5.3 Dispute Resolution: PPRA Complaints, Mediation, Adjudication & Appeals

5.3 Dispute Resolution: PPRA Complaints, Mediation, Adjudication & Appeals

Quick Summary: Disputes in the property sector—commission conflicts between agencies, consumer complaints about non-disclosure, and trust account irregularities—are governed by the structured statutory framework of Chapter 5 of the Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019 (PPA). Complaints are lodged with the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA) under Section 28, may be referred to mediation (Section 29), proceed to adjudication (Section 30) before an independent adjudicator, and can be appealed to the Adjudication Appeal Committee (Section 31). Separate sanctionable conduct proceedings under Section 62 allow the PPRA to discipline practitioners directly. Principal property practitioners must master each stage, its deadlines, and its consequences.

---

1. Lodging a Complaint (Section 28)

Any person—a buyer, seller, tenant, landlord, or another property practitioner—may lodge a complaint against a property practitioner with the PPRA in the prescribed form (Regulation 5 prescribes the complaint form). A well-prepared complaint file includes:

1. The completed prescribed complaint form with the complainant's and respondent's full details.
2. Supporting documents: mandates, deeds of sale or lease agreements, Section 67 mandatory disclosure forms, trust account receipts, and correspondence.
3. A clear statement of the conduct complained of and the relief sought.

The PPRA screens complaints for jurisdiction and merit before deciding on the appropriate channel: compliance enforcement (Sections 24–27), mediation, or adjudication.

---

2. Statutory Mediation (Section 29)

Mediation is the PPRA's primary alternative dispute resolution mechanism.

The Section 29 Process

1. Referral: The PPRA may refer a complaint to mediation if it believes the complaint can be resolved that way, or a party may apply for mediation (Section 29(1)).
2. Mediator Appointment: Within 7 days of referral, the PPRA must appoint a suitably qualified mediator (Section 29(2)).
3. Set-Down: The mediator must notify all parties within 7 days of appointment and set the matter down for mediation within 30 days (Section 29(3)).
4. Informal Facilitation: The mediator assists the parties to resolve the dispute but does not impose a ruling.
5. Certificate of Outcome: Whether the parties settle or the mediation fails, the mediator must issue a certificate stating the outcome and serve a copy on each party (Section 29(4)).

Key Legal Point: A mediated settlement operates as a binding agreement between the parties. The elevated status of an order of a magistrate's court attaches to adjudication orders under Section 30(6)(b)—not to mediation certificates. Property practitioners may also consent to refer inter-practitioner disputes to PPRA mediation on a cost-recovery basis (Section 29(6)).

If mediation has been attempted under Section 29 but has failed, the matter proceeds to adjudication (Section 30(1)(b)).

---

3. Formal Adjudication (Section 30)

Adjudication is triggered where a compliance notice is ignored, mediation has failed, or the serious nature of the complaint warrants it (Section 30(1)).

---

4. Appeals: The Adjudication Appeal Committee (Section 31)

1. Right of Appeal: Any person aggrieved by the adjudicator's decision may appeal to the Adjudication Appeal Committee in the prescribed format (Section 31(1)). Regulation 13.3 requires the notice of appeal to be delivered to the PPRA not later than 30 days after the adjudication decision.
2. Composition: Three independent, suitably qualified persons, established within 14 days of the notice of appeal (Section 31(2)).
3. Hearing: The appeal is set down within 60 days of the Committee's appointment (Section 31(3)).
4. Powers: The Committee may make any appropriate order, which likewise carries the status of a magistrate's court order (Section 31(5)).
5. Judicial Review: A party alleging procedural unfairness, bias, or legal error may seek review in the High Court under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA).

---

5. Sanctionable Conduct Proceedings (Section 62)

Distinct from complaint adjudication, the PPRA can discipline practitioners directly for sanctionable conduct under Section 62(1), which includes:

• Receiving remuneration from multiple parties with conflicting interests in the same transaction without written consent;
• Failing to comply with or contravening the Code of Conduct (Regulation 34);
• Failing to pay monies due to the PPRA or the Fund within one month;
• Committing an offence involving an element of dishonesty;
• Unfairly discriminating against consumers on prohibited constitutional grounds; or
• Failing to comply with any provision of the PPA.

After applying the PAJA fairness requirements, the PPRA may (Section 62(3)):

1. Withdraw the practitioner's Fidelity Fund Certificate;
2. Impose a fine (capped at the amount determined by the Minister of Justice for the Magistrates' Courts Act); or
3. Reprimand the practitioner and note the transgression on the PPRA website.

Payment of a fine or withdrawal of an FFC may be suspended for up to three years on conditions the PPRA determines. A criminal acquittal or conviction does not bar misconduct proceedings on the same facts (Section 62(4)).

---

6. Private Commercial Arbitration

For commercial disputes between property enterprises—franchise territorial conflicts, co-broking commission splits, or partnership breakups—parties frequently choose private arbitration under the Arbitration Act 42 of 1965 instead of administrative PPRA processes.

---

7. Principal's Dispute Management Checklist

• Step 1: Log every complaint within 24 hours in the enterprise compliance register.
• Step 2: Audit the transaction file: mandate, Section 67 disclosure, CRM communications, trust receipts.
• Step 3: Attempt direct informal resolution with the client within 7 days.
• Step 4: Prepare a formal response file for any PPRA mediation or adjudication notice, observing prescribed deadlines.
• Step 5: Notify Professional Indemnity insurers immediately if financial negligence is alleged.