Evaluating & Delivering Benefits

Projects exist to deliver business value. While completing deliverables on time and within budget is important, the true measure of project success is whether the organization realizes the intended benefits. This section covers benefits realization management (BRM)—the discipline of ensuring projects deliver real value.

What Is Benefits Realization Management?

Benefits Realization Management (BRM) is the process of identifying, planning, measuring, and tracking benefits from the start of a project or program investment until the realization of the last projected benefit.

According to PMI research, only about 31% of projects are considered truly successful in delivering their intended outcomes. BRM addresses this gap by focusing not just on outputs (what the project delivers) but on outcomes (the value those deliverables create).

The Benefits Management Lifecycle

---

The Benefits Management Plan

A Benefits Management Plan is a structured document that outlines how benefits will be identified, tracked, and realized. It serves as the roadmap for value delivery.

Key Components

1. Benefits Identification

   • Clear, specific descriptions of expected benefits
   • Alignment with organizational strategy and goals
   • Categorization by type and priority

2. Benefits Ownership

   • Assignment of accountable owners for each benefit
   • Typically business stakeholders, not project team members
   • Responsibilities for tracking and reporting

3. Measurement Criteria

   • Baseline metrics (current state before project)
   • Target metrics (desired future state)
   • Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
   • Data sources and collection methods

4. Realization Timeline

   • When each benefit is expected to materialize
   • Dependencies and prerequisites
   • Milestones for benefit tracking

---

Types of Benefits

Tangible Benefits

Tangible benefits are quantifiable and can be directly measured in financial or numerical terms:

Intangible Benefits

Intangible benefits are qualitative and harder to measure directly, but equally important:

---

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

KPIs are measurable values that demonstrate how effectively a project is achieving its key business objectives. Effective KPIs are:

• Specific — Clearly defined and unambiguous
• Measurable — Quantifiable with available data
• Achievable — Realistic given resources and constraints
• Relevant — Aligned with business objectives
• Time-bound — Associated with specific timeframes

Common Project KPIs

---

Financial Metrics for Value Delivery

Return on Investment (ROI)

ROI measures the profitability of an investment relative to its cost:

ROI = (Net Benefits - Costs) / Costs × 100%

Example: A project costs $500,000 and generates $750,000 in benefits

• ROI = ($750,000 - $500,000) / $500,000 × 100% = 50%

Net Present Value (NPV)

NPV calculates the present value of future cash flows minus the initial investment. A positive NPV indicates the project creates value.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

IRR is the discount rate that makes the NPV of an investment equal to zero. Projects with IRR exceeding the organization's hurdle rate are typically approved.

Payback Period

Payback Period measures how long it takes to recover the initial investment from project benefits.

---

Benefits Tracking and Reporting

Establishing Baselines

Before a project begins, establish baseline measurements for each benefit:

1. Document current state — What are the metrics before the project?
2. Set targets — What improvement is expected?
3. Define variance thresholds — When does variation trigger action?
4. Identify data sources — Where will measurements come from?

Ongoing Monitoring

Benefits Reporting

Effective benefits reports should include:

• Executive summary of benefit status
• Progress against targets for each benefit
• Variance explanations for underperformance
• Forecast updates based on current trends
• Recommendations for improvement actions

---

Benefits Ownership and Transition

During the Project

• Project Manager — Responsible for delivering capabilities that enable benefits
• Project Sponsor — Accountable for overall project success and value
• Business Stakeholders — Future owners of benefit realization

After Project Closure

• Benefits transfer to operational business owners
• Measurement systems must be in place before handoff
• Ongoing tracking becomes a business responsibility
• Post-project reviews assess actual vs. planned benefits

Transition Requirements

1. Clear handoff documentation
2. Trained benefit owners
3. Operational measurement processes
4. Escalation paths for issues
5. Scheduled benefit reviews

---

Common Challenges in Benefits Realization

---

Key Takeaways

• Projects are investments — They must generate returns that justify their costs
• Benefits must be defined early — Clarity on expected value guides all project decisions
• Measurement is essential — What gets measured gets managed
• Ownership must be assigned — Someone must be accountable for each benefit
• Benefits often lag deliverables — Value may not be realized until after project closure
• Continuous tracking enables correction — Regular monitoring allows for course adjustments