Question

An architect in Hulhumalé draws blueprints for a private residence. Due to a careless calculation error in the foundation load specifications, the concrete ground floor buckles two months after construction, cracking walls and causing structural instability. The homeowner sues the architect in negligence. What standard of care will the court apply to determine whether the architect breached their duty of care?

Tort Law

Question · Medium

Question

A patient underwent an elective orthopedic procedure at an island hospital. The operating surgeon failed to administer a standard prophylactic antibiotic regimen required by national surgical protocols. The patient subsequently developed a severe surgical site infection requiring extended hospitalization. Medical experts testify that 95% of patients given prophylactic antibiotics avoid this infection. What test will the court use to establish factual causation?

Tort Law

Question · Medium

Question

A delivery van driver employed by a logistics firm negligently collides with a pedestrian at an intersection in Malé. The pedestrian is hospitalized with a broken ankle. While in the hospital, a rare and unforeseeable structural gas explosion collapses the ceiling of the orthopedic ward, causing the pedestrian to suffer severe burn injuries. The pedestrian sues the van driver for both the ankle fracture and the burn injuries. Is the driver liable for the burn injuries?

Tort Law

Question · Medium

Question

A cargo vessel unloads steel drums containing industrial solvents at a harbor in Thilafushi. Due to the stevedoring company's negligence, a small quantity of solvent spills onto the wooden wharf. While cleaning operations are underway, a welder working on an adjacent barge 50 meters away drops molten slag, which lands on cotton waste soaked in the solvent, igniting a massive fire that destroys a warehouse. The court finds that while fouling of the wharf was foreseeable, combustion of the solvent on water was not reasonably foreseeable to a reasonable person. Under the Wagon Mound rule applied in the Maldives, can the warehouse owner recover for fire damage?

Tort Law

Question · Hard

Question

A motorcyclist rides along Boduthakurufaanu Magu in Malé without fastening his protective helmet. A car driver pulls out from a side road without stopping at a stop sign, striking the motorcycle. The motorcyclist sustains severe head trauma. Medical evidence proves that had the motorcyclist worn and fastened a helmet, his head injury would have been minor. How will the court treat the motorcyclist's failure to wear a helmet?

Tort Law

Question · Easy

Question

A speedboat ferry company employs captains to transport passengers between Malé and Velana International Airport. The company handbook explicitly forbids captains from taking detours or using company vessels for personal errands. While on duty, a captain takes an unsanctioned 15-minute detour to deliver personal groceries to a friend's safari boat, and negligently collides with a fishing vessel during this detour. Can the ferry company be held vicariously liable?

Tort Law

Question · Medium

Question

Security guards at a retail supermarket in Hulhumalé suspect a shopper of shoplifting. Without statutory authority or calling the police, they lock the shopper in an interrogation backroom for two hours. Although the room is equipped with a comfortable sofa and water, the only exit door is locked from the outside. A subsequent search reveals the shopper had not taken anything. Can the shopper bring a claim in tort?

Tort Law

Question · Easy

Question

A commercial bank provides a written credit reference to a trading company concerning the solvency of a prospective client. The bank includes an explicit, prominent disclaimer stating: 'This confidential assessment is provided without legal responsibility on the part of the bank or its officers.' The trading company relies on the reference, extends credit of MVR 2,000,000, and loses the entire sum when the client defaults. Can the company recover from the bank under Hedley Byrne v Heller?

Tort Law

Question · Hard

Question

A defendant is walking on an island street at night when an assailant brandishing an iron pipe attacks him, shouting that he is going to kill him. Believing his life is in imminent peril, the defendant grabs a wooden plank from the ground, strikes the assailant once on the shoulder to disarm him, and escapes to safety. The assailant suffers a bruised collarbone. What defence protects the defendant under the Penal Code?

Criminal Law And Procedure

Question · Easy

Question

Two individuals plan to break into a warehouse in Malé to steal electronics. One individual purchases lock-picking tools and conducts daytime surveillance on the warehouse security cameras. However, before they can approach the building on the scheduled night, police arrest both individuals based on an informant's tip. With what inchoate offence can they be charged under the Penal Code?

Criminal Law And Procedure

Question · Medium

Question

A criminal suspect in police custody initially waives his right to legal counsel in writing. Forty minutes into the police interrogation, the suspect states: 'I changed my mind; I want my lawyer present before I answer any more questions.' The investigating officer insists that because the waiver was signed, questioning must continue, and extracts an admission. Is the admission admissible at trial under the Criminal Procedure Code (Act No. 12/2016)?

Criminal Law And Procedure

Question · Medium

Question

The Ministry of Housing and Infrastructure published a formal gazetted scheme promising that all citizens who submitted valid housing applications by a specified date would be awarded land plots under settled eligibility criteria. An applicant fulfilled all criteria. Before allocations were finalized, the Ministry arbitrarily cancelled this applicant's file while granting plots to identical applicants, citing undocumented discretionary prerogative. Can the applicant challenge this decision?

Constitutional And Administrative Law

Question · Hard

Loading more…