The city council recently enacted a ban on single-use plastic bags. The council claimed the ban would significantly reduce litter in local waterways. However, studies in cities with similar bans show that plastic bag litter in waterways decreased by only 3% while overall litter increased as residents switched to heavier plastic bags that are equally problematic. Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the council's claim?
Logical Reasoning
Question · Medium
Contrapositive, darling: a torch song
Short
All professional athletes who compete in contact sports experience some degree of concussion risk. Anyone who experiences concussion risk should undergo regular neurological screening. Therefore, all professional athletes who compete in contact sports should undergo regular neurological screening. The argument above is an example of which of the following reasoning patterns?
Question · Easy
Chapter 1: LSAT Overview, Scoring & Post-2024 Format
1.1 LSAT Exam Format & Logistics
Study guide
Historian: The decline of the Roman Empire cannot be attributed primarily to military overextension. While the empire did maintain a large military, records show that military spending as a proportion of GDP remained relatively stable for two centuries before the fall. Economic disruption caused by currency debasement is a far more plausible primary cause. Which of the following is an assumption required by the historian's argument?
Question · Hard
The new municipal recycling program requires residents to separate recyclables into five distinct categories. City officials project the program will increase recycling rates by 40%. Critics argue the program will actually decrease overall recycling because the complexity will discourage participation. Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the critics' position?
Scientist: Our research team conducted a double-blind study showing that patients who took the new medication experienced a 30% improvement in symptoms compared to those who took a placebo. Some colleagues have questioned whether the improvement is clinically meaningful, but a 30% improvement is substantial by any measure. The scientist's argument is most vulnerable to criticism on which of the following grounds?
No students who failed the prerequisite course are permitted to enroll in Advanced Chemistry. All students enrolled in Advanced Chemistry must submit a lab safety certification. Marcus is enrolled in Advanced Chemistry. Which of the following must be true?
1.2 The Post-2024 Exam Structure
Nutritionist: Vitamin D deficiency is associated with increased rates of depression. Many people in northern latitudes, where sunlight exposure is limited, are deficient in vitamin D. Therefore, supplementing vitamin D in northern populations should reduce rates of depression. Which of the following most accurately describes a flaw in the nutritionist's reasoning?
The principle that individuals should be held responsible only for harms they could reasonably have foreseen supports which of the following judgments? A manufacturer sold a chemical solvent with a warning label for industrial use only. A consumer purchased the solvent, ignored the warning, and used it to clean a kitchen surface, causing a fire. The consumer was injured.
Film critic: Director Alejandro Muñoz's latest film received a standing ovation at its premiere. Studio executives then announced that Muñoz would direct their next three blockbusters. Therefore, studio executives were impressed by the audience's reaction to Muñoz's film. The conclusion drawn above follows logically if which of the following is assumed?
Geologist: The presence of fossilized marine organisms in rock layers at the summit of a mountain range provides evidence that the region was once covered by a shallow sea. Critics have argued this conclusion is undermined by the possibility that the fossils were transported to the site by ancient traders. However, the fossils are embedded throughout continuous rock strata over hundreds of square kilometers — a distribution pattern inconsistent with human transport. The geologist's response to the critics serves to:
1.3 Strategic Time Management & Pacing
Every elected official in the county who voted for the budget increase also voted against the environmental protection bill. Senator Reyes voted against the environmental protection bill. If the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?
Sociologist: Studies consistently show that neighborhoods with more green space have lower crime rates. City planners have proposed adding parks to high-crime neighborhoods to reduce crime. However, high-crime neighborhoods also tend to have lower property values, which limits municipal tax revenue available for park construction. The sociologist's statements, if true, most strongly support which of the following conclusions?
Attorney: My client could not have committed the robbery at 9:00 PM because he was seen at a restaurant across town at 8:45 PM, and it would take at least 25 minutes to drive from the restaurant to the robbery location. The attorney's argument relies on which of the following assumptions?
Psychologist: Fear of failure is more debilitating to academic performance than actual lack of ability. Students who believe they are incapable rarely attempt challenging tasks, while students with strong ability but high fear of failure also underperform. Thus, interventions targeting fear of failure should be prioritized over those targeting skill development. Which of the following, if true, most undermines the psychologist's recommendation?
Chapter 2: Foundations of Formal Logic & Argument Architecture
2.1 Argument Anatomy: Premises, Conclusions & Assumptions
The statement 'If the bridge is closed, then commuters must use the tunnel' is logically equivalent to which of the following?
Editorial: The town of Millbrook has seen a sharp rise in restaurant closures over the past year. The town council has proposed a tax relief program for restaurants. However, the closures are primarily due to a regional decline in foot traffic caused by a major employer relocating out of town. Tax relief will not attract new foot traffic. Which of the following best states the main conclusion of the editorial?
Philosopher: A person acts morally only when they act from duty, not from inclination. A philanthropist who enjoys helping others and gives generously is not acting morally — she is merely doing what she likes. True moral worth requires acting from duty even when it is difficult or unpleasant. A student responds: 'But if a doctor saves a patient's life and also happens to enjoy surgery, does that mean the act has no moral worth?' The student's response is best characterized as:
Researchers found that teenagers who sleep fewer than seven hours per night score on average 15% lower on standardized academic tests than those who sleep eight or more hours. A school district is considering starting school 90 minutes later to allow more sleep time. Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the case for the later start time?
2.2 Conditional Logic & Contrapositives
An economist argues: 'Raising the minimum wage will increase unemployment because employers will hire fewer workers when labor is more expensive.' A labor advocate responds: 'But in states that raised their minimum wage over the past decade, unemployment rates did not increase and often decreased.' The labor advocate's response functions as:
All the paintings in Gallery A are from the 19th century. Some paintings in Gallery A depict industrial landscapes. No paintings that depict industrial landscapes are priced under $10,000. If all the statements above are true, which of the following must be true?
A company's marketing director claims: 'Our new advertising campaign increased sales by 20%. We ran the campaign in March, and March sales were 20% higher than February sales. The campaign worked.' Which of the following, if true, most seriously calls the director's conclusion into question?
Linguist: Languages with tonal distinctions — where pitch changes the meaning of words — develop in regions with warm, humid climates at a higher rate than in cold, dry regions. This suggests that climate influences the phonological features of languages. Which of the following would it be most useful to determine in order to evaluate the linguist's argument?
2.3 Quantifiers & Formal Logic Sets
Activist: 'I support free speech only if it does not incite violence.' Administrator: 'Then you don't really support free speech, since the right to free speech is unconditional.' The administrator's response depends on which of the following assumptions?
The following two arguments share which of the following logical structures? Argument 1: Every novel nominated for the Booker Prize this year was written by a first-time author. No first-time author has previously published a novel. Therefore, no novel nominated for the Booker Prize this year was written by someone who has previously published a novel. Argument 2: All employees promoted to manager last quarter had exceeded their sales targets. No employee who exceeded their sales targets received a formal reprimand. Therefore, no employee promoted to manager last quarter received a formal reprimand.
The following argument is parallel in its reasoning to which of the following? 'The mayor argues we should adopt policy X because cities that adopted X saw crime fall. But those cities also simultaneously increased police staffing, so we cannot conclude X caused the crime reduction.'
Economist: Rent control policies, while intended to keep housing affordable, actually reduce housing supply over time because landlords have less incentive to maintain or expand rental units when returns are capped. Therefore, rent control ultimately harms the people it intends to help. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the economist's conclusion?
Chapter 3: Logical Reasoning — Assumptions & Formal Flaws
3.1 Necessary Assumption Questions
No policy is both effective and free of unintended consequences. Every policy recommended by the committee was deemed effective by the independent review board. Which of the following conclusions is most strongly supported by the statements above?
Educator: Students who graduate from our accelerated high school program consistently outperform their peers on college entrance exams. This proves that the accelerated curriculum is responsible for the improved test performance. The educator's argument is most flawed because it:
Any government that imposes broad surveillance measures on its own citizens without judicial oversight is acting in a manner inconsistent with democratic principles. The government of Verania recently authorized a mass surveillance program that does not require judicial approval for individual monitoring decisions. If the statements above are true, which of the following must be true?
Scientist A: The rapid decline of bee populations is primarily caused by pesticide exposure. My research shows that colonies near agricultural fields using neonicotinoids have a 40% higher collapse rate. Scientist B: But colonies near agricultural fields are also exposed to habitat fragmentation, pathogen pressure from managed hives, and nutritional stress from monocultures. Your research cannot isolate pesticides as the primary cause. Scientist B's response most directly challenges Scientist A's argument by:
3.2 Sufficient Assumption Questions
Legislators should vote for a bill if and only if they have read its full text and believe it is constitutional. Senator Huang voted against the infrastructure bill. Which of the following can be properly inferred from the statements above?
Columnist: Proponents of the four-day workweek claim it improves employee well-being without reducing productivity. But if this were true, profit-maximizing firms would have voluntarily adopted it long ago. Since most firms have not adopted it, the four-day workweek must reduce productivity. Which of the following is an assumption on which the columnist's argument depends?
Medical researcher: Our study found that patients who received treatment A had a 25% lower mortality rate than those who received treatment B. We therefore recommend switching hospital protocols to treatment A. Which of the following questions would be MOST important to answer before accepting the researcher's recommendation?
The city of Portsmith recently installed traffic-calming speed bumps on Riverside Drive. Neighborhood residents report that they feel safer walking in the area. The city engineer concludes that the speed bumps have made the street safer. The reasoning above would be most strengthened by which of the following?
3.3 Structural & Formal Logic Flaws
Whenever a country's central bank raises interest rates, mortgage rates increase within three months. Whenever mortgage rates increase, housing starts decline within six months. Zephyria's central bank raised interest rates in January. Which of the following must be true about Zephyria, based on the statements above?
The fact that a proposed explanation accounts for all known evidence does not mean the explanation is correct. There may be other explanations that also account for all known evidence. The principle above is most directly illustrated by which of the following situations?
Policy analyst: The government should not mandate vaccination for all adults. Individual autonomy must be respected, and there is no right to impose medical procedures on competent individuals. Critic: But we mandate many health and safety regulations — seat belt laws, building codes, food safety standards — that restrict individual behavior for the public good. Vaccination mandates are no different. The analyst could most effectively respond by pointing out that:
Paradox: Studies show that countries with the highest chocolate consumption per capita also have the highest number of Nobel Prize winners per capita. Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain this paradox without concluding that chocolate consumption causes Nobel Prize achievement?
Loading more…