Moral Hazard

Moral hazard is an increased risk of loss due to dishonesty or character defects of the insured, such as intentionally causing damage to collect insurance proceeds or filing fraudulent claims.

Get personalized explanations

🎬 Video Explanation

Checking video availability…
💡

Exam Tip

In producer-exam terminology, moral hazard = dishonesty/fraud; morale hazard = carelessness or indifference without fraud. Economics may use moral hazard more broadly. Both can increase risk.

What is Moral Hazard?

Moral hazard refers to the increased probability or severity of loss arising from the dishonesty, poor character, or fraudulent intent of an insured person. In the usual producer-exam distinction, moral hazard concerns dishonesty or fraud, while morale hazard concerns indifference to loss. Economics texts often use moral hazard more broadly for behavior changed by insurance, including reduced precautions; identify which usage a question tests.

Moral Hazard vs. Morale Hazard

AspectMoral HazardMorale Hazard
IntentDishonesty or intent to defraudCarelessness without intent to defraud
MotivationDishonesty, fraudIndifference, complacency
CharacterReflects on integrityReflects on attitude
ExampleArson for insurance moneyLeaving doors unlocked
ActionActive wrongdoingPassive negligence

Dishonesty Versus Reduced Precautions

TypeDescriptionExample
Deliberate lossInsurance-exam moral hazardSetting a fire to collect a claim
False claimInsurance-exam moral hazardInventing stolen property or inflating damage
Reduced precautionsUsually morale hazard in producer-exam terminologyIgnoring a known hazard because insurance will pay
Broader economics usageIncludes reduced precautions and insurance-driven service useThis usage does not make every extra medical service fraudulent

Examples of Moral Hazard in Insurance

Insurance TypeMoral Hazard Example
PropertyArson to collect on unprofitable business
AutoStaging accidents for injury claims
HealthKnowingly billing for treatment never provided
LifeCausing an insured person's death to obtain policy proceeds
DisabilityFeigning injury to collect benefits
Workers' CompFaking workplace injuries

Effects of Insurance Fraud

CategoryImpact
Claims costsFraudulent payments add to insurer costs
Premium impactIncreases premiums for honest policyholders
Detection focusSpecial Investigation Units (SIU)
Legal consequencesPossible prosecution and coverage remedies under applicable law

How Insurers Detect Moral Hazard

MethodDescription
UnderwritingReview relevant application information and loss history as law permits
Claims investigationDetailed review of suspicious claims
SIU (Special Investigation Unit)Dedicated fraud detection teams
Database analysisCross-referencing multiple claims
InterviewsRecorded statements, inconsistency detection

How Insurers Combat Moral Hazard

StrategyApplication
Thorough underwritingEvaluate applicant character and history
DeductiblesInsured shares in loss
Cost sharingDeductibles or applicable coinsurance give insureds a financial stake in losses
Policy limitsCap potential gain from fraud
ExclusionsApply intentional-loss exclusions as written and permitted by law
Claims investigationVerify legitimate losses

Underwriting Red Flags

Red FlagConcern
Prior claims historyPattern of suspicious claims
Financial difficultiesMay prompt further inquiry; financial stress is not proof of fraud
Criminal historyPast dishonest behavior
Over-insurancePossible incentive for a dishonest claim; investigate valuation
Recent coverage increaseSuspiciously timed changes

Policy Provisions Against Moral Hazard

ProvisionPurpose
Intentional-loss exclusionMay exclude loss deliberately caused by an insured; wording and law control
Concealment or fraud conditionSpecifies remedies for material concealment or fraud
Claim dutiesRequire truthful information and cooperation with investigation
Indemnity principleProperty coverage compensates covered loss rather than creating a profit

Consequences of Moral Hazard

ConsequenceImpact
Policy cancellationLoss of coverage
Claim denialNo payment received
Criminal prosecutionFines and imprisonment
Civil liabilityDamages and restitution
Future underwritingProven fraud or loss history may affect eligibility under applicable law

Exam Alert

Moral hazard = DISHONESTY or character defects that increase risk. Involves INTENTIONAL wrongdoing (fraud, arson). Different from morale hazard which is CARELESSNESS due to having insurance. Insurers use lawful underwriting, appropriate cost sharing, policy conditions and claims investigation. A suspicious circumstance alone does not establish fraud.

Source: NAIC insurance terminology and the broader economics usage, pp. 11-12 and glossary.

Study This Term In

Related Terms

Where shall we go next?

Your AI study companion · 10 free interactions a day

Stay Updated

Get free exam tips and study guides delivered to your inbox.

Free exam tips & study guides. Unsubscribe anytime.