17.3 Solution-Focused, Narrative & Motivational Interviewing
Key Takeaways
SFBT, narrative therapy and MI share a collaborative, resource-oriented stance but are distinct approaches; MI is a guiding style for change conversations.
The miracle question and scaling questions are SFBT's signature techniques, both future-oriented and focused on exceptions rather than root causes.
Narrative therapy's core premise — "the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem" — drives externalizing conversations and re-authoring around unique outcomes.
Miller and Rollnick’s fourth edition describes MI spirit as partnership, acceptance, compassion and empowerment. Evoking is one of its four tasks; OARS summarizes core communication skills.
Adapt the conversation to readiness. MI may support engagement, focus, evoking and collaborative planning at different stages of change.
Why Brief and Motivational Approaches Matter (and Where Item O Fits)
Solution-Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT), narrative therapy, and Motivational Interviewing (MI) round out the theory-based interventions tested in Domain 5. Each approach works collaboratively and can support change without first establishing a distant cause. They use different methods. This section also folds in KSA item O — "help facilitate clients' motivation to make the changes they desire" — because MI is one established approach for supporting client motivation.
Solution-Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT)
Developed by Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg at the Brief Family Therapy Center in Milwaukee, SFBT assumes the client is the expert on their own life, that exceptions to the problem are already occurring (times the problem could have happened but didn't, or was less severe), and that a small, concrete change can ripple outward into larger change. SFBT counselors avoid diagnosing root causes and instead build a detailed, sensory picture of the client's preferred future. Signature techniques:
- The miracle question: "Suppose tonight, while you were asleep, a miracle happened and the problem that brought you here was solved. How would you know? What would be different?" This shifts the conversation from problem analysis to a concrete, actionable description of the desired outcome.
- Scaling questions: "On a scale of 0 to 10, where are you today, and what would it take to move up just one point?" Scaling makes abstract progress measurable and breaks change into a small, achievable next step.
- Exception-finding questions: "Tell me about a recent time when the problem could have happened but didn't." These questions surface the client's own existing competencies.
- Presuppositional (future-oriented) language: SFBT counselors deliberately say "when things improve," not "if things improve," embedding an expectation of change directly into the wording of a question.
Narrative Therapy
Developed by Michael White and David Epston, narrative therapy rests on the premise that "the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem." Rather than treating a diagnosis or symptom as an inherent part of a client's identity, the counselor uses externalizing conversations to name and separate the problem from the person — for example, referring to "the Anger" or "the Worry" as an external force acting on the client rather than a trait the client possesses ("How has the Worry been trying to convince you that you can't handle this?"). The counselor and client then search for unique outcomes (also called "sparkling moments") — times the problem's influence was absent, resisted, or reduced — and use those moments as evidence to re-author a new, preferred story about who the client is, replacing the old "problem-saturated" dominant narrative. Narrative therapists also practice deconstruction: examining how broader cultural or family narratives (about gender, illness, success) shaped the original problem-saturated story in the first place.
Motivational Interviewing (MI)
Developed by William Miller and Stephen Rollnick, originally for substance-use treatment and now used broadly across health behavior change, MI is a directive-yet-client-centered method for resolving ambivalence about change. Its foundation is the spirit of MI. Miller and Rollnick’s fourth edition describes partnership, acceptance, compassion and empowerment (earlier editions used evocation as the fourth spirit element):
| Element | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Partnership | Counselor and client collaborate; the counselor is not the sole expert |
| Acceptance | Unconditional positive regard, accurate empathy, autonomy support, and affirmation of the client's strengths |
| Compassion | Actively promoting the client's welfare, not the counselor's own agenda |
| Empowerment | Help clients recognize and use their strengths while supporting their autonomy |
Counselors deliver MI through the OARS micro-skills: Open-ended questions, Affirmations, Reflective listening, and Summaries. A central MI skill is distinguishing change talk ("I know I need to cut back") from sustain talk ("but I've done this for 30 years and it's part of who I am") — the counselor selectively reflects and reinforces change talk while avoiding the righting reflex, the counselor's natural urge to argue for change directly, which tends to provoke discord and push a client deeper into defending the status quo.
MI illustrates task O: rather than persuading, lecturing, or confronting, the counselor evokes the client's own reasons for change and reflects them back, strengthening the client's internal motivation. MI pairs closely with the Transtheoretical Model (Stages of Change) developed by James Prochaska and Carlo DiClemente: precontemplation (not yet considering change), contemplation (ambivalent, weighing pros and cons), preparation (intending to act soon), action (actively modifying behavior), and maintenance (sustaining the change and preventing relapse). MI can support people at different stages. Its tasks include engaging, focusing, evoking and planning; agree on action steps with the client when they are ready. Mismatching stage and technique — for example, pushing goal-setting homework on a precontemplation-stage client — is a classic exam trap.
Quick-Reference Comparison
| Approach | Founder(s) | Core Assumption | Signature Technique |
|---|---|---|---|
| SFBT | de Shazer; Insoo Kim Berg | Exceptions to the problem already exist; small changes ripple outward | Miracle question, scaling questions |
| Narrative | White; Epston | The person is not the problem; problems are externalized and stories can be re-authored | Externalizing conversations, unique outcomes |
| Motivational Interviewing | Miller; Rollnick | Ambivalence, not lack of insight, blocks change; motivation is evoked, not installed | OARS, distinguishing change talk from sustain talk |
Exam Scenario
A client mandated to counseling after a DUI arrest is guarded and insists, "I don't have a problem — this was a one-time thing." Rather than arguing the point, the counselor reflects what the client said ("You see this as a one-time event") and asks an open-ended question about what the client values in life. This reflects MI’s approach of acknowledging the client’s perspective and evoking their own motivation — appropriate for a client still in the precontemplation or contemplation stage.
Key Takeaways
- SFBT, narrative therapy and MI are distinct collaborative approaches that draw on the client’s perspective and resources.
- The miracle question and scaling questions are SFBT's signature techniques; both are future-oriented and avoid analyzing root causes.
- Narrative therapy's core premise — "the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem" — drives externalizing conversations and the search for unique outcomes to re-author a preferred story.
- In the fourth edition, MI spirit includes partnership, acceptance, compassion and empowerment. Use OARS and the evoking task to draw out motivation.
- Match next steps to the client’s readiness and goals. MI can support collaborative planning as well as exploration of ambivalence.
A client in motivational interviewing says, "I know smoking is bad for me, but I've smoked for 30 years — it's just part of who I am." The second half of that statement is best described as:
Change talk
Sustain talk
An exception
Externalizing
A solution-focused counselor asks, "On a scale of 0 to 10, how confident are you that you can get through tomorrow without an argument with your partner?" This is an example of:
The miracle question
A scaling question
Externalizing the problem
Paradoxical intention
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.