7.2 Statutory Agency Disclosure & Dual Agency Rules

7.2 Statutory Agency Disclosure & Dual Agency Rules

To prevent consumer confusion regarding whom real estate licensees represent in real estate transactions, the California Legislature enacted the Statutory Agency Disclosure Scheme codified in California Civil Code §2079.13 et seq. Originally applicable primarily to residential transactions, the passage of Senate Bill 1171 expanded the scope of statutory agency disclosure to include commercial real estate transactions and residential leases exceeding one year.

---

1. Statutory Scope and Applicability

The statutory disclosure rules apply to the following covered real property transactions:

• Sale or exchange of 1-4 unit residential real property.
• Leases of 1-4 unit residential property exceeding one (1) year in duration.
• Sale, exchange, or lease (exceeding one year) of commercial real estate (including industrial, retail, office, multi-family 5+ units, and vacant commercial land).

---

2. The Mandatory DEC Process (Disclosure, Election, Confirmation)

Compliance with California agency disclosure law requires real estate licensees to follow a strict sequential three-step procedure known by the acronym DEC:

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                         THE DEC PROCESS                               |
|                                                                       |
|   1. DISCLOSURE   -->  Deliver statutory AD Form prior to execution    |
|   2. ELECTION     -->  Parties select Seller, Buyer, or Dual Agency   |
|   3. CONFIRMATION -->  Confirm agency status in purchase agreement    |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------+

Step 1: Disclosure (D)

Licensees must deliver the statutory form titled "Disclosure Regarding Real Estate Agency Relationships" (commonly referred to as the C.A.R. AD Form) to the client or customer:

• Listing Agent: Must deliver the AD form to the seller prior to entering into the listing agreement.
• Selling (Buyer's) Agent: Must deliver the AD form to the buyer prior to signing an offer or purchase agreement. When presenting an offer to the seller, the selling agent must deliver the AD form to the seller prior to or concurrent with presenting the offer.

The AD form explains the legal duties of a Seller's Agent, a Buyer's Agent, and an Agent Representing Both Buyer and Seller (Dual Agent).

Step 2: Election (E)

After reviewing the AD form, the principal(s) select and elect the type of agency representation they desire for the specific transaction (Seller's Agent, Buyer's Agent, or Dual Agent).

Step 3: Confirmation (C)

The agency relationship chosen by the parties must be formally confirmed in writing under Civil Code §2079.17. This confirmation is embedded directly into the purchase contract (such as Section 2 of the C.A.R. Residential Purchase Agreement) or set forth in a separate Agency Confirmation Form. It explicitly names the listing broker and selling broker and states whether each represents the seller exclusively, the buyer exclusively, or both buyer and seller as a dual agent.

---

3. Dual Agency in California (Civ. Code §2079.16 & §2079.21)

Dual Agency occurs when a real estate broker (or two salespersons licensed under the same broker) acts as an agent for both the buyer and the seller in the same transaction. Dual agency is legally permissible in California, but only under strict statutory conditions:

Required Informed Consent

Under Civil Code §2079.16, acting as a dual agent requires the full, informed written consent of BOTH the buyer and seller. Undisclosed dual agency is illegal under California Business and Professions Code §10176(d). If an agent acts as an undisclosed dual agent:

• The transaction is voidable at the option of either party.
• The broker forfeits all rights to a real estate commission.
• The broker and agent face DRE disciplinary action, including license suspension or revocation.

Statutory Confidentiality Limits for Dual Agents (Civ. Code §2079.21)

Because a dual agent owes fiduciary duties to two parties with opposing financial interests, the law places strict statutory limits on what a dual agent may disclose. Under Civil Code §2079.21, a dual agent CANNOT:

1. Disclose to the buyer that the seller will accept a price less than the listing price, without express written authorization of the seller.
2. Disclose to the seller that the buyer will pay a price greater than the offered price, without express written authorization of the buyer.
3. Disclose confidential financial information, seller or buyer motivation, or negotiating tactics to the opposing party without written consent.

---

4. In-House Sales & Broker-Salesperson Subagency Rules

In California real estate practice, associate licensees (salespersons and broker-associates) derive their authority entirely from their employing broker. In law, salespersons are agents of the broker, and the broker is the agent of the client.

Therefore, in an in-house transaction—where Salesperson A represents the seller and Salesperson B represents the buyer, but both salespersons are licensed under Broker X—the legal agent for both sides is Broker X. This transaction is legally classified as DUAL AGENCY of Broker X.

• Salesperson A and Salesperson B cannot act as exclusive agents for their respective clients because their overarching principal (the broker) represents both sides.
• Both salespersons must comply with dual agency disclosure rules, obtain written consent from both parties, and abide by Civil Code §2079.21 pricing confidentiality restrictions.