Question

The city council recently enacted a ban on single-use plastic bags. The council claimed the ban would significantly reduce litter in local waterways. However, studies in cities with similar bans show that plastic bag litter in waterways decreased by only 3% while overall litter increased as residents switched to heavier plastic bags that are equally problematic. Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the council's claim?

Logical Reasoning

Question · Medium

Question

Historian: The decline of the Roman Empire cannot be attributed primarily to military overextension. While the empire did maintain a large military, records show that military spending as a proportion of GDP remained relatively stable for two centuries before the fall. Economic disruption caused by currency debasement is a far more plausible primary cause. Which of the following is an assumption required by the historian's argument?

Logical Reasoning

Question · Hard

Question

Geologist: The presence of fossilized marine organisms in rock layers at the summit of a mountain range provides evidence that the region was once covered by a shallow sea. Critics have argued this conclusion is undermined by the possibility that the fossils were transported to the site by ancient traders. However, the fossils are embedded throughout continuous rock strata over hundreds of square kilometers — a distribution pattern inconsistent with human transport. The geologist's response to the critics serves to:

Logical Reasoning

Question · Hard

Question

Psychologist: Fear of failure is more debilitating to academic performance than actual lack of ability. Students who believe they are incapable rarely attempt challenging tasks, while students with strong ability but high fear of failure also underperform. Thus, interventions targeting fear of failure should be prioritized over those targeting skill development. Which of the following, if true, most undermines the psychologist's recommendation?

Logical Reasoning

Question · Hard

Question

Philosopher: A person acts morally only when they act from duty, not from inclination. A philanthropist who enjoys helping others and gives generously is not acting morally — she is merely doing what she likes. True moral worth requires acting from duty even when it is difficult or unpleasant. A student responds: 'But if a doctor saves a patient's life and also happens to enjoy surgery, does that mean the act has no moral worth?' The student's response is best characterized as:

Logical Reasoning

Question · Medium

Question

The following two arguments share which of the following logical structures? Argument 1: Every novel nominated for the Booker Prize this year was written by a first-time author. No first-time author has previously published a novel. Therefore, no novel nominated for the Booker Prize this year was written by someone who has previously published a novel. Argument 2: All employees promoted to manager last quarter had exceeded their sales targets. No employee who exceeded their sales targets received a formal reprimand. Therefore, no employee promoted to manager last quarter received a formal reprimand.

Logical Reasoning

Question · Hard

Question

Scientist A: The rapid decline of bee populations is primarily caused by pesticide exposure. My research shows that colonies near agricultural fields using neonicotinoids have a 40% higher collapse rate. Scientist B: But colonies near agricultural fields are also exposed to habitat fragmentation, pathogen pressure from managed hives, and nutritional stress from monocultures. Your research cannot isolate pesticides as the primary cause. Scientist B's response most directly challenges Scientist A's argument by:

Logical Reasoning

Question · Medium

Question

Policy analyst: The government should not mandate vaccination for all adults. Individual autonomy must be respected, and there is no right to impose medical procedures on competent individuals. Critic: But we mandate many health and safety regulations — seat belt laws, building codes, food safety standards — that restrict individual behavior for the public good. Vaccination mandates are no different. The analyst could most effectively respond by pointing out that:

Logical Reasoning

Question · Medium

Loading more…