a Receivable from Factor (a holdback or retention amount kept by the factor to cover potential sales returns or disputes).

• Journal Entry (Without Recourse):

Debit Cash                                      [Proceeds]
Debit Receivable from Factor                     [Holdback]
Debit Loss on Sale of Receivables               [Finance Fee]
  Credit Accounts Receivable                            [Face Value]

Factoring With Recourse

The seller retains the risk of uncollectibility. If the customer defaults, the seller must reimburse the factor.

• Under ASC 860, if the transfer meets the sale criteria, it is recorded as a sale, but the seller must recognize a Recourse Liability at fair value (representing the estimated cost of bad debts they will have to cover).

• Loss on Sale is increased by the fair value of the recourse liability.

• Journal Entry (With Recourse Treated as Sale):

Debit Cash                                      [Proceeds]
Debit Receivable from Factor                     [Holdback]
Debit Loss on Sale of Receivables               [Finance Fee + Recourse Liability]
  Credit Accounts Receivable                            [Face Value]
  Credit Recourse Liability                             [Fair Value of Recourse]

---

Discounting Notes Receivable

Discounting is the transfer (sale) of a note receivable to a bank before its maturity date. The bank advances cash (proceeds) to the holder after deducting a discount (interest) charge. This requires a five-step mathematical calculation:

Step-by-Step Discounting Calculation:

1. Calculate Maturity Value: Principal plus total interest over the full term of the note. $\text{Maturity Value} = \text{Principal} \times \left(1 + \text{Stated Rate} \times \frac{\text{Total Term}}{360}\right)$
2. Calculate Bank Discount Period: The remaining time from the date of discounting to the note's maturity date. $\text{Discount Period} = \text{Total Term} - \text{Time Note was Held by Seller}$
3. Calculate Bank Discount Charge: Bank's interest charge on the maturity value over the discount period. $\text{Bank Discount} = \text{Maturity Value} \times \text{Bank's Discount Rate} \times \frac{\text{Discount Period}}{360}$
4. Calculate Cash Proceeds: The cash the bank pays the seller. $\text{Proceeds} = \text{Maturity Value} - \text{Bank Discount}$
5. Calculate carrying value at transfer date: Principal plus accrued interest up to the date of discounting. $\text{Carrying Value} = \text{Principal} + \left(\text{Principal} \times \text{Stated Rate} \times \frac{\text{Time Held}}{360}\right)$
6. Calculate Gain or Loss: Compare Cash Proceeds with Carrying Value. $\text{Gain (Loss)} = \text{Cash Proceeds} - \text{Carrying Value}$

Worked Example: Discounting Math

Company X holds a 90-day, 8%, $100,000 note receivable dated June 1. On July 1 (30 days later), Company X discounts the note at a bank at a discount rate of 10%.

1. Maturity Value: $\$100,000 \times \left(1 + 0.08 \times \frac{90}{360}\right) = \$100,000 + \$2,000 = \$102,000$
2. Discount Period: $90 \text{ days total} - 30 \text{ days held} = 60 \text{ days remaining}$
3. Bank Discount: $\$102,000 \times 0.10 \times \frac{60}{360} = \$1,700$
4. Cash Proceeds: $\$102,000 - \$1,700 = \$100,300$
5. Carrying Value at July 1: $\$100,000 \text{ principal} + \left(\$100,000 \times 0.08 \times \frac{30}{360}\right) = \$100,000 + \$667 = \$100,667$
6. Gain or Loss on Discounting: $\$100,300 \text{ proceeds} - \$100,667 \text{ carrying value} = -\$367 \text{ (Loss of } \$367\text{)}$

Journal Entry to Record Discounting (Treated as Sale):

Debit Cash                                      $100,300
Debit Loss on Discounting of Note                   $367
  Credit Notes Receivable                               $100,000
  Credit Interest Revenue                                   $667