8.5 The Three-Part Workers' Compensation Policy, Other States Coverage & the Subsequent Injury Fund

8.5 The Three-Part Workers' Compensation Policy, Other States Coverage & the Subsequent Injury Fund

Quick Reference: The policy an employer actually buys is a Workers' Compensation and Employers Liability Policy, and it has three parts. Part One — Workers' Compensation pays the benefits the Texas Workers' Compensation Act requires, with no dollar limit. Part Two — Employers Liability pays the employer's legal liability for work-related bodily injury that the compensation bargain does not resolve, and it does carry limits. Part Three — Other States Insurance extends Part One and Part Two to states listed in the information page. Behind all of it sits the Subsequent Injury Fund (SIF), a state account created by Texas Labor Code § 403.006 that shares lifetime income benefits with carriers and reimburses certain overpayments.

---

1. The Anatomy of the Policy

Part One — Workers' Compensation

The insurer promises to pay promptly when due the benefits required of the insured by the workers' compensation law. Three features distinguish it from every other coverage part in this guide:

• No policy limit. The obligation is measured by the statute, not by a declared amount. Lifetime medical on a catastrophic Texas claim is an uncapped promise.
• No deductible in the ordinary sense. Large accounts may use deductible programs, but the injured worker is always paid in full and the employer reimburses the carrier.
• Direct obligation to the worker. The employee's right to benefits does not depend on the employer's solvency or cooperation.

Part Two — Employers Liability

Part Two answers the question the exclusive remedy doctrine leaves open: what happens when someone brings a work-injury-related tort claim against the employer that is not a claim for statutory benefits? It applies to bodily injury by accident or by disease arising out of and in the course of employment, and it carries three limits:

The gap claims Part Two is built for:

1. Third-party-over actions. An injured worker sues a machine manufacturer; the manufacturer impleads the employer for negligent maintenance or failure to train. The employee could not sue the employer, but the manufacturer can, and Part Two defends and indemnifies.
2. Consequential bodily injury. A spouse's loss of consortium claim, or a claim by a child or parent, flowing from the worker's injury.
3. Dual capacity. The employer is sued in a different legal capacity — as the manufacturer of the product that injured its own employee, or as the landowner.
4. Liability assumed under a sidetrack agreement — the classic railroad spur indemnity.

Part Two exclusions that reliably appear on exams: liability assumed under any other contract; punitive damages awarded because of the employment of a person in violation of law; bodily injury to a person knowingly employed in violation of law; damages arising out of discrimination, termination, coercion, or harassment; fines or penalties for violation of federal or state law; and obligations under workers' compensation, disability, or unemployment compensation law (those belong to Part One).

Texas Wrinkle — Exemplary Damages. Texas Labor Code § 408.001(b) preserves a surviving spouse's or heir's right to sue a subscribing employer for exemplary damages where the death was caused by an intentional act or gross negligence. Because Part Two excludes punitive damages in certain circumstances and many policies restrict them, the gross-negligence death case is a recurring coverage-dispute pattern in Texas and should be reported to the carrier's coverage counsel immediately.

Part Three — Other States Insurance

Part Three extends Part One and Part Two to states listed in Item 3.C of the information page. Three rules govern it:

• If the insured begins work in a state listed in 3.C, the policy applies there as though that state were shown in Item 3.A.
• If the insured begins work in a state that is not listed, the insured must notify the insurer at once; coverage does not attach retroactively to a claim that has already happened.
• Monopolistic state fund states can never be listed. Employers operating in North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, and Wyoming must buy coverage from the state fund itself, and the private policy provides only employers liability (through a stop-gap endorsement) in those jurisdictions.

Extraterritorial coverage. Texas Labor Code Subchapter D of Chapter 406 addresses employees hired in Texas who are temporarily injured out of state, and the reciprocal treatment of out-of-state workers temporarily in Texas. The practical rule for an adjuster: when a Texas-domiciled employee is hurt in another state, determine where the employment relationship was created, how long the out-of-state assignment was intended to last, and whether Item 3.C lists that state, before telling anyone which state's benefit schedule applies.

2. The Subsequent Injury Fund

The SIF exists to solve an old and genuine problem. If an employer became liable for the full consequences of a catastrophic combined disability whenever a new injury interacted with an old one, no employer would knowingly hire a worker who already had an impairment. The SIF removes that disincentive by making the state, not the carrier, pay the incremental cost.

Statutory Architecture

Texas Labor Code § 403.006 makes the SIF a dedicated account in the general revenue fund, appropriable only for the purposes of that section or as otherwise provided by law, and directs the commissioner to appoint an administrator for the fund.

Section 403.006(b) makes the fund liable for four things:

1. Payment of compensation under § 408.162 — the subsequent-injury lifetime income benefit split;
2. Reimbursement of carrier overpayments made under an interlocutory order or decision of the commissioner that is later reversed or modified;
3. Reimbursement of carrier claims under § 408.042 (average weekly wage for an employee with multiple employment) and § 413.0141 (payment for health care later determined not to be the carrier's liability); and
4. Reimbursement of a carrier under § 408.0041(f-1) in connection with designated doctor examinations.

Section 403.006(d) allows the commissioner to make partial payment of category (3) claims based on an actuarial assessment of available funding — a real-world limitation an adjuster requesting reimbursement should expect.

The § 408.162 Split — How Lifetime Income Benefits Are Shared

Texas Labor Code § 408.162 states the rule in two sentences:

• (a) If a subsequent compensable injury, with the effects of a previous injury, results in a condition for which the employee is entitled to lifetime income benefits, the insurance carrier is liable for benefits for the subsequent injury only to the extent the subsequent injury would have entitled the employee to benefits had the previous injury not existed.
• (b) The Subsequent Injury Fund compensates the employee for the remainder of the lifetime income benefits to which the employee is entitled.

SECTION 408.162 WORKED EXAMPLE

A Beaumont refinery worker lost his LEFT hand at the wrist in a 2011
accident. In 2026 a compensable press injury takes his RIGHT hand at
the wrist.

Texas Labor Code Sec. 408.161(a)(3) makes "loss of both hands at or
above the wrist" a lifetime income benefit condition. The employee is
now entitled to LIBs.

  What the 2026 carrier owes ...... ONLY what the loss of the right hand
                                    alone would have required, had the
                                    2011 injury never existed
  What the SIF owes ............... the REMAINDER of the lifetime income
                                    benefits the employee is entitled to

Result: the worker is made whole under the statute, and the 2026 employer
and carrier are not charged with the consequences of a disability that
predated the employment relationship.

How the SIF Is Funded — The 364-Week Death Benefit Rule

Texas Labor Code § 403.007 supplies the fund's principal revenue. If a compensable death occurs and no legal beneficiary survives, or a claim for death benefits is not timely made, the insurance carrier must pay to the division's subsequent injury fund an amount equal to 364 weeks of death benefits.

The implementing rule, 28 TAC § 132.10, fills in the mechanics an adjuster actually executes:

• The carrier pays the SIF without an order from the division once its investigation confirms there are no legal beneficiaries, and the payment must be accompanied by the Employer's First Report of Injury and the Wage Statement.
• If benefits were paid to legal beneficiaries who later cease to be eligible before a full 364 weeks has been paid, the carrier pays the remainder of the 364 weeks to the SIF, computed by subtracting amounts already paid (including any remarriage payment).
• If no claim is filed on or before the first anniversary of the employee's death and the investigation confirms no legal beneficiaries, it is presumed for purposes of § 403.007 that no legal beneficiary survived. That presumption does not apply against a minor beneficiary, or an incompetent beneficiary for whom no guardian has been appointed.
• The SIF may enter any fatality dispute as a party, because it is a potential beneficiary.

Adjuster Practice Point: A fatality with no apparent beneficiary is not a closed file. It is a 364-week payment obligation to the State of Texas, triggered without any order, and it must be reserved as such from the outset. Failing to identify this obligation is one of the more expensive reserve errors available on a Texas workers' compensation desk.

---

3. Subrogation Against the Responsible Third Party

Where a third party is liable for the compensable injury, Texas Labor Code § 417.001 lets the carrier recover the benefits it paid out of the employee's third-party recovery, and § 417.002 gives the carrier a first money right to reimbursement from that recovery. The relationship runs in one direction the exam tests: the injured worker keeps the recovery in excess of the carrier's subrogation interest, and the carrier's future benefit obligation is credited against the excess.

THE TEXAS WORK-INJURY COVERAGE MAP

Statutory benefits to the injured worker ............ PART ONE
Machine maker's third-party-over claim against
   the employer .................................... PART TWO
Spouse's loss of consortium claim .................. PART TWO
Employee injured on a temporary assignment in a
   state listed in Item 3.C ........................ PART THREE
Employee injured in Ohio, North Dakota, Washington,
   or Wyoming ...................................... STATE FUND + stop-gap
                                                     employers liability
Old injury + new injury = lifetime income benefits .. CARRIER pays the
                                                     subsequent-injury share;
                                                     SIF pays the remainder
Compensable death, no legal beneficiary ............ CARRIER pays 364 weeks
                                                     of death benefits to SIF
Third party caused the injury ...................... Carrier SUBROGATION
                                                     under Sec. 417.001-.002