Why Worker Classification Matters

Proper worker classification is one of the most important employment tax issues. The classification determines:

• Tax withholding obligations - Employers must withhold federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare from employee wages
• Employment tax liability - Employers pay matching FICA taxes plus FUTA on employee compensation
• Reporting requirements - Employees receive Form W-2; independent contractors receive Form 1099-NEC
• Worker protections - Employees may be entitled to benefits, workers' compensation, and unemployment insurance

Employment Tax Comparison (2024)

Key 2024 Figures:

• Social Security wage base: $168,600
• Maximum Social Security tax (employee or employer): $10,453.20
• FUTA wage base: $7,000 per employee
• Net FUTA rate (after state credit): 0.6% (maximum $42 per employee)

---

IRS Classification Test: The Three Categories

The IRS uses the common law test to determine worker status by examining three categories of evidence:

1. Behavioral Control

Behavioral control examines whether the business has the right to direct and control how the worker performs the job.

Factors indicating EMPLOYEE status:

• Business provides detailed instructions on when, where, and how to work
• Business provides training on methods and procedures
• Worker must perform services in a specific sequence
• Business dictates tools and equipment to use

Factors indicating CONTRACTOR status:

• Worker determines own methods and approach
• Worker uses own judgment in completing tasks
• Minimal or no training provided
• Worker controls when and where to work

2. Financial Control

Financial control examines the business aspects of the worker's relationship.

3. Relationship of the Parties

This category examines how both parties perceive their relationship:

• Written contracts - Though not determinative, contracts may specify the relationship
• Employee benefits - Receiving benefits (insurance, pension, vacation) suggests employment
• Permanency - Indefinite relationships suggest employment; project-based work suggests contractor status
• Services integral to business - Workers performing key business activities are more likely employees
• Discharge/termination - Employees can typically be fired; contractors work per contract terms

Important: No single factor determines classification. The IRS weighs all factors together. The key question is: Does the business have the right to control how the worker performs the services?

---

Common Law Rules (Traditional 20-Factor Test)

While the IRS now emphasizes the three-category approach, the traditional 20-factor test provides additional guidance. Key factors include:

Suggesting Employee Status:

1. Required to comply with instructions
2. Training provided by employer
3. Services integrated into business operations
4. Services rendered personally (cannot subcontract)
5. Employer hires, supervises, and pays assistants
6. Continuing relationship
7. Set hours of work
8. Full-time work required
9. Work performed on employer's premises
10. Services performed in set order or sequence

Suggesting Contractor Status:

1. Working for multiple clients
2. Offering services to the general public
3. Significant investment in equipment
4. Possibility of profit or loss
5. Right to hire own assistants
6. Freedom to determine methods
7. Paid by project, not by time
8. Can work for competitors
9. Can terminate relationship without liability
10. Uses own supplies and materials

---

Form SS-8: Determination of Worker Status

When classification is uncertain, either the worker or the business can file Form SS-8 to request an official IRS determination.

Key Points:

• No fee to file Form SS-8
• IRS acknowledges receipt and assigns the case to a technician
• Processing time: 6 months or longer (often much longer)
• IRS may contact both parties and third parties for information
• Determination applies only to years with open statutes
• IRS maintains a searchable SS-8 database of past determinations

When to File:

• Dispute between worker and business about classification
• Worker believes they were misclassified
• Business wants clarity before establishing a relationship

Filing Address: Internal Revenue Service Form SS-8 Determinations P.O. Box 630, Stop 631 Holtsville, NY 11742-0630

---

Consequences of Misclassification

Misclassifying employees as independent contractors carries significant penalties:

Unintentional Misclassification (IRC Section 3509)

If the employer had no reasonable basis but the misclassification was not intentional:

• 1.5% of wages for income tax withholding
• 20% of employee's share of FICA taxes
• 100% of employer's share of FICA taxes
• $50 penalty per unfiled W-2

Intentional Misclassification

If the employer knew or should have known the worker was an employee:

• 3% of wages for income tax withholding
• 40% of employee's share of FICA taxes
• 100% of employer's share of FICA taxes
• Potential criminal penalties up to $1,000 per worker and imprisonment
• Failure-to-pay penalty: 0.5% per month up to 25%

Additional Consequences

• Interest on unpaid taxes
• Trust fund recovery penalty (Section 6672) - personal liability for responsible persons
• Back wages and benefits owed to workers
• State unemployment insurance liability
• Workers' compensation claims

---

Section 530 Relief (Safe Harbor)

Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 provides relief from retroactive reclassification if employers meet three requirements:

Three Requirements for Section 530 Relief

1. Reporting Consistency - Filed all required Forms 1099 for the workers
2. Substantive Consistency - Never treated the worker (or similar workers) as employees after December 31, 1977
3. Reasonable Basis - Had a reasonable basis for treating workers as contractors

The Three Safe Harbors (Reasonable Basis)

Other Reasonable Bases:

• Advice of a tax professional or attorney
• Favorable state agency determinations
• Reasonable interpretation of common law rules

Important: Section 530 relief only applies to federal employment taxes - it does not affect state taxes or labor law obligations.

---

Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP)

The VCSP allows employers to voluntarily reclassify workers prospectively with limited liability for past misclassification.

VCSP Eligibility Requirements

• Currently treating workers as independent contractors
• Want to prospectively reclassify them as employees
• Filed all required 1099 forms for the past 3 years
• Consistently treated the workers as non-employees
• Not currently under IRS employment tax examination

VCSP Benefits

• Pay only 10% of one year's employment tax liability (under Section 3509 reduced rates)
• No interest or penalties
• No employment tax audit for prior years regarding these workers
• Full compliance going forward

How to Apply

1. File Form 8952 (Application for VCSP)
2. File at least 120 days before the desired reclassification date
3. Do not include payment with the application
4. Attach list of workers with names and Social Security numbers
5. Sign and submit - IRS will send a closing agreement
6. Pay the settlement amount with the signed closing agreement