5.4 Fractures, Dislocations, Joint Pain, & Musculoskeletal Emergencies
Key Takeaways
- Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency diagnosed clinically by severe pain out of proportion to injury and pain on passive muscle stretch; emergent fasciotomy is mandatory.
- Anterior shoulder dislocation is the most common joint dislocation, presenting with a squared-off shoulder appearance and requiring assessment of axillary nerve sensation (regimental badge area).
- Posterior hip dislocation presents with a shortened, adducted, and internally rotated lower extremity, requiring urgent closed reduction within 6 hours to prevent avascular necrosis.
- Ottawa Ankle Rules determine the need for X-rays based on bone tenderness at the posterior malleoli or inability to bear weight for 4 steps immediately and in the emergency department.
- Septic arthritis requires emergency joint arthrocentesis revealing synovial WBC >50,000/mcL (>75-90% PMNs) followed by immediate IV antibiotics and surgical joint drainage.
Fractures, Dislocations, Joint Pain, & Musculoskeletal Emergencies
Musculoskeletal trauma and acute arthropathies require prompt systematic evaluation to prevent permanent neurological deficit, avascular necrosis, limb loss, or systemic sepsis.
Compartment Syndrome & Open Fractures
Compartment Syndrome
- Pathophysiology: Elevated tissue pressure within a closed fascial compartment exceeds capillary perfusion pressure, leading to muscle and nerve ischemia. Most common sites: Anterior compartment of the lower leg (post-tibia fracture) and volar compartment of the forearm (Supracondylar humerus fracture in children).
- Clinical Presentation (The 6 Ps):
- Pain out of proportion to injury (Earliest and most sensitive physical sign)
- Pain on passive stretch of compartment muscles (Most specific early exam finding)
- Paresthesias (Nerve ischemia in distribution of compartmental nerves, e.g., deep peroneal nerve in anterior leg)
- Pallor (Late sign)
- Paralysis (Late sign indicating irreversible muscle necrosis)
- Pulselessness (Extremely late sign; peripheral pulses often REMAIN PRESENT early!)
- Diagnosis: Primary clinical diagnosis. In unconscious/obtunded patients, measure intracompartmental pressure. Absolute pressure $> 30\text{ mmHg}$ or Delta pressure (Diastolic BP $-$ Compartment pressure) $< 30\text{ mmHg}$ confirms compartment syndrome.
- Management: EMERGENT OPERATIVE FASCIOTOMY (e.g., two-incision 4-compartment leg fasciotomy). Release all tight dressings/casts immediately. Do NOT elevate the limb (elevating reduces arterial perfusion gradient).
Open Fractures (Gustilo-Anderson Classification)
- Gustilo Type I: Clean wound $< 1\text{ cm}$. Low energy. Antibiotics: Cefazolin.
- Gustilo Type II: Wound $> 1\text{ cm}$ without extensive soft tissue damage. Antibiotics: Cefazolin.
- Gustilo Type III: High energy, extensive soft tissue trauma, severe contamination, or open segmental fracture.
- IIIA: Adequate soft tissue bone coverage. Antibiotics: Cefazolin + Gentamicin (add Penicillin G for soil/barnyard contamination).
- IIIB: Extensive soft tissue loss requiring local or free flap coverage.
- IIIC: Open fracture associated with major arterial injury requiring repair.
- Emergency Management: Tetanus prophylaxis, immediate IV antibiotics within 3 hours, sterile saline dressing, splinting, and emergent operative irrigation and debridement within 24 hours.
High-Yield Fractures & Clinical Decision Rules
Scaphoid Fracture
- Mechanism: Fall on an outstretched hand (FOOSH).
- Physical Exam: Tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox and pain with axial loading of the thumb.
- Complication: Avascular necrosis (AVN) of the proximal pole due to retrograde blood supply from the dorsal carpal branch of the radial artery.
- Management: If snuffbox tenderness is present, apply a thumb spica splint even if initial X-rays are completely normal. Repeat X-rays in 10–14 days or obtain an immediate MRI.
Ottawa Decision Rules for Imaging
Validated clinical decision rules with near $100%$ sensitivity designed to eliminate unnecessary radiographs.
| Clinical Rule | Criteria Indicating Need for Radiographs |
|---|---|
| Ottawa Ankle Rules | Ankle series required if pain in malleolar zone AND any of: |
- Bone tenderness along posterior 6 cm of distal lateral malleolus
- Bone tenderness along posterior 6 cm of distal medial malleolus
- Inability to bear weight both immediately after injury and in ED for 4 steps | | Ottawa Foot Rules | Foot series required if pain in midfoot zone AND any of:
- Bone tenderness at the base of the 5th metatarsal
- Bone tenderness at the navicular bone
- Inability to bear weight both immediately after injury and in ED for 4 steps | | Ottawa Knee Rules | Knee series required for acute knee injury patients with ANY of:
- Age $\ge 55$ years
- Isolated tenderness of patella (no other bone tenderness)
- Tenderness at the head of the fibula
- Inability to flex knee to 90 degrees
- Inability to bear weight both immediately and in ED for 4 steps |
Joint Dislocations & Associated Nerve Complications
| Dislocation | Deformity / Clinical Findings | Associated Neurovascular / Structural Risk | Acute Management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anterior Shoulder (95% of shoulder dislocations) | Abducted, externally rotated arm; 'squared-off' shoulder appearance | Axillary nerve injury (loss of sensation over regimental badge area; deltoid weakness); Bankart & Hill-Sachs lesions | Closed reduction (Kocher/Hennepin technique); post-reduction X-ray & neuro exam |
| Posterior Shoulder | Adducted, internally rotated arm; locked in internal rotation | Caused by seizures or electrocution. 'Lightbulb sign' on AP X-ray | Closed reduction; ortho consult |
| Posterior Hip (90% of hip dislocations) | Shortened, adducted, internally rotated lower extremity | Sciatic nerve injury (foot drop); high risk of Avascular Necrosis of femoral head | Urgent closed reduction $< 6\text{ hours}$ under conscious sedation |
| Femoral Neck Fracture (For comparison) | Shortened, ABDUCTED, EXTERNALLY ROTATED lower extremity | Disrupts retinacular vessels leading to AVN of femoral head | Surgical fixation (cannulated screws or hemiarthroplasty) |
| Knee (Tibiofemoral) Dislocation | Gross knee deformity or spontaneous reduction | Popliteal artery disruption (check Ankle-Brachial Index [ABI]; CT angiogram if ABI $< 0.9$); Peroneal nerve injury | Immediate reduction; emergent vascular surgery if arterial injury confirmed |
Acute Monoarthritis: Septic Joint vs. Crystal Arthropathy
An acute, hot, swollen monoarticular joint is a medical emergency until septic arthritis is excluded.
Synovial Fluid Analysis Guidelines
| Classification | Appearance | WBC Count (/\mu L) | % PMNs | Gram Stain / Crystals |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | Clear / Straw | $< 200$ | $< 25%$ | Negative |
| Non-inflammatory (OA, Trauma) | Clear / Yellow | $200\text{--}2,000$ | $< 25%$ | Negative |
| Inflammatory (Gout, Pseudogout, RA) | Turbid / Yellow | $2,000\text{--}50,000$ | $> 50%$ | Gout: Needle-shaped, strongly negative birefringent monosodium urate.<br/>Pseudogout: Rhomboid, weakly positive birefringent CPPD. |
| Septic Arthritis | Opaque / Purulent | $> 50,000$ | $> 75\text{--}90%$ | Positive Gram stain ($50\text{--}75%$); culture positive for Staphylococcus aureus or Neisseria gonorrhoeae. |
- Septic Arthritis Management: Immediate arthrocentesis before antibiotics. Empiric IV Vancomycin (plus Ceftriaxone if Gram-negative or young sexually active adult) AND emergent surgical joint drainage (arthroscopic or open wash-out).
- Pediatric Septic Hip (Kocher Criteria): Non-weight bearing, ESR $> 40\text{ mm/h}$, Fever $> 38.5^\circ\text{C}$, WBC $> 12,000/\mu\text{L}$. Score $\ge 3$ indicates $> 93%$ probability of septic hip; requires urgent ultrasound-guided aspiration and surgical drainage.
A 24-year-old male presents 6 hours following a closed mid-shaft tibia fracture sustained during a soccer match. The leg was immobilized in a plaster cast in the emergency department. He now complains of excruciating, progressive calf pain unrelieved by IV morphine. On physical examination, there is severe pain when the physician passively dorsiflexes his foot. Dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial pulses are palpable. What is the single most appropriate immediate action?
A 21-year-old university student falls onto her outstretched right hand while rollerblading. She complains of right wrist pain. On physical exam, there is localized tenderness within the anatomical snuffbox. Initial 3-view right wrist X-rays show no fracture or dislocation. What is the most appropriate management plan?
A 32-year-old driver is involved in a head-on collision. In the resuscitation bay, his right lower extremity is fixed in a position of flexion, adduction, and internal rotation. He complains of severe hip pain and numbness over the dorsum of his right foot. What is the primary diagnosis and the key associated complication?