Broker-Dealer Exemptions and Exclusions
Not all persons who might appear to be broker-dealers are required to register. The Uniform Securities Act provides specific exclusions (not meeting the definition) and exemptions (meeting the definition but released from registration). Understanding these distinctions is critical for the Series 63 exam.
Persons Excluded from Broker-Dealer Definition
The following are excluded from the broker-dealer definition entirely:
| Exclusion | Reasoning |
|---|---|
| Agents | Individuals who represent broker-dealers (separate registration category) |
| Issuers | Entities selling their own securities (not in the business of selling for others) |
| Banks | Federally regulated financial institutions |
| Savings Institutions | Thrifts and credit unions |
| Trust Companies | Separately regulated fiduciaries |
Key Distinction: Banks are excluded from the broker-dealer definition, but bank holding companies are NOT excluded. A bank holding company that engages in broker-dealer activities must register.
Banks vs. Bank Holding Companies
| Entity | Excluded from BD Definition? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Bank | Yes | Federally regulated by banking authorities |
| Bank Holding Company | No | Not a bank itself; may need to register |
| Bank Subsidiary (BD) | No | Separate legal entity from the bank |
No Place of Business Exemption
A broker-dealer with no place of business in a state may be exempt from registration if they only transact with certain parties:
Exempt Transactions (No Office in State)
| Transaction Partner | Registration Required? |
|---|---|
| Other broker-dealers | No |
| Institutional investors (banks, insurance companies, investment companies) | No |
| Issuers of securities involved in the transaction | No |
| Existing customers temporarily in the state | No |
| Retail customers residing in the state | Yes |
Exam Tip: The key phrase is "no place of business in the state." If the broker-dealer has ANY office, branch, or place of business in the state, this exemption does not apply.
What Constitutes a "Place of Business"?
| Is a Place of Business | Is NOT a Place of Business |
|---|---|
| Office or branch location | Post office box |
| Location where agents work | Telephone answering service |
| Any location open to the public | Agent's personal residence (usually) |
Institutional Investors Defined
For the no-place-of-business exemption, institutional investors include:
| Institution Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Banks and Trust Companies | Commercial banks, trust departments |
| Savings Institutions | Savings banks, credit unions |
| Insurance Companies | Life, property, casualty insurers |
| Investment Companies | Mutual funds, closed-end funds |
| Pension/Profit-Sharing Trusts | ERISA-qualified plans |
| Other Institutional Buyers | Entities with $1 million+ in investments |
Canadian Broker-Dealers
The USA provides a limited registration option for Canadian broker-dealers:
Requirements for Canadian BD Limited Registration
| Requirement | Description |
|---|---|
| Residence | Must be resident in Canada |
| No U.S. Office | Cannot have an office or physical presence in the state |
| Clients | May only transact with Canadian citizens temporarily in the state |
| Registration | Must file for limited registration with the Administrator |
Note: Canadian broker-dealers with limited registration can only serve their existing Canadian clients who happen to be visiting or temporarily residing in the state—not U.S. residents.
Existing Customer Exception
A broker-dealer with no place of business in a state may transact with an existing customer who is temporarily in the state without registering, provided:
| Condition | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Pre-existing Relationship | Customer relationship existed before the customer entered the state |
| Temporary Presence | Customer is not a permanent resident of the state |
| No Solicitation | BD did not solicit the customer while in the state |
Example Scenario
A New York broker-dealer has a customer who normally resides in New York. The customer vacations in Florida for two weeks. The broker-dealer can execute trades for this customer without registering in Florida because:
- The customer relationship pre-existed
- The customer is only temporarily in Florida
- The BD has no Florida office
Summary: Registration Decision Tree
When determining if a broker-dealer must register in a state:
-
Do they have a place of business in the state?
- Yes → Must register (no exceptions)
- No → Continue to step 2
-
Who do they transact with in the state?
- Only other BDs, institutions, or issuers → No registration required
- Only existing customers temporarily in state → No registration required
- Any retail customers residing in state → Must register
Key Takeaways
- Banks are excluded from the BD definition; bank holding companies are NOT
- No-place-of-business exemption only applies when dealing with institutions, other BDs, or issuers
- Existing customers temporarily in the state can be served without registration
- Canadian BDs may obtain limited registration to serve Canadian citizens in the state
- The exemption disappears if the BD has ANY place of business in the state
Which of the following is EXCLUDED from the definition of "broker-dealer" under the USA?
A broker-dealer headquartered in State A has no office in State B. Under what circumstances can this BD transact business in State B WITHOUT registering?
A Canadian broker-dealer wants to serve its Canadian clients who are vacationing in the United States. Under the USA, this broker-dealer:
2.3 Agent Registration
Continue learning