Passage: Throughout the nineteenth century, historians largely treated history as a narrative of great men and pivotal political events. The 'history from above' model emphasized the actions of kings, generals, and statesmen as the primary engines of historical change. By the mid-twentieth century, however, social historians began shifting focus toward the experiences of ordinary people — workers, women, and marginalized communities. This 'history from below' approach drew on demographic data, court records, and oral histories to reconstruct everyday life. Critics of the new social history argued that it fragmented the coherent narrative that gave history its explanatory power, while proponents countered that such narratives had merely disguised whose experiences were deemed worthy of remembering.
The passage implies that proponents of 'history from below' would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
- AOral histories and demographic data are less reliable than official political records.
- BTraditional historical narratives reflected the perspectives of those in power rather tha…
- CThe fragmentation of historical narrative is an unavoidable scholarly problem.
- DSocial history succeeded in replacing political history as the dominant paradigm.