7.4 Professional Adjuster Ethics & Fraud Prevention

7.4 Professional Adjuster Ethics & Fraud Prevention

Professional ethics and insurance fraud prevention form the regulatory cornerstone of claims adjusting. Adjusters hold a position of public trust, managing millions of dollars in claims while balancing contractual obligations and public protection. Adhering to the claims adjuster Code of Ethics, preventing conflicts of interest, respecting claimant legal representation, maintaining privacy compliance, recognizing fraud red flags, and fulfilling mandatory reporting duties under South Carolina law are essential requirements for every licensed insurance professional.

---

Code of Ethics for Insurance Adjusters

A licensed insurance adjuster operates under a statutory and professional Code of Ethics designed to preserve integrity and fairness throughout the claims process.

Fundamental Ethical Duties

• Duty of Utmost Honesty & Integrity: Adjusters must make truthful statements in all communications with policyholders, claimants, contractors, attorneys, and state insurance regulators. Deceptive statements or intentional omissions are grounds for license revocation.
• Impartiality & Objectivity: Adjusters must evaluate claims objectively based on facts, policy language, and evidence, without bias toward the policyholder or financial bias in favor of the insurance carrier.
• Prompt & Equitable Settlement: Adjusters must strive to achieve prompt, fair, and equitable settlements for valid claims, avoiding intentional delays, onerous documentation burdens, or low-ball settlement tactics.

---

Conflicts of Interest & Prohibited Practices

Maintaining ethical integrity requires adjusters to avoid all situations that create real or perceived conflicts of interest.

Prohibited Financial Interests & Kickbacks

• Vendor Kickbacks & Referral Fees: Adjusters are strictly prohibited from receiving financial compensation, kickbacks, referral fees, gifts, or gratuities from repair contractors, auto body shops, restoration companies, public adjusters, or salvage buyers in exchange for steering business.
• Financial Self-Interest in Repairs: An adjuster cannot have a direct or indirect financial interest in any repair firm, contractor business, or salvage enterprise performing work on a claim assigned to that adjuster.
• Freedom of Choice in Repairs: South Carolina law protects the consumer's right to choose their preferred repair facility. Adjusters may recommend qualified preferred repair vendors, but they are strictly prohibited from coercing, forcing, or steering an insured or claimant to use a specific repair shop against their wishes.

Protocols for Represented vs. Unrepresented Claimants

• Handling Unrepresented Claimants: When negotiating with unrepresented claimants, adjusters must act with fairness and transparency. Adjusters must clearly explain policy coverages and settlement calculations. However, adjusters are strictly prohibited from offering legal advice or actively discouraging a claimant from seeking legal counsel.
• Handling Represented Claimants: Once an adjuster receives formal notice (oral or written) that a claimant is represented by an attorney, the adjuster must immediately cease all direct contact and negotiation with the claimant. All subsequent inquiries, documents, and settlement offers must be directed exclusively to the claimant's legal counsel, unless the attorney provides explicit permission for direct communication.

---

Confidentiality & Privacy Regulations

Adjusters handle highly sensitive personal, financial, and medical data, imposing strict confidentiality duties under state and federal law.

Non-Public Personal Information (GLBA)

Under the federal Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) and South Carolina privacy statutes, adjusters must protect non-public personal financial information (NPI)—including Social Security numbers, bank account details, and credit records. Information must be encrypted in transit and stored securely, and cannot be disclosed to third parties without consent, except as required for claims administration or law enforcement.

Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)

In bodily injury claims, adjusters receive confidential medical records, diagnostic scans, and physician notes. Adjusters must comply with HIPAA privacy standards by securing signed Medical Authorization Releases from claimants before requesting records, restricting access strictly to personnel handling the claim, and excluding medical history unrelated to the claimed injury.

---

Insurance Fraud Detection & Red Flags

Insurance fraud inflicts billions of dollars in annual losses across the insurance industry, driving up premium rates for policyholders. Adjusters serve as the primary line of defense against fraudulent schemes.

Categorizing Fraud: Soft Fraud vs. Hard Fraud

• Soft Fraud (Opportunistic Fraud): Occurs when an individual opportunistically exaggerates or inflates a legitimate, accidental claim. Examples include inflating personal property values on a contents inventory following a legitimate fire, or exaggerating the duration of neck soreness following a real auto collision.
• Hard Fraud (Deliberate Fraud): Occurs when an individual deliberately plans, fabricates, or executes an intentional event to collect insurance money. Examples include arson-for-profit, staged vehicle accidents, paper accidents, or reporting non-existent property as stolen.

Red Flags in Property & Casualty Claims

Red flags are indicators that warrant heightened investigative scrutiny, though they do not constitute definitive proof of fraud on their own:

Arson Indicators & Staged Accidents

• Arson Indicators: Fire scenes exhibiting multiple independent points of origin, presence of liquid accelerants (gasoline/kerosene), burn patterns on floors (pour patterns), disabled smoke detectors, missing major appliances prior to fire, or severe owner financial distress (pending foreclosure).
• Staged Accidents: "Swoop-and-squat" maneuvers (where a vehicle cuts in front of a target vehicle and slams on brakes to cause a rear-end crash), "drive-by" setups, or "paper accidents" (where a crash is entirely fabricated on paper with non-existent vehicles).

---

Mandatory Reporting Under South Carolina Law

South Carolina enforces rigorous statutory mechanisms to investigate and prosecute insurance fraud.

South Carolina Omnibus Insurance Fraud Act (S.C. Code § 38-55-510 et seq.)

The South Carolina Omnibus Insurance Fraud Act establishes insurance fraud as a specific crime and mandates cooperation between the insurance industry and law enforcement.

• Mandatory Reporting Duty: Any insurer or licensed adjuster who has reason to believe that a fraudulent insurance act has been committed, or is about to be committed, MUST report the suspected fraud to the SCDOI Insurance Fraud Division (or the South Carolina Attorney General's Insurance Fraud Division) and provide all relevant claim file documentation.
• Statutory Civil Immunity: To encourage aggressive fraud detection, South Carolina law provides civil immunity to licensed adjusters, insurers, and employees who report suspected insurance fraud in good faith and without malice. An adjuster cannot be sued for libel, slander, or tortious interference for submitting a fraud report to state authorities.
• Criminal & Civil Penalties: Insurance fraud convictions in South Carolina carry severe criminal penalties (felonies punishable by imprisonment and heavy fines), mandatory restitution, and administrative license revocation by the SCDOI Director.