Building Shared Understanding

One of the greatest challenges in project management is ensuring all stakeholders share the same understanding of what the project will deliver, how it will be accomplished, and what success looks like. Misaligned expectations are the root cause of most project conflicts and dissatisfaction.

What is Shared Understanding?

Shared understanding means all parties have the same mental model of:

• Project objectives and success criteria
• Scope boundaries and constraints
• Roles, responsibilities, and decision rights
• How work will be conducted
• What trade-offs are acceptable

Without shared understanding, stakeholders make assumptions that lead to conflict when reality differs from expectations.

---

Managing Expectations

Expectation management is proactive - you shape expectations rather than react to them.

The Expectation Gap

Key Principles

1. Set expectations early - The beginning is when expectations are most malleable
2. Be specific - Vague commitments create vague expectations
3. Document agreements - Written records prevent "I thought you said..."
4. Communicate changes immediately - Early warning prevents surprise
5. Under-promise, over-deliver - Create positive gaps when possible

Common Expectation Areas

---

Consensus Building

Consensus doesn't mean everyone agrees completely - it means reaching a decision all parties can accept and support.

Consensus vs. Other Decision Methods

Building Consensus

1. Define the decision clearly - What exactly are we deciding?
2. Gather input from all parties - Ensure everyone is heard
3. Identify common ground - Start with areas of agreement
4. Address concerns systematically - Don't dismiss objections
5. Generate options - Create alternatives to consider
6. Test for consensus - "Can everyone support this?"
7. Document the agreement - Capture the decision and rationale

When Consensus Fails

If consensus cannot be reached:

• Identify the specific blocking issues
• Escalate with clear options and recommendations
• Accept the escalated decision gracefully
• Commit to the decision once made

---

Handling Conflicts of Expectations

When stakeholders have conflicting expectations, the project manager must navigate carefully:

Sources of Conflict

Resolution Approaches

Best Practice: Confronting/Problem-solving

The PMI generally recommends confronting (also called problem-solving or collaborating) as the preferred approach because it:

• Addresses the root cause of conflict
• Creates lasting solutions
• Strengthens relationships through honest dialogue
• Builds shared understanding

---

Team Agreements

Team agreements (also called working agreements or social contracts) establish how the team will work together.

What Team Agreements Cover

Creating Effective Agreements

1. Involve the whole team - Agreements imposed aren't owned
2. Be specific and actionable - "Respect each other" is too vague
3. Start with few critical agreements - Don't overwhelm
4. Review and update regularly - Adjust as the team matures
5. Hold everyone accountable - Including the PM

Example Team Agreement

• Meetings start on time; latecomers join without disrupting
• All voices are heard before decisions are made
• Disagree during discussion; commit once decided
• Reply to teammate messages within 4 business hours
• No work communications after 7 PM or on weekends
• Definition of Done must be met before moving stories to complete

---

Techniques for Building Shared Understanding

Visual Techniques

Collaborative Techniques

---

Social Contracts in Agile

In Agile environments, social contracts formalize team behaviors:

Elements of an Agile Social Contract

• Values we share - What we believe is important
• Behaviors we expect - How we act toward each other
• Practices we follow - Our working methods
• Consequences for violations - How we handle breaches

Reinforcing Social Contracts

• Reference in retrospectives
• Post visibly in team space
• New team members review and commit
• Revisit when conflicts arise
• Update based on lessons learned

---

Key Takeaways

• Shared understanding prevents conflicts from misaligned expectations
• Manage expectations proactively - set them early and adjust continuously
• Build consensus through systematic dialogue and problem-solving
• Confront conflicts directly rather than avoiding them
• Create team agreements that define how you'll work together
• Use visual and collaborative techniques to align diverse stakeholders