10.3 Structural & Induction Icing
Key Takeaways
- Structural icing forms when supercooled liquid water droplets (SLD) freeze upon striking aircraft surfaces between 0°C and -20°C; clear ice forms from large droplets at 0°C to -10°C, rime ice from small droplets at -10°C to -20°C, and mixed ice at -10°C to -15°C.
- Supercooled Large Droplets (SLD)—comprising freezing drizzle (100–500 µm) and freezing rain (>500 µm)—strike and flow aft of protected deice boots and thermal anti-ice surfaces, creating ridge runback ice that induces catastrophic roll upset and uncommanded aileron deflections.
- Ice Contaminated Tailplane Stall (ICTS) occurs when horizontal stabilizer ice reduces the tail's maximum negative lift, triggering sudden uncommanded pitch-down upon flap extension; recovery requires immediate flap retraction and aft control column pressure, the exact opposite of a conventional wing stall recovery.
- High-altitude Engine Core Ice Crystal Icing (ICI) occurs at FL200–FL400 in the vicinity of convective systems at temperatures down to -60°C, where non-visible dry ice crystals melt upon warm compressor components and refreeze on stators, causing compressor stalls, surges, and engine flameouts.
- Under 14 CFR 121.629 (Clean Aircraft Concept), takeoff is prohibited with frost, ice, or snow adhering to critical surfaces; deicing/anti-icing utilizes Type I (unthickened deicing, heated) and Type II/III/IV (thickened pseudoplastic anti-icing) with rigid Holdover Time (HOT) limitations calculated from the start of the final fluid application.
Structural & Induction Icing
Core Airline Transport Principle: Inflight structural icing and engine induction icing represent insidious aerodynamic and propulsion hazards. Ice accretion on critical airfoils degrades maximum lift coefficient ($C_{L\text{max}}$) by up to 30%, increases parasite drag by 100% to 200%, reduces stall angle of attack, and can induce uncommanded roll upset or tailplane stall. Full compliance with the FAA Clean Aircraft Concept (14 CFR 121.629) and mastery of Supercooled Large Droplet (SLD) recognition are essential for ATP airmanship.
1. Physics of Supercooled Water & Structural Ice Types
Liquid water in the atmosphere does not automatically freeze at 0°C. In the absence of microscopic freezing nuclei, water droplets remain liquid in a supercooled state down to temperatures as low as -40°C (the homogeneous freezing threshold). When an aircraft impacts these Supercooled Water Droplets (SLD), the droplet impacts the cold airframe and freezes.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| STRUCTURAL ICING CLASSIFICATION MATRIX |
| |
| Ice Type Temperature Range Droplet Size & LWC Physical Properties |
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Clear 0°C to -10°C Large Droplets Dense, heavy, glossy, |
| (Glaze) High Liquid Water transparent; flows aft|
| Content (LWC) before freezing |
| |
| Rime -10°C to -20°C Small Droplets Milky, opaque, brittle|
| Low Liquid Water freezes instantly with|
| Content (LWC) trapped air bubbles |
| |
| Mixed -10°C to -15°C Varied Droplet Sizes Rough, irregular, hard|
| Intermediate LWC combines clear & rime;|
| forms horn-shaped ribs|
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Clear Ice Mechanics
Clear ice forms when large supercooled droplets strike an airfoil surface. Because the temperature is only slightly below freezing (0°C to -10°C) and the droplet mass is large, the release of latent heat of fusion prevents instantaneous freezing. The liquid film flows aft along the chord before solidifying into a smooth, dense, solid sheet. Clear ice is tenaciously adherent, exceptionally difficult to dislodge with pneumatic boots, and forms jagged horns along leading edges that catastrophically distort the laminar boundary layer.
Rime Ice Mechanics
Rime ice forms in colder ambient temperatures (-10°C to -20°C) from smaller droplets (typical of stratiform clouds). The low droplet mass and sub-zero temperature permit immediate freezing on contact without chordwise runback. Air is trapped between the rapidly freezing droplets, giving rime ice its characteristic porous, white, opaque appearance. While lighter than clear ice, rime accumulation alters the airfoil leading-edge camber, increasing drag and reducing stall margins.
2. Supercooled Large Droplets (SLD) & Roll Upset Mechanics
Supercooled Large Droplets (SLD) represent conditions that exceed standard 14 CFR Part 25 Appendix C icing certification envelopes (regulated under Appendix O):
- Freezing Drizzle (FZDZ): Droplet diameters between 100 and 500 micrometers (µm).
- Freezing Rain (FZRA): Droplet diameters exceeding 500 micrometers (0.5 mm to several mm).
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| SUPERCOOLED LARGE DROPLET (SLD) RUNBACK DYNAMICS |
| |
| AIRFLOW --> [ PROTECTED LEADING EDGE ] [ UNPROTECTED AFT WING SURFACE ] |
| (Pneumatic Boot / Heated) |
| |
| Standard Droplet: Strikes Boot --------> Deiced / Evaporated |
| SLD Droplet: Strikes Boot --------> FLOWS AFT BEYOND BOOT |
| | |
| v |
| [ RIDGE OF ICE FORMS AFT OF BOOT ] |
| | |
| v |
| AIRFLOW SEPARATION OVER AILERON / SPOILER |
| | |
| v |
| UNCOMMANDED AILERON DEFLECTION / ROLL UPSET |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
The Aerodynamic Roll Upset Mechanism
When an aircraft encounters SLD (freezing drizzle/rain), the large drops possess high kinetic momentum. Upon striking the leading edge, they splatter and flow aft past the deice boots or heated thermal slats before freezing, forming an ice ridge on unprotected upper and lower wing surfaces immediately forward of the ailerons:
- As angle of attack increases during maneuvering or approach configuration, airflow separates behind this ice ridge.
- The separated low-pressure vortex creates an asymmetric suction peak over the aileron horn or balance tab.
- The aileron is pulled violently into an uncommanded deflection (control snatch), overwhelming the autopilot servo and exceeding the pilot's manual roll authority.
- Recovery Action: Immediately disconnect autopilot, reduce angle of attack (lower nose), roll wings level with coordinated rudder and aileron, extend flaps cautiously (or return to previous flap setting if roll occurred upon flap deployment), and exit icing conditions immediately.
3. Wing Stall vs. Ice Contaminated Tailplane Stall (ICTS)
Pilots must differentiate between an aerodynamic wing stall and an Ice-Contaminated Tailplane Stall (ICTS), as their recovery procedures are diametrically opposed:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| WING STALL VS. TAILPLANE STALL (ICTS) MATRIX |
| |
| Feature Wing Stall Tailplane Stall (ICTS) |
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Airfoil Location Main Wing Horizontal Stabilizer |
| Aerodynamic Force Loss of upward positive lift Loss of DOWNWARD tail load|
| Typical Trigger High AOA, slow airspeed, Flap extension on approach|
| steep turns, G-load (increases downwash) |
| Onset Symptoms Buffet, stick shaker, mushy Abrupt uncommanded PITCH-|
| roll, decaying airspeed DOWN, lightening stick |
| Elevator Control Normal or heavy backpressure Forward control snatch, |
| Feel required to hold attitude pulsing yoke forward |
| RECOVERY ACTION 1. Lower nose (push forward) 1. PULL BACK on control |
| 2. Roll wings level column (increase AOA) |
| 3. Advance thrust smoothly 2. RETRACT FLAPS to |
| 4. Retract speedbrakes previous setting |
| 3. Reduce thrust if pod- |
| mounted high engines |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
4. High-Altitude Engine Core & Ice Crystal Icing (ICI)
Turbine transport aircraft cruising at high altitudes (FL200 to FL400) face a specialized hazard: Ice Crystal Icing (ICI).
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| HIGH-ALTITUDE ICE CRYSTAL ICING (ICI) |
| |
| * Environmental Setting: FL200–FL400, OAT -10°C to -60°C near convective |
| storms, tropical Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCS), or anvil clouds. |
| * Physical Mechanism: |
| 1. Glaciated cloud contains billions of microscopic, dry ice crystals. |
| 2. Dry crystals do NOT stick to cold exterior surfaces (no airframe ice).|
| 3. Crystals are ingested into turbine engine core. |
| 4. Crystals strike warm internal surfaces (inlet guide vanes, low- |
| pressure compressor stators), absorb heat, and melt into liquid film.|
| 5. Subsequent crystals impact the wet surface, chilling it and building |
| massive ice accumulations inside the warm compressor core. |
| * Operational Manifestations: |
| - Uncommanded thrust rollback / engine power loss |
| - Engine surge / compressor stall (loud bangs, severe vibration) |
| - Total engine flameout in multiple engines |
| - Erroneous Total Air Temperature (TAT) probe readings (probe icing) |
| * Pilot Mitigation: Turn on Engine Anti-Ice (EAI) manually (heats core/ |
| sensors), select continuous ignition, and divert around convective anvils.|
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
5. Ground Deicing / Anti-Icing & Holdover Times (HOT)
Under 14 CFR 121.629 (Clean Aircraft Concept), no pilot may take off in an aircraft that has frost, ice, or snow adhering to any propeller, windshield, stabilizing or control surface, powerplant installation, or wing surface (with strict, limited exceptions for approved cold-soak fuel tank frost allowances under specific OpSpecs).
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| SAE AIRCRAFT DEICING / ANTI-ICING FLUID TYPES |
| |
| Fluid Type Visual Color Viscosity & Rheology Primary Application |
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Type I Orange / Unthickened, Newtonian, Deicing (heats & melts |
| Clear low viscosity; shears accumulated snow/ice); |
| off at low speed (>30 kt)short holdover time |
| |
| Type II Straw / Thickened with polymers, Anti-icing for aircraft|
| Pale Yellow pseudoplastic; shears offwith high rotation |
| during takeoff (>100 kt) speed (VR > 100 kts) |
| |
| Type III Bright Thickened, intermediate Anti-icing for turboprop|
| Yellow shear threshold; shears and regional aircraft |
| cleanly at VR < 100 kts with VR < 100 kts |
| |
| Type IV Emerald Highly thickened, Advanced anti-icing for|
| Green advanced polymers; shearslong taxi times; max |
| cleanly above 100 kts Holdover Time (HOT) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Holdover Time (HOT) Management
Holdover Time (HOT) is the estimated time that an anti-icing fluid will prevent the formation of frost or ice and the accumulation of snow on the protected critical surfaces of an aircraft under specified meteorological conditions.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| HOLDOVER TIME (HOT) RULES |
| |
| 1. TIMING INITIATION: |
| - HOT begins PRECISELY at the START of the FINAL application of fluid |
| (the start of Step 2 in a two-step deice/anti-ice procedure). |
| |
| 2. DETERMINING FACTORS: |
| - Outdoor Ambient Temperature (OAT) |
| - Precipitation type and intensity (e.g., light snow vs freezing rain) |
| - Fluid concentration (e.g., Type IV 100/0, 75/25, or 50/50 mix) |
| - Aircraft skin temperature (cold-soaked wing effect) |
| |
| 3. EXPIRATION PROTOCOL (14 CFR 121.629): |
| - If HOT has NOT expired: Conduct standard Pre-Takeoff Check from |
| flight deck windows prior to takeoff. |
| - If HOT EXPIRES prior to takeoff: Takeoff is prohibited unless an |
| approved physical Pre-Takeoff Contamination Check is conducted from |
| the cabin/exterior within 5 minutes of takeoff, OR the aircraft |
| returns to the deice pad for complete re-treatment. |
| - In FREEZING RAIN or HEAVY SNOW, Type IV HOT is extremely short or |
| undefined -- takeoff is NOT permitted if fluid failure occurs. |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
A turboprop transport aircraft is holding on an extended approach in freezing drizzle (SLD conditions). Upon extending flaps from Flaps 0 to Flaps 15, the flight deck experiences an abrupt, violent nose-down pitching moment and the control column is snatched forward toward the instrument panel. What malfunction has occurred, and what is the proper pilot recovery action?
Which of the following statements correctly differentiates Type I and Type IV aircraft deicing/anti-icing fluids under SAE specifications?
A Boeing 787 cruising at FL380 near a line of tropical oceanic thunderstorms in an ambient temperature of -48°C reports normal pitot heat and zero airframe ice accumulation. Suddenly, both engines experience high vibration, rising EGT, and uncommanded thrust rollback. What meteorological phenomenon is responsible?