7.3 Assessing Fiscal Sustainability, Solvency & SEA Reporting

4.2 Assessing Fiscal Sustainability, Solvency & SEA Reporting

In public finance, evaluating the fiscal health of a government requires a much deeper analysis than merely verifying that the general fund cash balance is positive on the final day of the fiscal year. Governments possess unique legal attributes—including the power to levy taxes, issue tax-exempt municipal bonds, and enforce regulatory mandates—but they also bear perpetual responsibilities to deliver essential public safety, infrastructure, education, and social welfare services across generations.

Consequently, financial managers, credit rating agencies, legislative bodies, and citizens must evaluate both short-term fiscal compliance and long-term fiscal sustainability. This evaluation integrates traditional financial statement analysis with performance metrics under the Service Efforts and Accomplishments (SEA) reporting framework.

---

Concepts of Fiscal Sustainability and Interperiod Equity

A fundamental distinction in public financial management separates financial position from financial condition:

• Financial Position: A point-in-time, short-term measure of a government's liquid assets and short-term liabilities, as captured on the balance sheet or fund financial statements. It reflects whether the government has sufficient cash and current receivables to satisfy immediate liabilities.
• Financial Condition (Fiscal Sustainability): A broader, dynamic, multi-year evaluation of a government's capacity to maintain its service delivery standards, honor its long-term financial commitments, and withstand macroeconomic downturns or demographic shifts without compromising the well-being of future generations.

Interperiod Equity: The Moral Anchor of Public Finance

As articulated in GASB Concepts Statement No. 1, Objectives of Financial Reporting, the concept of interperiod equity is a significant part of accountability and is fundamental to public financial management. Interperiod equity asserts that:

"Current-year revenues should be sufficient to pay for current-year services, and future-year citizens should not be forced to pay for services previously received by past generations."

When a government finances current operating costs by issuing long-term debt, underfunding pension obligations, or deferring critical capital maintenance on water treatment plants and bridges, it violates interperiod equity. It artificially reduces taxes for current residents while passing the deferred economic bill to future taxpayers who will receive no new service in exchange.

---

The Four Dimensions of Public Sector Solvency

Public finance literature—pioneered by researchers such as Groves, Valente, and Hendrick, and standard across CGFM curricula—evaluates governmental financial condition across four distinct dimensions of solvency:

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                     THE FOUR SOLVENCY TIERS                     │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ 1. Cash Solvency         ► 30-90 Day Liquidity & Cash Runway    │
│ 2. Budgetary Solvency    ► Annual Operating Structural Balance  │
│ 3. Long-Run Solvency     ► Long-Term Debt, Pensions & Net Pos.  │
│ 4. Service-Level Solvency► Capacity to Deliver Quality Services │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

1. Cash Solvency

Cash solvency refers to a government's immediate ability to generate liquidity and cash equivalents to pay current legal obligations as they mature over the next 30 to 90 days (e.g., biweekly payroll, vendor invoices, utility bills, and short-term debt maturities).

• Key Metrics:
  • Quick Ratio / Acid-Test Ratio: $(\text{Cash} + \text{Cash Equivalents} + \text{Short-Term Investments}) / \text{Current Liabilities}$
  • Days of Cash on Hand: $(\text{Unrestricted Cash and Investments} \times 365) / (\text{Total Operating Expenses} - \text{Depreciation})$
  • Cash-to-Expenditure Ratio: Measures the liquidity buffer available relative to total monthly or annual spending.
• Distress Thresholds: Having fewer than 30 to 45 days of operating cash on hand represents severe cash illiquidity, forcing governments to issue Tax Anticipation Notes (TANs) or Revenue Anticipation Notes (RANs) to fund routine payroll.

2. Budgetary Solvency

Budgetary solvency evaluates whether a government can generate sufficient recurring revenues over an entire annual or biennial budget cycle to finance recurring operating expenditures, without resorting to one-time fiscal gimmicks, structural deficits, or depleting unassigned fund balance reserves below policy minimums.

• Structural Balance vs. Gimmicks: A structurally balanced budget pairs recurring revenues (property taxes, sales taxes, regular user fees) with recurring expenditures (salaries, operational maintenance, debt service). Governments facing budgetary insolvency often employ "one-time budget gimmicks" to mask operational deficits:
  • Selling capital assets (e.g., parking meters, public land) to finance general operating payroll.
  • Scooping and tossing debt (refinancing maturing debt to push principal repayments decades into the future).
  • Transferring surplus capital project funds or enterprise fund reserves into the general fund.
  • Delaying the final monthly payroll or vendor disbursement into the subsequent fiscal year.
• Key Metrics:
  • Operating Ratio: $\text{Total Operating Revenues} / \text{Total Operating Expenditures}$ (a ratio $< 1.0$ indicates an operating deficit).
  • Unassigned General Fund Balance as % of Operating Revenues/Expenditures: The Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) recommends that general-purpose governments maintain an unassigned general fund balance of at least two months of regular general fund operating revenues or expenditures (approximately 16.7%).

3. Long-Run Solvency

Long-run solvency assesses a government's structural capacity to pay all long-term debt obligations, capitalized lease commitments, environmental remediation liabilities, and post-employment legacy liabilities (pensions and OPEB) as they become due over future decades.

• Key Metrics:
  • Debt Service Ratio: $\text{Annual Debt Service (Principal + Interest)} / \text{Total General Governmental Operating Revenues}$. Ratios exceeding 15% to 20% indicate dangerous debt crowding that restricts operational flexibility.
  • Direct Debt per Capita & Direct Debt as % of Full Taxable Value: Gauges the legal and economic debt burden placed on the community's tax base relative to statutory debt limits.
  • Net Position Trend: Evaluates whether total net position (Assets + Deferred Outflows minus Liabilities + Deferred Inflows) on the full accrual government-wide Statement of Net Position is expanding or deteriorating over a 5-to-10-year trend line.

4. Service-Level Solvency

Service-level solvency represents a government's ongoing capacity to provide the volume, scope, and quality of essential public services that citizens require and expect (e.g., 24/7 emergency medical response, police patrols, clean potable water, well-paved roadways, public health inspections) without driving tax rates to confiscatory levels that induce private disinvestment.

• A city might appear cash solvent and structurally balanced on paper simply because it canceled street paving for five years, laid off 30% of its police force, and shut down public libraries. While such actions preserve cash solvency, the city has experienced service-level bankruptcy.

---

Solvency Evaluation Framework & Financial Ratios

---

Legacy Liabilities: Post-Employment Benefits Under GASB 67/68 and 74/75

For decades, state and local governments disclosed defined benefit pension and retiree health obligations only in the notes to the financial statements, reporting annual "contributions" rather than the full actuarial liability. To enforce accounting transparency and reflect true long-run solvency, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board enacted landmark standards:

• GASB Statement No. 67 (Plan Reporting) and GASB Statement No. 68 (Employer Accounting for Pensions)
• GASB Statement No. 74 (Plan Reporting) and GASB Statement No. 75 (Employer Accounting for Other Post-Employment Benefits - OPEB)